12 recorded contributions
Jev-reviewed existing detailed tags · editorial review required
Accepted detailed tags: Planning
Last week I asked about Sea to Sky regional transit, the most important issue in West Vancouver–Sea to Sky, and the minister said he agrees with the importance of transit along the Sea to
Sky corridor. I can tell you, there are 50,000 residents that are glad he put that
on the record. Even in a fiscal bind, this government added public transit funding to this year's
budget, showing some leadership, to their credit, and reflecting the importance of
this service that returns money to the economy roughly 4 to 1 for every dollar invested.
Setting aside the contributions of Squamish and Pemberton, the resort municipality
of Whistler alone attracts over 3 million annual visitors, generating $1.5 billion
in spending, roughly one quarter of B.C.'s tourism export revenue, $1.4 million per
day in tax revenue. The problem is businesses are looking at setting up in Whistler and saying: "We can't
move forward. All our staff would need their own personal vehicles." Especially in
the hospitality business, this isn't feasible or practical. The minister last week said it's too early to order buses, but after 16 months, he
hasn't even instructed B.C. Transit to start planning for this service he recognizes
is important. Local governments and First Nations have taken this as far as they can
on their own and have made a number of concessions to get this done.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Public access, Public administration
I am deeply gratified and very excited to be here to speak to the motion to delay
Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026. I'd like to start by saying that I, of course, fully support all the comments made
by my colleague, the member for Saanich North and the Islands, who is an expert in this area of legislation. You may find at some point that these
words sound familiar because I defer to him on all matters FOI, given his stature
as the grandfather of freedom of information in this province. I'd also like to thank my colleague, the member for Surrey–White Rock, for bringing this motion forward. It's very clear to me, crystal clear to me, that
this piece of legislation is simply not ready. Not ready for prime time. Not ready
to be passed into legislation. The government needs to take the summer to do the work to get this bill right. Instead,
what we have is the government rushing this piece of legislation through. After all,
that's why I'm standing here at 8:34 p.m. rather than enjoying the B.C. Ale Trail,
which is, I think, where we'd all rather be. This motion is necessary because of exactly the kinds of moves that the government
has pulled tonight. When this government has an opportunity for collaboration, for
reconsideration, for hearing and responding to the valid concerns that members of
this House have raised, they insist that they know better, that critique is a challenge,
that dissent is unacceptable. This is not a government that can be trusted with weaker freedom-of-information laws.
This is a government that is widely said to be the least transparent in Canada, and
they are currently showing that with their actions again and again. So I want to speak to why it's necessary that this bill be stood down for six months
and amended. Freedom of information is the cornerstone of our democracy. People must have access to information. They must understand why decisions are being
made on what information and at whose request. As my colleague said yesterday, I believe that public trust depends on this transparency.
When people can access information, they are more likely to believe that government
is acting fairly and in the public interest. This legislation has been the tool that
empowers As my colleague said yesterday, I believe that public trust depends on this transparency.
When people can access information, they're more likely to believe that government
is acting fairly and in the public interest. This legislation has been the tool that
empowers journalists, researchers and citizens to have direct oversight of government.
This keeps decision-making connected to the people it affects, and that is why we
must delay this bill for six months. People cannot meaningfully participate in public debate if they don't have access
to the facts, and when access is restricted, reduced or delayed, suspicion grows.
Even good decisions can be questioned if they're made without transparency. Strong access-to-information laws set expectations inside government as well, encouraging
better recordkeeping, clearer reasoning and more careful decision-making. These are the questions that the government can use six months to answer: how this
bill is not an attempt to evade necessary scrutiny, how this bill isn't simply making
it harder for citizens to access more information and giving more discretion to centralized
decision-makers to determine who gets what and when. The concerns that my colleagues from across this side of the House have raised are
real. The questions we are asking are legitimate. If we can't get answers from where
we stand here, how on earth are we supposed to believe that they will tell the public
anything that they don't want to hear? I would like the government to spend six months thinking about what "reasonable" means,
how they define it now and how they intend to define it when they're back on this
side of the House. We haven't had any certainty or scrutiny.... Because that is what
this is about. We trade sides, except for the Third Party. We always stay on this
side. How would we want to be treated when we're on this side of the House? I think
we should all apply that test. We haven't had any certainty or security about how the government intends to define
"reasonable." I stand here unclear on what a reasonable amount of time is, other than
whenever the scrutiny they're trying to avoid has passed. Perhaps when the media has
moved on to the next scandal? I stand here unclear on how a public body can determine
when to refuse to disclose information about a proposed program — again, a level of
certainty that I should be able to have. The government has not done the work on this, and they need six months more to do
it. There should not be members of this House who are legitimately concerned about
their access to detail on programs and government spending. Freedom of information is not just the access to the information itself. It's the
wider regime in which it sits. It's about the level of trust that members of the public,
business, civil society, academics can have in the institutions governing them. It's very clear that this regime is under threat because of this bill and because
of the way in which it has been introduced and debated without the work being done,
without sufficient consultation, without rigorous analysis, without the ability for
the concerns of people from across this province to be assuaged — work that requires
six more months. Government information does not belong to the government; it belongs to all of us,
and the government owes the people of British Columbia the responsibility to do this
work carefully, with precision, with care for not only the change that they're making
but the precedent that they're creating. A six-month delay gives the government that opportunity. If this legislative change
is necessary, the government must prove it. Bring us along with you. Bring us along
so we don't have to sit through the night objecting to this bill, proposing amendments. If the government can be trusted to make decisions in the best interests of British
Columbians, then you'll hear the people of British Columbia when they say, "stop,"
when they ask you to pause, when they tell you that what you're doing is dangerous
and that you haven't brought them along with you. Access-to-information systems exist precisely because governments are not infallible.
History has repeatedly shown that secrecy can conceal waste, corruption, abuse of
power and poor decision-making. As the saying goes: "Act in haste; repent in leisure."
This is not something that should be rushed through. I hear that government officials have been surprised by the backlash to this bill,
that they thought it would pass with minimal fuss, that it was an administrative change.
The fact that they are surprised shows the danger of this bill and details exactly
why this pause is so desperately needed. The government has once again proven that
they're out of touch with the reality on the ground in British Columbia, that they're
not listening to anyone outside of their bubble. This motion gives them the opportunity to fix that, to speak to people who haven't
been consulted on this information, to look at other jurisdictions and how they manage
freedom-of-information requests in the age of mass information. I suspect they'll
be surprised by what they find, because I suspect the answer is proactive release,
not limiting the grounds, the time frames or the discretion. Once again, I repeat that the work here has simply not been done. Once again, I echo
my colleague, who was critical in the development of this piece of legislation when
it was first developed, when it was considered world-leading legislation. Once again, I echo my colleague who was critical in the development of this piece
of legislation when it was first developed, when it was considered world-leading legislation.
In his speech to this bill at second reading, he spoke to the work that was done in
the development of the bill — the consultation, the amendments, the gaining consensus
from across the province. In his speech on this motion yesterday, he said by way of comparison that in 1992
when the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act was introduced in this
Legislature, a discussion paper was released publicly. There was feedback sought from
all interested parties, including journalists, including future users of the act,
including organizations, including businesses — essentially any British Columbian
and any British Columbia organization or business that had any interest in legislation,
either because it intended to use the legislation or because it wanted to ensure the
legislation was robust. By way of comparison, that hasn't been done in six months. Hoist is needed to do it.
