Tony Luck · 2026-05

3 recorded contributions · Small sample

Back to media pack

Jev-reviewed existing detailed tags · editorial review required

Governance: 2 contributions
2026-05-06 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: Public access, Public administration

It's a real pleasure to be here this evening. It reminds me of the old days when
               we used to do all-nighters and things like that. So here we are, an all-nighter. It's
               been a long time. So I'm really looking forward to this, to being able to speak to
               this motion that we've got on the floor here, this hoist motion. Tonight I want to say strongly that I do support the hoist amendment to Bill 9, the
               Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act. I think it's a very important thing we're looking at today, because it's one of
               those little small things that define democracy in the end, right? Let me be absolutely clear at the outset about this hoist amendment, what it really
               does, why it really matters in the long term and why it is absolutely necessary that
               we move this as soon as possible. This hoist amendment proposes that the word "now"
               be replaced with "six months hence." I know we've heard that a lot today and the last
               day or two, but once again, I'll repeat it for the viewers out there that have tuned
               in late to this show tonight. I just want to make sure that they're very clear what
               we're trying to do here. We're not trying to defeat this bill, kill the bill, do anything like that. What we
               want to do is have a serious, second, sober look at this bill because there are some
               gaps in it. What we want to do is just extend it for six months, bring it back in
               the fall, allow the government to take some time over the summer vacation here — unfortunately,
               they'll have to work a little bit of their vacation — come back, have another look
               at this and fill in some of the gaps that we're really concerned about. It's not just us that are really concerned about the gaps. It's industry out there.
               It's other businesses. It's FOI associations and groups that have sown some real concern
               about it. I think in my original speech on Bill 9 I talked about that, and I made
               it very clear. We're not here to talk about the bill tonight. We're here to talk about
               the hoist amendment. So we just want to make sure that it's very, very clear that
               we're talking about the hoist and what it wants to do here. Six months to do what this government has failed to do. What are some of the things
               that it has failed to do? Well, it's failed to properly examine the bill, put it under
               a microscope and look at some of the finer details. We know this is the history of
               this government and what they don't do. That's properly consult. We hear that all
               the time, everywhere we go. They haven't properly consulted. So we need to go back
               and properly consult on this bill and properly understand the consequences of this
               deeply flawed legislation because that is what a hoist amendment is for. It's to be
               able to bring and shine the light on some things where there's some holes in it and
               have a look at that and try to improve where we can. The hoist amendment is not about the delay for the sake of delay. We don't want to
               do that. We all believe in properly effective, properly working freedom of information.
               I think that's a really important piece of legislation that this House can do and
               what we have in modern society today. I think it's really important to make sure we
               get it right, make sure we have the right timelines and the right costs. If there
               is a cost, there probably shouldn't be a cost, and that kind of thing, but some of
               the right things we do here. It's about preventing bad laws from being passed in haste. That's what this actually
               looks like. It looks like a bill that's being tried and passed in haste, rushed through.
               So you have to ask the question. Why are we trying to rush this bill through? I'll
               talk a little bit more about that, about rushing things, as I go along here. But it's also about forcing government to take a second, sober look when it has clearly
               gotten it wrong the first time, and this government has gotten it wrong. As I mentioned
               before, it's not just us saying this and other groups. This bill is not ready, and
               that is why this hoist amendment is absolutely necessary as we move forward here. It is not refined, and it certainly is not a balanced bill, as we've seen, as we have
               talked about, in the bill itself. It's not rooted in strengthening transparency. It
               seems more to do with shutting down transparency. This hoist motion will be there
               so we can go and look with clarity of how we can strengthen transparency because that's
               what's This hoist motion will be there so we can go and look, with clarity, at how we can
               strengthen transparency, because that's what it's all about — making sure everybody
               understands exactly what's happening, how the process is to work. It is a bill that weakens access right, expands government discretion and tilts the
               balance away from the public and towards the state, and that is precisely why this
               hoist motion must be passed — to go in and have a look at how it does that and how
               we can pull that back and rebalance the bill, moving forward here. If we allow this
               bill to proceed now, we are knowingly allowing flawed legislation to pass into law,
               legislation that will impact every journalist, every parent, every taxpayer and every
               British Columbia seeking answers from their government. I may say this once or twice through my comments here, but the people's business is
               the people's business. We always need to remember that when we sit in this House and
               we do things in this House. We are here at the behest of our voters and of the people
               that we represent out there. We believe and we feel that six months is not an unreasonable amount of time to ask
               to have a second sober look at this bill and make sure that we all get it right. If
               that side of the House gets it right, we will support it, but it has to be right,
               moving forward. Six months is what good legislators do when a bill is not quite ready
               here. We take some time to have a look at it. So what this hoist amendment is really about. This hoist amendment is about one thing
               — giving this Legislature the time to do its job, because this bill, this deeply consequential
               bill, has not been subjected to the level of scrutiny it deserves. Where was the full
               consultation with transparency experts? Where was the deep engagement with journalists?
               Where was the serious response to warnings from watchdog organizations? We mention those because we're not discussing the bill. We talked about that in the
               previous bill, but these are some of the things we're concerned about, and it's why
               we're looking at the hoist motion — to go back and answer the questions we didn't
               get answers for in the previous discussion and debate of the bill, in the beginning. Instead, we are asked to accept the government's word that this is modernization.
               Modernization — I'm not exactly sure what that word means in this respect. Is it updating?.
               Is it digitizing? What is it doing with this bill to make it more transparent, easily
               readable, that kind of thing? If weakening transparency is modernizing, then we have
               lost the meaning of the word. This government has a track record, and it is not a good one. Once again, I detailed
               that when I did my debate on Bill 9, so we won't reiterate that here. But we know