I note that after that feedback was provided on the discussion paper, there was actually
a televised debate regarding the legislation. Imagine a televised debate on a piece of legislation like this, involving the minister
and others. The submissions made during that period of time were made public. This
all resulted in amendments to the legislation, which is a far different process than
the process that's been undertaken for this bill. It gives a clear indication of the
type of work that could be conducted over the next six months if this motion is adopted.
None of this work has been done. These legislative changes are difficult. They speak to some of the biggest powers
that government has and can most easily misuse. Restricting this access in haste is
a mistake, one that we don't have to make. We're fortunate there are experts and stakeholders
who stand by to advise the government on what the path forward is here. We should be looking to the 2022 report as a whole from the Special Committee to Review
the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act for changes. We should remember
that six months is not a long amount of time. If the government can come back with
proof that these changes are necessary, then we look forward to receiving that information.
We look forward to the discussions that could be had, the discussion papers that could
be disseminated, the experts in democracy and informed electorates that could provide
us with information, televised debates on this piece of legislation that could occur. The only way for freedom of information to be protected in this province, which is
fundamental to our democracy, is by hoisting this motion. The hoist of this motion
is required because the changes to freedom of information introduced in Bill 9 will
fundamentally change freedom of information to freedom from information. I am speaking in support of the motion, and for every point I make for the balance
of the time I have, I will link every line to why it relates to the motion because
I definitely do not want to lose my opportunity to speak at this important juncture.
I have 19 minutes to.... I have a lot of minutes left. There are parts of this bill, to be frank, to be fair, that solve some real issues
that this caucus doesn't have a problem with. I'm supporting the hoist motion because
there are other parts of the legislation that are very problematic. There are clauses,
and they did not influence my decision, like clause 22, that allow people to access
their own information more easily, and that's important. That's the problem and another reason why I support this hoist motion, because there
is no amount of amendments that will save this legislation and protect freedom of
information. It's unfortunate that in this legislation there are some provisions that
protect or support personal information access, but on the balance, I am supporting
and speaking in favour of this hoist motion because the changes that are problematic
far outweigh the changes that are supportable. I want to note that clauses that expand the ability of government to delay, deny or
limit access to information are not changes that improve freedom of information. For
that reason, this act needs to be hoisted for six months. My colleague covered some
of this in his second reading speech. That was in a different context. That was in
opening debate of this legislation. This is about the six-month hoist. I think it's important for the public of British Columbia and everybody who follows
the deliberations of this House to understand why I support the hoisting of this bill,
which is a very major step that none of us on this side of the House are taking lightly,
especially when it comes to the middle of the night when we're standing here talking
about a hoist motion. It's a big decision. It's important to provide an overview of
the specific clauses that we see as problematic in the legislation, as the government
is now proposing to amend some of these clauses. There's clause 1. It removes from FOI records the records that fall within a general
class of records that is listed or identified as part of a proceeding. That section
stands as it is, and it creates a whole new class exemption for general records in
relation to the items mentioned in clause 1. Clause 2 proposed amendments that would remove, in the opinion of the head of the
public body....Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Public administration
I rise to ask about Joffre Lakes Provincial Park, also known as Piipiuk in the Ucwalmícwts
language. It's a very important place in my riding for both Indigenous and non-Indigenous
people, a place of cultural significance, recreation, tourism and connection to the
land. In 2018, the province established a visitor management plan and collaborative working
group with the Líl̓wat and the N'Quatqua Nations to help guide decisions about the
park. These recognized the importance of closing the park for periods over the summer
months for the nations to reconnect with the land and allow the park to recover from
the effects of overtourism, which in prior years climbed to around 200,000 visitors.
In each of the last two years, the park has been closed for about 60 days for cultural
practices and healing. Two weeks ago, the ministry dictated by press release the 31 days it decided on for
the summer, different from what the nations requested, without any apparent consultation
with the working group. In this climate, even 31 days of closure...Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Indigenous governments
It's a privilege to speak today to Bill 20, the K'ómoks Treaty Act. I will be brief, and I will be echoing my colleague, the member for Saanich North and the Islands, and many others in expressing the importance of treaties and the treaty-making process.
As a province that has established and continues to establish itself in the absence
of negotiated processes with First Nations, treaties represent an avenue to right
that wrong. I wish to convey my congratulations to the K'ómoks Nation on their arrival to this stage of the process, an incredibly delicate endeavour
that has spanned 30 years and undoubtedly many many meetings, collaborations, agreements,
disagreements and resolutions. We do not take it lightly that this treaty legislation
is in front of the House and we honour the legacy of labour that has brought it here. We've also heard many perspectives in this House on this specific piece of legislation.
It's clear that the environment and moment in time in which this bill has been introduced
has been, and is, complex. As we all know, and it's been named multiple times during this process, there are
significant concerns in regard to this treaty act. These include concerns of overlap,
of economic development considerations and of non-derogation. These concerns and those
voicing them — and we would like to thank the Chiefs and leaders of the Wei Wai Kum
again for sharing their time and insight with us — have reminded us of the incredible
care, time and work that is required when passing treaty legislation through this
House. It is also critical for many of us to remember that Indigenous Peoples in British
Columbia have developed and practised intercommunity negotiation and protocols for
far longer than the rest of us have even been here. Many of these practices were intentionally
disrupted, banned and even outlawed through colonial interference and legal orders. It is important to remember this because we are placed in a very specific situation
in responding to this legislation as Members of the Legislative Assembly. As elected
officials, we're not here to determine the quality or validity of the claims for or
against this treaty nor are we here to control what treaty is or isn't supposed to
be. We're here to do our part in ensuring that the self-determination of all First
Nations in B.C. is, at the very least, not impeded by the laws created and passed
in this House. Keeping this responsibility in mind, the comments in the House on this act have been
announcements and assertions, not dialogue. The second reading vote we have directly
in front of us is not whether this treaty passes through the Legislature but whether
we are willing to have a further conversation about it. We want to We want to be sure that the concerns are brought forward for the record and that this
legislation will, without a doubt, not impede the self-determination of any nation
impacted by its ratification. I believe we owe it to the decades of work, negotiation,
relationship-building and community effort that has gone into this treaty process
to take our time at this stage. It is in the spirit of the democratic process that the Third Party supports this act
to move into the committee stage. We will be looking to the government to answer,
in detail, the hard questions that have been raised. It's an opportunity to continue
the conversation, move this bill to committee and ensure the concerns raised by nations
regarding overlap in territory are fully responded to by government on the public
record. There are clearly misunderstandings, fears and competing interpretations circulating
publicly right now. Government has an opportunity at committee to provide clear, factual
responses and help build confidence in this treaty and in the treaty process more
broadly, at this important moment in our province, by approaching it constructively
and bringing in the appropriate experts to support them in providing those informed
responses to what has been raised.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Aid programs
Here's a sampling of pleas we're hearing from British Columbians with disabilities,
for the record. "In B.C., being disabled and unable to work is punishable by neglect
and deep poverty which can lead to death," and "We are beyond desperate." Disability assistance rates in British Columbia are still $1,000 per month below the
poverty line and under CARGA, the 2025 cooperation agreement, this government committed
to review these rates and make recommendations for future increases. A year into that agreement, that review hadn't even begun. If it's okay with the minister,
please, can we skip the part about how it's our fault because we walked away from
CARGA? Making progress on basic dignity for persons with disabilities should never
have hinged on having two Green members constantly asking when. It's reasonable to expect that work to have continued, so to the Minister of Social
Development and Is this government unable or unwilling to raise rates without constant pressure from
two members of this Third Party?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Public access
We've talked a lot about economic sovereignty and data sovereignty in this House.
Our food sovereignty is clearly also under threat. In response to President Trump, the government has proudly promoted the Buy B.C. label,
but it looks like that moniker also applies literally to B.C. farmland, with billionaires
buying up ALR land as investments. Near Merritt, an heir to the Walmart fortune now controls 1.2 million acres of farmland
and is blocking the public from accessing public land. In my riding, in Pemberton
Meadows, luxury real estate is booming as farmland is sold off for multi-million-dollar
mansions, equestrian facilities and even landing pads for private helicopters. Farming
operations are priced out or faced with unstable leases. In Dunster, an American billionaire
who profits from ICE detention centres is buying up ranchland for a game hunter's playground. To the Minister of Agriculture and Food, arable land is the foundation of thriving
communities, and its ownership needs oversight. What is this government doing to stop
the ultra-wealthy from treating B.C. farmland as nothing more than a safe financial
asset?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Public finance
Last week I asked about Sea to Sky regional transit, the most important issue in West Vancouver–Sea to Sky, and the minister said he agrees with the importance of transit along the Sea to
Sky corridor. I can tell you, there are 50,000 residents that are glad he put that
on the record. Even in a fiscal bind, this government added public transit funding to this year's
budget, showing some leadership, to their credit, and reflecting the importance of
this service that returns money to the economy roughly 4 to 1 for every dollar invested.
Setting aside the contributions of Squamish and Pemberton, the resort municipality
of Whistler alone attracts over 3 million annual visitors, generating $1.5 billion
in spending, roughly one quarter of B.C.'s tourism export revenue, $1.4 million per
day in tax revenue. The problem is businesses are looking at setting up in Whistler and saying: "We can't
move forward. All our staff would need their own personal vehicles." Especially in
the hospitality business, this isn't feasible or practical. The minister last week said it's too early to order buses, but after 16 months, he
hasn't even instructed B.C. Transit to start planning for this service he recognizes
is important. Local governments and First Nations have taken this as far as they can
on their own and have made a number of concessions to get this done.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Taxes
With regards to regional public transit in the Sea to Sky corridor, I asked the minister
yesterday about directions to B.C. Transit. The minister said: "In terms of B.C. Transit,
we work with them in terms of what they're looking at, in terms of plans for the coming
years, much of which is determined at the local level. We've had a number of meetings.
The member knows what the issues are." The issue is that after a year of meetings
to hear from the local level, the ministry came up with an artificial governance obstacle
in December to slow this down. But what I really object to is the minister throwing out the vigour of $0.18 a litre
of gas tax yesterday. This is irresponsible considering the discussions have been
mirroring the Victoria model at $0.5 a litre. The only time $0.18 has been discussed
in the context of the TransLink levy and how Sea to Sky motorists are paying the equivalent
of that levy because prices are a single market with the Lower Mainland, meaning residents
have been paying extra without the transit to show for it for the last ten years.... What was the minister's intention in using an inflammatory high gas tax figure in
this time of high gas prices when he replied yesterday?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Negotiations
It's a privilege to speak today to Bill 20, the K'ómoks Treaty Act. I will be brief, and I will be echoing my colleague, the member for Saanich North and the Islands, and many others in expressing the importance of treaties and the treaty-making process.
As a province that has established and continues to establish itself in the absence
of negotiated processes with First Nations, treaties represent an avenue to right
that wrong. I wish to convey my congratulations to the K'ómoks Nation on their arrival to this stage of the process, an incredibly delicate endeavour
that has spanned 30 years and undoubtedly many many meetings, collaborations, agreements,
disagreements and resolutions. We do not take it lightly that this treaty legislation
is in front of the House and we honour the legacy of labour that has brought it here. We've also heard many perspectives in this House on this specific piece of legislation.
It's clear that the environment and moment in time in which this bill has been introduced
has been, and is, complex. As we all know, and it's been named multiple times during this process, there are
significant concerns in regard to this treaty act. These include concerns of overlap,
of economic development considerations and of non-derogation. These concerns and those
voicing them — and we would like to thank the Chiefs and leaders of the Wei Wai Kum
again for sharing their time and insight with us — have reminded us of the incredible
care, time and work that is required when passing treaty legislation through this
House. It is also critical for many of us to remember that Indigenous Peoples in British
Columbia have developed and practised intercommunity negotiation and protocols for
far longer than the rest of us have even been here. Many of these practices were intentionally
disrupted, banned and even outlawed through colonial interference and legal orders. It is important to remember this because we are placed in a very specific situation
in responding to this legislation as Members of the Legislative Assembly. As elected
officials, we're not here to determine the quality or validity of the claims for or
against this treaty nor are we here to control what treaty is or isn't supposed to
be. We're here to do our part in ensuring that the self-determination of all First
Nations in B.C. is, at the very least, not impeded by the laws created and passed
in this House. Keeping this responsibility in mind, the comments in the House on this act have been
announcements and assertions, not dialogue. The second reading vote we have directly
in front of us is not whether this treaty passes through the Legislature but whether
we are willing to have a further conversation about it. We want to We want to be sure that the concerns are brought forward for the record and that this
legislation will, without a doubt, not impede the self-determination of any nation
impacted by its ratification. I believe we owe it to the decades of work, negotiation,
relationship-building and community effort that has gone into this treaty process
to take our time at this stage. It is in the spirit of the democratic process that the Third Party supports this act
to move into the committee stage. We will be looking to the government to answer,
in detail, the hard questions that have been raised. It's an opportunity to continue
the conversation, move this bill to committee and ensure the concerns raised by nations
regarding overlap in territory are fully responded to by government on the public
record. There are clearly misunderstandings, fears and competing interpretations circulating
publicly right now. Government has an opportunity at committee to provide clear, factual
responses and help build confidence in this treaty and in the treaty process more
broadly, at this important moment in our province, by approaching it constructively
and bringing in the appropriate experts to support them in providing those informed
responses to what has been raised.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Economic issues, Financial assistance, Income, Low income, Poverty
Here's a sampling of pleas we're hearing from British Columbians with disabilities,
for the record. "In B.C., being disabled and unable to work is punishable by neglect
and deep poverty which can lead to death," and "We are beyond desperate." Disability assistance rates in British Columbia are still $1,000 per month below the
poverty line and under CARGA, the 2025 cooperation agreement, this government committed
to review these rates and make recommendations for future increases. A year into that agreement, that review hadn't even begun. If it's okay with the minister,
please, can we skip the part about how it's our fault because we walked away from
CARGA? Making progress on basic dignity for persons with disabilities should never
have hinged on having two Green members constantly asking when. It's reasonable to expect that work to have continued, so to the Minister of Social
Development and Is this government unable or unwilling to raise rates without constant pressure from
two members of this Third Party?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Agri-food industry, Agriculture, Economic issues, Economy, Farmlands, Real estate
We've talked a lot about economic sovereignty and data sovereignty in this House.
Our food sovereignty is clearly also under threat. In response to President Trump, the government has proudly promoted the Buy B.C. label,
but it looks like that moniker also applies literally to B.C. farmland, with billionaires
buying up ALR land as investments. Near Merritt, an heir to the Walmart fortune now controls 1.2 million acres of farmland
and is blocking the public from accessing public land. In my riding, in Pemberton
Meadows, luxury real estate is booming as farmland is sold off for multi-million-dollar
mansions, equestrian facilities and even landing pads for private helicopters. Farming
operations are priced out or faced with unstable leases. In Dunster, an American billionaire
who profits from ICE detention centres is buying up ranchland for a game hunter's playground. To the Minister of Agriculture and Food, arable land is the foundation of thriving
communities, and its ownership needs oversight. What is this government doing to stop
the ultra-wealthy from treating B.C. farmland as nothing more than a safe financial
asset?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Avalanches
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Sorry to be slow. I attended two memorials in Whistler the weekend before last for very different people, but both impressively well-attended by hundreds of people. I wanted to mark these two very important people in the community,
in the Sea to Sky community. Nigel Woods lived to the age of 74 and he was a pillar of the Whistler community, first visited
when he was a UVic student, founded coastal mountain excavations that shaped modern Whistler. It was Whistler's oldest operating company. From a chairlift, he spotted an island in Alpha Lake that he bought in 1974 — for some unknown, but it had previously changed hands for $50. He built a home there, affectionately called Woods Island. He was known in his family for his ZFL — zest for life. His daughter Carly said: "I've had friends only decide on their life partner because that person had the ZFL." She said of Nigel: "You could be lined up in the
village, 200 people deep with little kids that are crying and it's pouring down rain,
and Nigel would be like, 'It was the best day ever.'" There was always a silver lining. It was said that if you rode a chairlift with him, he became your friend. And I have....
Several people told me examples of that. His son Matt said he lived 100 lives in one, and he'll be missed by his family and by the community. Nigel was 74, which is still too early, but the hardest one for me was in the Whistler Conference Centre for 23-year-old Kai Smart, who is a rare breed. He was born and raised in Whistler, the son of two Olympians, John and Julia, who were founders of momentum ski camps. Kai was first overall in B.C. as a competitive skier, and Kai and his brother Luke cut their teeth on the ski ramp their family had in the back of their house. Kai was a film-maker focused on skiing but also on social and climate issues. Kai passed away from doing what he loved. He died from injuries he sustained in an
avalanche while filming for a ski and climate film in Japan. He'll be sorely missed by his parents, John and Julia, and his brother Luke. And I thank you, Mr. Speaker, for the opportunity I thank you for the opportunity.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Parks
I rise to ask about Joffre Lakes Provincial Park, also known as Piipiuk in the Ucwalmícwts
language. It's a very important place in my riding for both Indigenous and non-Indigenous
people, a place of cultural significance, recreation, tourism and connection to the
land. In 2018, the province established a visitor management plan and collaborative working
group with the Líl̓wat and the N'Quatqua Nations to help guide decisions about the
park. These recognized the importance of closing the park for periods over the summer
months for the nations to reconnect with the land and allow the park to recover from
the effects of overtourism, which in prior years climbed to around 200,000 visitors.
In each of the last two years, the park has been closed for about 60 days for cultural
practices and healing. Two weeks ago, the ministry dictated by press release the 31 days it decided on for
the summer, different from what the nations requested, without any apparent consultation
with the working group. In this climate, even 31 days of closure...Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Environmental technology
I haven't had any constituents in the House for a little while, so I'm very pleased
to have two today. The first is Greig Walsh, a close friend and ski buddy. He's one of the founders of
Greenlight Innovation, a leading hydrogen equipment supplier. Greenlight has sold half-a-billion dollars in their history into global markets, and
that represents clean tech jobs and revenue into B.C. It's my hope that inBC will
adopt some of this technology. The second is Ruth Simons. Ruth is the powerhouse behind the Howe Sound Biosphere
Region Initiative, president and executive director since 2017, previously a Lions
Bay council member and recipient from the Sḵwx̱wú7mesh Nation of a blanketing ceremony and an honorary degree from Capilano University. Most importantly, Ruth has convened the House Sound Community Forum for over a decade,
which is the most valuable place for me to find out what's going on in the Howe Sound
biosphere and watershed and a great service to all our communities.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Farms
We've talked a lot about economic sovereignty and data sovereignty in this House.
Our food sovereignty is clearly also under threat. In response to President Trump, the government has proudly promoted the Buy B.C. label,
but it looks like that moniker also applies literally to B.C. farmland, with billionaires
buying up ALR land as investments. Near Merritt, an heir to the Walmart fortune now controls 1.2 million acres of farmland
and is blocking the public from accessing public land. In my riding, in Pemberton
Meadows, luxury real estate is booming as farmland is sold off for multi-million-dollar
mansions, equestrian facilities and even landing pads for private helicopters. Farming
operations are priced out or faced with unstable leases. In Dunster, an American billionaire
who profits from ICE detention centres is buying up ranchland for a game hunter's playground. To the Minister of Agriculture and Food, arable land is the foundation of thriving
communities, and its ownership needs oversight. What is this government doing to stop
the ultra-wealthy from treating B.C. farmland as nothing more than a safe financial
asset?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Indigenous affairs, Indigenous lands
I rise to ask about Joffre Lakes Provincial Park, also known as Piipiuk in the Ucwalmícwts
language. It's a very important place in my riding for both Indigenous and non-Indigenous
people, a place of cultural significance, recreation, tourism and connection to the
land. In 2018, the province established a visitor management plan and collaborative working
group with the Líl̓wat and the N'Quatqua Nations to help guide decisions about the
park. These recognized the importance of closing the park for periods over the summer
months for the nations to reconnect with the land and allow the park to recover from
the effects of overtourism, which in prior years climbed to around 200,000 visitors.
In each of the last two years, the park has been closed for about 60 days for cultural
practices and healing. Two weeks ago, the ministry dictated by press release the 31 days it decided on for
the summer, different from what the nations requested, without any apparent consultation
with the working group. In this climate, even 31 days of closure...Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: First Nations, Indigenous affairs, Indigenous peoples, Indigenous programs
I have been listening carefully, and I feel like this is a true debate. I've been
a little disappointed, coming from a municipal council background, that sometimes
what passes for debate in this House is sort of entrenched monologues, so I'm happy
to listen to this. I want to thank my colleagues for the time and effort they've put into this dialogue.
Treaties are incredibly important, and it is critical we take our time to ensure we're
honouring the time and relationship and labour that's informed them. I'm going to put together a slightly different view here, and I'm going to be a little
pedantic with my colleague. I don't think this is a hoist motion. We had a lot of
discussion about whether a six-month delay was effectively killing the bill or not.
I'm open to further comment on this, but it seems to me that referring to a committee
that hasn't met in decades either could easily or is intended to stop this in its
tracks. In any case, I'll explain why we are currently opposed to this dilatory motion. The Third Party, the B.C. Greens, support the self-determination of First Nations
in all the forms that may take, including treaty-making. We're all here to do our
part in ensuring self-determination of all First Nations is supported by the legislation
passed in this chamber. It's been made crystal clear there are long-standing issues with the treaty process,
including the Crown's interference in Indigenous relations, governance and legal orders.
We also know that negotiation tables have not yet been successful in avoiding the
need for First Nations to seek justice or redress through the judicial branch. As we see through this conversation — and more to come, I'm sure — and throughout
this entire session, there are not sufficient venues for the cross-partisan consideration
of Indigenous affairs issues needed to find consensus. I would say, perhaps subjectively,
that political opportunism has further degraded this conversation. The B.C. Greens have been calling for the re-establishment of the Standing Committee
on Aboriginal Affairs as a space where this House can come together, with support
from First Nations and legal experts, to move past partisanship and actually make
progress on these critical issues. In April, the B.C. Greens invited the government to consider this proposal, which
included the following three things — and I will get to the motion in just one second,
if you bear with me: reviewing progress on the agreed approach, with regular updates
to the Legislature and the public — pretty key, in keeping the public informed; reviewing
funding for the B.C. Treaty Commission, the Declaration Act secretariat and other
treaty and reconciliation initiatives, which involves treating this work as a major
project; and reviewing and making recommendations on additional ways to advance reconciliation,
such as establishing an independent reconciliation commissioner, selected by the all-party
committee together with First Nations. For all these reasons, we appreciate the effort being made to create space for these
more nuanced and non-partisan conversations. It's an important goal, and I thank the
opposition for bringing it forward. We also believe it's important to recognize the larger context in which this House
sits and that the substance of this act is not, nor should it be, created and stewarded
solely through legislative processes. To clarify this, the development of treaties is an incredibly complex process. It
spans generations, requires skill in Crown litigation, Indigenous legal orders, relationship-building,
historical and cultural knowledge, humility, critical thinking and grace. This is not to say that the process is without flaws. It's clear that it has many.
But it's important to remember that the document in front of us is not the K'ómoks treaty but the K'ómoks Treaty Act. This is a critical distinction. It is fundamentally for First Nations
themselves — with the support of the Crown, when requested — to determine what are
and aren't their own historical boundaries. The process through which the government participates in treaty-making is made possible
through the B.C. Treaty Commission, an organization that draws on the skills I just
named. If British Columbia is involved, this is where litigation specifics of a treaty
are meant to be unpacked and negotiated, not in the Legislative Assembly. Speaking to the motion, the Aboriginal Affairs Committee should be a place for provincewide
consideration of reconciliation and how to all move forward together. It should not
be where the details of a treaty, which has been discussed and contributed to by generations
of people.... This should not be a place where these are dissected and determined. With all that said, questions about the process remain. As the Third Party shared
in our statement yesterday, our role is to ensure that laws passed in this House,
at the very least, do not impede or disrupt With all that said, questions about the process remain, and as the Third Party shared
in our statement yesterday, our role is to ensure that laws passed in this House at
the very least do not impede or disrupt the self-determination of any First Nation. For that reason, the Third Party's caucus is not inclined to support the motion proposed.
We recognize the intention and appreciate the attempt to give space for issues to
be resolved, but we don't believe a pause of this form is appropriate or will be effective. In acknowledging this, this caucus believes that for this specific piece of legislation,
the committee stage of the legislative process is the appropriate venue in which to
voice concerns about the impacts of the legislation — an important point; that's impacts
of the legislation — that have been raised. I thank you for the time, Mr. Speaker.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Disadvantaged persons
Here's a sampling of pleas we're hearing from British Columbians with disabilities,
for the record. "In B.C., being disabled and unable to work is punishable by neglect
and deep poverty which can lead to death," and "We are beyond desperate." Disability assistance rates in British Columbia are still $1,000 per month below the
poverty line and under CARGA, the 2025 cooperation agreement, this government committed
to review these rates and make recommendations for future increases. A year into that agreement, that review hadn't even begun. If it's okay with the minister,
please, can we skip the part about how it's our fault because we walked away from
CARGA? Making progress on basic dignity for persons with disabilities should never
have hinged on having two Green members constantly asking when. It's reasonable to expect that work to have continued, so to the Minister of Social
Development and Is this government unable or unwilling to raise rates without constant pressure from
two members of this Third Party?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Skiing
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Sorry to be slow. I attended two memorials in Whistler the weekend before last for very different people, but both impressively well-attended by hundreds of people. I wanted to mark these two very important people in the community,
in the Sea to Sky community. Nigel Woods lived to the age of 74 and he was a pillar of the Whistler community, first visited
when he was a UVic student, founded coastal mountain excavations that shaped modern Whistler. It was Whistler's oldest operating company. From a chairlift, he spotted an island in Alpha Lake that he bought in 1974 — for some unknown, but it had previously changed hands for $50. He built a home there, affectionately called Woods Island. He was known in his family for his ZFL — zest for life. His daughter Carly said: "I've had friends only decide on their life partner because that person had the ZFL." She said of Nigel: "You could be lined up in the
village, 200 people deep with little kids that are crying and it's pouring down rain,
and Nigel would be like, 'It was the best day ever.'" There was always a silver lining. It was said that if you rode a chairlift with him, he became your friend. And I have....
Several people told me examples of that. His son Matt said he lived 100 lives in one, and he'll be missed by his family and by the community. Nigel was 74, which is still too early, but the hardest one for me was in the Whistler Conference Centre for 23-year-old Kai Smart, who is a rare breed. He was born and raised in Whistler, the son of two Olympians, John and Julia, who were founders of momentum ski camps. Kai was first overall in B.C. as a competitive skier, and Kai and his brother Luke cut their teeth on the ski ramp their family had in the back of their house. Kai was a film-maker focused on skiing but also on social and climate issues. Kai passed away from doing what he loved. He died from injuries he sustained in an
avalanche while filming for a ski and climate film in Japan. He'll be sorely missed by his parents, John and Julia, and his brother Luke. And I thank you, Mr. Speaker, for the opportunity I thank you for the opportunity.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Cultural heritage
I rise to ask about Joffre Lakes Provincial Park, also known as Piipiuk in the Ucwalmícwts
language. It's a very important place in my riding for both Indigenous and non-Indigenous
people, a place of cultural significance, recreation, tourism and connection to the
land. In 2018, the province established a visitor management plan and collaborative working
group with the Líl̓wat and the N'Quatqua Nations to help guide decisions about the
park. These recognized the importance of closing the park for periods over the summer
months for the nations to reconnect with the land and allow the park to recover from
the effects of overtourism, which in prior years climbed to around 200,000 visitors.
In each of the last two years, the park has been closed for about 60 days for cultural
practices and healing. Two weeks ago, the ministry dictated by press release the 31 days it decided on for
the summer, different from what the nations requested, without any apparent consultation
with the working group. In this climate, even 31 days of closure...Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Information, Information dissemination
I am deeply gratified and very excited to be here to speak to the motion to delay
Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026. I'd like to start by saying that I, of course, fully support all the comments made
by my colleague, the member for Saanich North and the Islands, who is an expert in this area of legislation. You may find at some point that these
words sound familiar because I defer to him on all matters FOI, given his stature
as the grandfather of freedom of information in this province. I'd also like to thank my colleague, the member for Surrey–White Rock, for bringing this motion forward. It's very clear to me, crystal clear to me, that
this piece of legislation is simply not ready. Not ready for prime time. Not ready
to be passed into legislation. The government needs to take the summer to do the work to get this bill right. Instead,
what we have is the government rushing this piece of legislation through. After all,
that's why I'm standing here at 8:34 p.m. rather than enjoying the B.C. Ale Trail,
which is, I think, where we'd all rather be. This motion is necessary because of exactly the kinds of moves that the government
has pulled tonight. When this government has an opportunity for collaboration, for
reconsideration, for hearing and responding to the valid concerns that members of
this House have raised, they insist that they know better, that critique is a challenge,
that dissent is unacceptable. This is not a government that can be trusted with weaker freedom-of-information laws.
This is a government that is widely said to be the least transparent in Canada, and
they are currently showing that with their actions again and again. So I want to speak to why it's necessary that this bill be stood down for six months
and amended. Freedom of information is the cornerstone of our democracy. People must have access to information. They must understand why decisions are being
made on what information and at whose request. As my colleague said yesterday, I believe that public trust depends on this transparency.
When people can access information, they are more likely to believe that government
is acting fairly and in the public interest. This legislation has been the tool that
empowers As my colleague said yesterday, I believe that public trust depends on this transparency.
When people can access information, they're more likely to believe that government
is acting fairly and in the public interest. This legislation has been the tool that
empowers journalists, researchers and citizens to have direct oversight of government.
This keeps decision-making connected to the people it affects, and that is why we
must delay this bill for six months. People cannot meaningfully participate in public debate if they don't have access
to the facts, and when access is restricted, reduced or delayed, suspicion grows.
Even good decisions can be questioned if they're made without transparency. Strong access-to-information laws set expectations inside government as well, encouraging
better recordkeeping, clearer reasoning and more careful decision-making. These are the questions that the government can use six months to answer: how this
bill is not an attempt to evade necessary scrutiny, how this bill isn't simply making
it harder for citizens to access more information and giving more discretion to centralized
decision-makers to determine who gets what and when. The concerns that my colleagues from across this side of the House have raised are
real. The questions we are asking are legitimate. If we can't get answers from where
we stand here, how on earth are we supposed to believe that they will tell the public
anything that they don't want to hear? I would like the government to spend six months thinking about what "reasonable" means,
how they define it now and how they intend to define it when they're back on this
side of the House. We haven't had any certainty or scrutiny.... Because that is what
this is about. We trade sides, except for the Third Party. We always stay on this
side. How would we want to be treated when we're on this side of the House? I think
we should all apply that test. We haven't had any certainty or security about how the government intends to define
"reasonable." I stand here unclear on what a reasonable amount of time is, other than
whenever the scrutiny they're trying to avoid has passed. Perhaps when the media has
moved on to the next scandal? I stand here unclear on how a public body can determine
when to refuse to disclose information about a proposed program — again, a level of
certainty that I should be able to have. The government has not done the work on this, and they need six months more to do
it. There should not be members of this House who are legitimately concerned about
their access to detail on programs and government spending. Freedom of information is not just the access to the information itself. It's the
wider regime in which it sits. It's about the level of trust that members of the public,
business, civil society, academics can have in the institutions governing them. It's very clear that this regime is under threat because of this bill and because
of the way in which it has been introduced and debated without the work being done,
without sufficient consultation, without rigorous analysis, without the ability for
the concerns of people from across this province to be assuaged — work that requires
six more months. Government information does not belong to the government; it belongs to all of us,
and the government owes the people of British Columbia the responsibility to do this
work carefully, with precision, with care for not only the change that they're making
but the precedent that they're creating. A six-month delay gives the government that opportunity. If this legislative change
is necessary, the government must prove it. Bring us along with you. Bring us along
so we don't have to sit through the night objecting to this bill, proposing amendments. If the government can be trusted to make decisions in the best interests of British
Columbians, then you'll hear the people of British Columbia when they say, "stop,"
when they ask you to pause, when they tell you that what you're doing is dangerous
and that you haven't brought them along with you. Access-to-information systems exist precisely because governments are not infallible.
History has repeatedly shown that secrecy can conceal waste, corruption, abuse of
power and poor decision-making. As the saying goes: "Act in haste; repent in leisure."
This is not something that should be rushed through. I hear that government officials have been surprised by the backlash to this bill,
that they thought it would pass with minimal fuss, that it was an administrative change.
The fact that they are surprised shows the danger of this bill and details exactly
why this pause is so desperately needed. The government has once again proven that
they're out of touch with the reality on the ground in British Columbia, that they're
not listening to anyone outside of their bubble. This motion gives them the opportunity to fix that, to speak to people who haven't
been consulted on this information, to look at other jurisdictions and how they manage
freedom-of-information requests in the age of mass information. I suspect they'll
be surprised by what they find, because I suspect the answer is proactive release,
not limiting the grounds, the time frames or the discretion. Once again, I repeat that the work here has simply not been done. Once again, I echo
my colleague, who was critical in the development of this piece of legislation when
it was first developed, when it was considered world-leading legislation. Once again, I echo my colleague who was critical in the development of this piece
of legislation when it was first developed, when it was considered world-leading legislation.
In his speech to this bill at second reading, he spoke to the work that was done in
the development of the bill — the consultation, the amendments, the gaining consensus
from across the province. In his speech on this motion yesterday, he said by way of comparison that in 1992
when the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act was introduced in this
Legislature, a discussion paper was released publicly. There was feedback sought from
all interested parties, including journalists, including future users of the act,
including organizations, including businesses — essentially any British Columbian
and any British Columbia organization or business that had any interest in legislation,
either because it intended to use the legislation or because it wanted to ensure the
legislation was robust. By way of comparison, that hasn't been done in six months. Hoist is needed to do it.
I note that after that feedback was provided on the discussion paper, there was actually
a televised debate regarding the legislation. Imagine a televised debate on a piece of legislation like this, involving the minister
and others. The submissions made during that period of time were made public. This
all resulted in amendments to the legislation, which is a far different process than
the process that's been undertaken for this bill. It gives a clear indication of the
type of work that could be conducted over the next six months if this motion is adopted.
None of this work has been done. These legislative changes are difficult. They speak to some of the biggest powers
that government has and can most easily misuse. Restricting this access in haste is
a mistake, one that we don't have to make. We're fortunate there are experts and stakeholders
who stand by to advise the government on what the path forward is here. We should be looking to the 2022 report as a whole from the Special Committee to Review
the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act for changes. We should remember
that six months is not a long amount of time. If the government can come back with
proof that these changes are necessary, then we look forward to receiving that information.
We look forward to the discussions that could be had, the discussion papers that could
be disseminated, the experts in democracy and informed electorates that could provide
us with information, televised debates on this piece of legislation that could occur. The only way for freedom of information to be protected in this province, which is
fundamental to our democracy, is by hoisting this motion. The hoist of this motion
is required because the changes to freedom of information introduced in Bill 9 will
fundamentally change freedom of information to freedom from information. I am speaking in support of the motion, and for every point I make for the balance
of the time I have, I will link every line to why it relates to the motion because
I definitely do not want to lose my opportunity to speak at this important juncture.
I have 19 minutes to.... I have a lot of minutes left. There are parts of this bill, to be frank, to be fair, that solve some real issues
that this caucus doesn't have a problem with. I'm supporting the hoist motion because
there are other parts of the legislation that are very problematic. There are clauses,
and they did not influence my decision, like clause 22, that allow people to access
their own information more easily, and that's important. That's the problem and another reason why I support this hoist motion, because there
is no amount of amendments that will save this legislation and protect freedom of
information. It's unfortunate that in this legislation there are some provisions that
protect or support personal information access, but on the balance, I am supporting
and speaking in favour of this hoist motion because the changes that are problematic
far outweigh the changes that are supportable. I want to note that clauses that expand the ability of government to delay, deny or
limit access to information are not changes that improve freedom of information. For
that reason, this act needs to be hoisted for six months. My colleague covered some
of this in his second reading speech. That was in a different context. That was in
opening debate of this legislation. This is about the six-month hoist. I think it's important for the public of British Columbia and everybody who follows
the deliberations of this House to understand why I support the hoisting of this bill,
which is a very major step that none of us on this side of the House are taking lightly,
especially when it comes to the middle of the night when we're standing here talking
about a hoist motion. It's a big decision. It's important to provide an overview of
the specific clauses that we see as problematic in the legislation, as the government
is now proposing to amend some of these clauses. There's clause 1. It removes from FOI records the records that fall within a general
class of records that is listed or identified as part of a proceeding. That section
stands as it is, and it creates a whole new class exemption for general records in
relation to the items mentioned in clause 1. Clause 2 proposed amendments that would remove, in the opinion of the head of the
public body....Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Energy technology, Technological innovation, Technology
I haven't had any constituents in the House for a little while, so I'm very pleased
to have two today. The first is Greig Walsh, a close friend and ski buddy. He's one of the founders of
Greenlight Innovation, a leading hydrogen equipment supplier. Greenlight has sold half-a-billion dollars in their history into global markets, and
that represents clean tech jobs and revenue into B.C. It's my hope that inBC will
adopt some of this technology. The second is Ruth Simons. Ruth is the powerhouse behind the Howe Sound Biosphere
Region Initiative, president and executive director since 2017, previously a Lions
Bay council member and recipient from the Sḵwx̱wú7mesh Nation of a blanketing ceremony and an honorary degree from Capilano University. Most importantly, Ruth has convened the House Sound Community Forum for over a decade,
which is the most valuable place for me to find out what's going on in the Howe Sound
biosphere and watershed and a great service to all our communities.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Intercity transport, Public transit, Transport
Last week I asked about Sea to Sky regional transit, the most important issue in West Vancouver–Sea to Sky, and the minister said he agrees with the importance of transit along the Sea to
Sky corridor. I can tell you, there are 50,000 residents that are glad he put that
on the record. Even in a fiscal bind, this government added public transit funding to this year's
budget, showing some leadership, to their credit, and reflecting the importance of
this service that returns money to the economy roughly 4 to 1 for every dollar invested.
Setting aside the contributions of Squamish and Pemberton, the resort municipality
of Whistler alone attracts over 3 million annual visitors, generating $1.5 billion
in spending, roughly one quarter of B.C.'s tourism export revenue, $1.4 million per
day in tax revenue. The problem is businesses are looking at setting up in Whistler and saying: "We can't
move forward. All our staff would need their own personal vehicles." Especially in
the hospitality business, this isn't feasible or practical. The minister last week said it's too early to order buses, but after 16 months, he
hasn't even instructed B.C. Transit to start planning for this service he recognizes
is important. Local governments and First Nations have taken this as far as they can
on their own and have made a number of concessions to get this done.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Public transit, Transport
With regards to regional public transit in the Sea to Sky corridor, I asked the minister
yesterday about directions to B.C. Transit. The minister said: "In terms of B.C. Transit,
we work with them in terms of what they're looking at, in terms of plans for the coming
years, much of which is determined at the local level. We've had a number of meetings.
The member knows what the issues are." The issue is that after a year of meetings
to hear from the local level, the ministry came up with an artificial governance obstacle
in December to slow this down. But what I really object to is the minister throwing out the vigour of $0.18 a litre
of gas tax yesterday. This is irresponsible considering the discussions have been
mirroring the Victoria model at $0.5 a litre. The only time $0.18 has been discussed
in the context of the TransLink levy and how Sea to Sky motorists are paying the equivalent
of that levy because prices are a single market with the Lower Mainland, meaning residents
have been paying extra without the transit to show for it for the last ten years.... What was the minister's intention in using an inflammatory high gas tax figure in
this time of high gas prices when he replied yesterday?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Disabilities, Persons with disabilities
Here's a sampling of pleas we're hearing from British Columbians with disabilities,
for the record. "In B.C., being disabled and unable to work is punishable by neglect
and deep poverty which can lead to death," and "We are beyond desperate." Disability assistance rates in British Columbia are still $1,000 per month below the
poverty line and under CARGA, the 2025 cooperation agreement, this government committed
to review these rates and make recommendations for future increases. A year into that agreement, that review hadn't even begun. If it's okay with the minister,
please, can we skip the part about how it's our fault because we walked away from
CARGA? Making progress on basic dignity for persons with disabilities should never
have hinged on having two Green members constantly asking when. It's reasonable to expect that work to have continued, so to the Minister of Social
Development and Is this government unable or unwilling to raise rates without constant pressure from
two members of this Third Party?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Funding, Public funding
Last week I asked about Sea to Sky regional transit, the most important issue in West Vancouver–Sea to Sky, and the minister said he agrees with the importance of transit along the Sea to
Sky corridor. I can tell you, there are 50,000 residents that are glad he put that
on the record. Even in a fiscal bind, this government added public transit funding to this year's
budget, showing some leadership, to their credit, and reflecting the importance of
this service that returns money to the economy roughly 4 to 1 for every dollar invested.
Setting aside the contributions of Squamish and Pemberton, the resort municipality
of Whistler alone attracts over 3 million annual visitors, generating $1.5 billion
in spending, roughly one quarter of B.C.'s tourism export revenue, $1.4 million per
day in tax revenue. The problem is businesses are looking at setting up in Whistler and saying: "We can't
move forward. All our staff would need their own personal vehicles." Especially in
the hospitality business, this isn't feasible or practical. The minister last week said it's too early to order buses, but after 16 months, he
hasn't even instructed B.C. Transit to start planning for this service he recognizes
is important. Local governments and First Nations have taken this as far as they can
on their own and have made a number of concessions to get this done.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Legal issues
I am deeply gratified and very excited to be here to speak to the motion to delay
Bill 9, the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act, 2026. I'd like to start by saying that I, of course, fully support all the comments made
by my colleague, the member for Saanich North and the Islands, who is an expert in this area of legislation. You may find at some point that these
words sound familiar because I defer to him on all matters FOI, given his stature
as the grandfather of freedom of information in this province. I'd also like to thank my colleague, the member for Surrey–White Rock, for bringing this motion forward. It's very clear to me, crystal clear to me, that
this piece of legislation is simply not ready. Not ready for prime time. Not ready
to be passed into legislation. The government needs to take the summer to do the work to get this bill right. Instead,
what we have is the government rushing this piece of legislation through. After all,
that's why I'm standing here at 8:34 p.m. rather than enjoying the B.C. Ale Trail,
which is, I think, where we'd all rather be. This motion is necessary because of exactly the kinds of moves that the government
has pulled tonight. When this government has an opportunity for collaboration, for
reconsideration, for hearing and responding to the valid concerns that members of
this House have raised, they insist that they know better, that critique is a challenge,
that dissent is unacceptable. This is not a government that can be trusted with weaker freedom-of-information laws.
This is a government that is widely said to be the least transparent in Canada, and
they are currently showing that with their actions again and again. So I want to speak to why it's necessary that this bill be stood down for six months
and amended. Freedom of information is the cornerstone of our democracy. People must have access to information. They must understand why decisions are being
made on what information and at whose request. As my colleague said yesterday, I believe that public trust depends on this transparency.
When people can access information, they are more likely to believe that government
is acting fairly and in the public interest. This legislation has been the tool that
empowers As my colleague said yesterday, I believe that public trust depends on this transparency.
When people can access information, they're more likely to believe that government
is acting fairly and in the public interest. This legislation has been the tool that
empowers journalists, researchers and citizens to have direct oversight of government.
This keeps decision-making connected to the people it affects, and that is why we
must delay this bill for six months. People cannot meaningfully participate in public debate if they don't have access
to the facts, and when access is restricted, reduced or delayed, suspicion grows.
Even good decisions can be questioned if they're made without transparency. Strong access-to-information laws set expectations inside government as well, encouraging
better recordkeeping, clearer reasoning and more careful decision-making. These are the questions that the government can use six months to answer: how this
bill is not an attempt to evade necessary scrutiny, how this bill isn't simply making
it harder for citizens to access more information and giving more discretion to centralized
decision-makers to determine who gets what and when. The concerns that my colleagues from across this side of the House have raised are
real. The questions we are asking are legitimate. If we can't get answers from where
we stand here, how on earth are we supposed to believe that they will tell the public
anything that they don't want to hear? I would like the government to spend six months thinking about what "reasonable" means,
how they define it now and how they intend to define it when they're back on this
side of the House. We haven't had any certainty or scrutiny.... Because that is what
this is about. We trade sides, except for the Third Party. We always stay on this
side. How would we want to be treated when we're on this side of the House? I think
we should all apply that test. We haven't had any certainty or security about how the government intends to define
"reasonable." I stand here unclear on what a reasonable amount of time is, other than
whenever the scrutiny they're trying to avoid has passed. Perhaps when the media has
moved on to the next scandal? I stand here unclear on how a public body can determine
when to refuse to disclose information about a proposed program — again, a level of
certainty that I should be able to have. The government has not done the work on this, and they need six months more to do
it. There should not be members of this House who are legitimately concerned about
their access to detail on programs and government spending. Freedom of information is not just the access to the information itself. It's the
wider regime in which it sits. It's about the level of trust that members of the public,
business, civil society, academics can have in the institutions governing them. It's very clear that this regime is under threat because of this bill and because
of the way in which it has been introduced and debated without the work being done,
without sufficient consultation, without rigorous analysis, without the ability for
the concerns of people from across this province to be assuaged — work that requires
six more months. Government information does not belong to the government; it belongs to all of us,
and the government owes the people of British Columbia the responsibility to do this
work carefully, with precision, with care for not only the change that they're making
but the precedent that they're creating. A six-month delay gives the government that opportunity. If this legislative change
is necessary, the government must prove it. Bring us along with you. Bring us along
so we don't have to sit through the night objecting to this bill, proposing amendments. If the government can be trusted to make decisions in the best interests of British
Columbians, then you'll hear the people of British Columbia when they say, "stop,"
when they ask you to pause, when they tell you that what you're doing is dangerous
and that you haven't brought them along with you. Access-to-information systems exist precisely because governments are not infallible.
History has repeatedly shown that secrecy can conceal waste, corruption, abuse of
power and poor decision-making. As the saying goes: "Act in haste; repent in leisure."
This is not something that should be rushed through. I hear that government officials have been surprised by the backlash to this bill,
that they thought it would pass with minimal fuss, that it was an administrative change.
The fact that they are surprised shows the danger of this bill and details exactly
why this pause is so desperately needed. The government has once again proven that
they're out of touch with the reality on the ground in British Columbia, that they're
not listening to anyone outside of their bubble. This motion gives them the opportunity to fix that, to speak to people who haven't
been consulted on this information, to look at other jurisdictions and how they manage
freedom-of-information requests in the age of mass information. I suspect they'll
be surprised by what they find, because I suspect the answer is proactive release,
not limiting the grounds, the time frames or the discretion. Once again, I repeat that the work here has simply not been done. Once again, I echo
my colleague, who was critical in the development of this piece of legislation when
it was first developed, when it was considered world-leading legislation. Once again, I echo my colleague who was critical in the development of this piece
of legislation when it was first developed, when it was considered world-leading legislation.
In his speech to this bill at second reading, he spoke to the work that was done in
the development of the bill — the consultation, the amendments, the gaining consensus
from across the province. In his speech on this motion yesterday, he said by way of comparison that in 1992
when the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act was introduced in this
Legislature, a discussion paper was released publicly. There was feedback sought from
all interested parties, including journalists, including future users of the act,
including organizations, including businesses — essentially any British Columbian
and any British Columbia organization or business that had any interest in legislation,
either because it intended to use the legislation or because it wanted to ensure the
legislation was robust. By way of comparison, that hasn't been done in six months. Hoist is needed to do it.
I note that after that feedback was provided on the discussion paper, there was actually
a televised debate regarding the legislation. Imagine a televised debate on a piece of legislation like this, involving the minister
and others. The submissions made during that period of time were made public. This
all resulted in amendments to the legislation, which is a far different process than
the process that's been undertaken for this bill. It gives a clear indication of the
type of work that could be conducted over the next six months if this motion is adopted.
None of this work has been done. These legislative changes are difficult. They speak to some of the biggest powers
that government has and can most easily misuse. Restricting this access in haste is
a mistake, one that we don't have to make. We're fortunate there are experts and stakeholders
who stand by to advise the government on what the path forward is here. We should be looking to the 2022 report as a whole from the Special Committee to Review
the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act for changes. We should remember
that six months is not a long amount of time. If the government can come back with
proof that these changes are necessary, then we look forward to receiving that information.
We look forward to the discussions that could be had, the discussion papers that could
be disseminated, the experts in democracy and informed electorates that could provide
us with information, televised debates on this piece of legislation that could occur. The only way for freedom of information to be protected in this province, which is
fundamental to our democracy, is by hoisting this motion. The hoist of this motion
is required because the changes to freedom of information introduced in Bill 9 will
fundamentally change freedom of information to freedom from information. I am speaking in support of the motion, and for every point I make for the balance
of the time I have, I will link every line to why it relates to the motion because
I definitely do not want to lose my opportunity to speak at this important juncture.
I have 19 minutes to.... I have a lot of minutes left. There are parts of this bill, to be frank, to be fair, that solve some real issues
that this caucus doesn't have a problem with. I'm supporting the hoist motion because
there are other parts of the legislation that are very problematic. There are clauses,
and they did not influence my decision, like clause 22, that allow people to access
their own information more easily, and that's important. That's the problem and another reason why I support this hoist motion, because there
is no amount of amendments that will save this legislation and protect freedom of
information. It's unfortunate that in this legislation there are some provisions that
protect or support personal information access, but on the balance, I am supporting
and speaking in favour of this hoist motion because the changes that are problematic
far outweigh the changes that are supportable. I want to note that clauses that expand the ability of government to delay, deny or
limit access to information are not changes that improve freedom of information. For
that reason, this act needs to be hoisted for six months. My colleague covered some
of this in his second reading speech. That was in a different context. That was in
opening debate of this legislation. This is about the six-month hoist. I think it's important for the public of British Columbia and everybody who follows
the deliberations of this House to understand why I support the hoisting of this bill,
which is a very major step that none of us on this side of the House are taking lightly,
especially when it comes to the middle of the night when we're standing here talking
about a hoist motion. It's a big decision. It's important to provide an overview of
the specific clauses that we see as problematic in the legislation, as the government
is now proposing to amend some of these clauses. There's clause 1. It removes from FOI records the records that fall within a general
class of records that is listed or identified as part of a proceeding. That section
stands as it is, and it creates a whole new class exemption for general records in
relation to the items mentioned in clause 1. Clause 2 proposed amendments that would remove, in the opinion of the head of the
public body....Open source reference