               that is why we want the hoist motion, because some of those answers were not forthcoming,
               and we're still trying to decide where this bill is going. They are attempting to make some modest amendments — the government on its own — to
               change the bill and try to make it a little bit more transparent, but it's not working.
               As some of my colleagues have mentioned in the past, they are simply a little bit
               of housekeeping amendments and everything, not really changing the gist of the bill
               to begin with. Hence our requirement, our ask for a hoist motion, to be able to take
               the time to look at some of the things that aren't working in this bill. One of the things, as well.... The record from the government is deeply concerning,
               and it should be. This is a government that has been called one of the most secretive
               in Canada. We've heard that numerous times here. We've heard it a number of times
               during the debate on Bill 9, and not only Bill 9 but previous bills that we have discussed
               here — about the way the government is trying to change things, drop it in behind,
               orders in council, those kinds of things. This is a government that received, obviously, the code of silence — a number of my
               colleagues have mentioned that before — from the journalists. Of course, the journalists
               are one of the largest groups that is showing some real concerns about where this
               bill is and their ability to be able to get the access they need to find out things
               like limo rides and things like that. It's been mentioned many times. So this is why
               we need the hoist motion to be able to go in and review and see if journalists, the
               general public, have ease of access. Remember that the people's business is the people's business, and we've got to make
               these bills as transparent and as flexible and available as possible for the general
               public. At the end of the day, we may sound like At the end of the day, we may sound like here.... I know some of the members on the
               other side — not particularly tonight, but earlier on — have been kind of critical
               of our thoughts on this and asking about this hoist motion to be able to go in and
               review this bill a little bit more thoroughly. But it's not rhetoric. There are some concerns there. Like we're saying, we're in
               here doing the people's business ourselves on this side, and this is what we're hearing
               out there in the general public — their concerns. They're bringing it forward to us,
               and we just want to make sure we're doing the right thing here and doing our work. We're here to work. That's why we're here. What time is it? It's almost 12:30, and
               we're in the House here, doing the work to make sure we get it right for the people,
               the people that we represent out there in the general public. So now this same government is asking us to pass legislation that further weakens
               access to information. We don't want to weaken. We want to strengthen. We want to
               give people the ability to be able to come in and access their information. It's their
               information. I think sometimes, as legislators, we might forget about that, but that's
               the most important. This is their information, and it should be accessible. They're
               the ones that pay the bills. They should know what they're buying. That, I think,
               is really important. Hence the hoist amendment so that we can go in and review that information and make
               sure that it's functioning for the people, the voters, the people that put us here
               in this House. That's what we're here for. I had a little note here, just reiterating
               again. It says: "The voters are wanting this." They are holding us accountable to
               make sure we get this right moving forward. Let's talk about the substance of the bill for a few minutes. The government will
               try to hide behind language like "efficiency" and "streamlining." Well, it seems a
               little clear. In our debate on Bill 9, which we're not debating here tonight.... We're
               debating the hoist motion. But back then, we talked about this. We brought a lot of
               this forward and centre to make sure that we could try to get answers that particular
               time through the debate. But now what we need is.... It looks like we're going to need some more time to analyze
               and review this and have a much deeper dive into the bill to make sure that we get
               this right, give the government a chance here. We're asking for six months on this
               hoist amendment so that we can go in and make sure it aligns properly. We want to modernize. We want to make sure of things here. We want to make sure that
               we're using the most modern and useful technology so people can have easy access into
               their own information. But I think this is some doublespeak for some language that's
               trying to shut it down. As a number of my colleagues have talked about, it's more
               about misinformation or disinformation or shutting the information down than it is
               about making it more accessible for the general public out there. When you strip everything away, what are we left with? Well, we're left with a bill
               that replaces "without delay" with "without reasonable delay." That's just one of
               the changes they fundamentally want to change in here, one of the small amendments. Now, I think a few of my colleagues have gone on and talked about this. We need a
               definition of what "reasonable" is. Without delay, without reasonable delay.... We're
               not really sure what unreasonable delay is. I think we've had some great examples. Somebody gets up out of the wrong side of the
               bed, and he decides he wants to reasonably delay somebody just because he's having
               a bad day or something. That's not the way we should be looking at using this information
               or anything like that. I'm really concerned. We need to really make sure the definition of "unreasonable"
               is here. With the hoist motion, we're going to be able to go in and look at these
               words, probably change the words up, make sure they're much tighter and people understand
               what that work really is. It'll expand the ability to disregard requests at the whim of somebody that, once
               again, has a bad day or something. They can disregard requests. There's no real strong
               definition around that. Let's go in and take the time and define that a little bit
               more tightly and make sure that we understand what disregarding requests really is. And it's here: "Increase discretion to reject or limit access." Well, that's not very
               good. I hear about limiting access and not allowing people access in countries other
               than Canada. We're a democratic country. We should be able to have it fairly wide
               open so that people can come and access their information. This hoist amendment will allow us to go in and fix that. Look at how we should be....
               How do we limit this without really limiting access? Once again, the people's business
               is the people's business. They should not be limited to the access that they have
               on their information. As well, it fails to address the real And as well, it fails to address the real problems within the system. There are a
               number of problems in the system. It has been slowed down in efficiency. The technology has been slow. The staffing has been limited. Those kinds of things.
               So this really hasn't been a lot of reform, it looks like. It just seems to be that
               instead of fixing the front end, they're doing it with the back end and doing some
               things to shut access down and make it tougher to get in to see the information that
               they have. When the B.C. Freedom of Information and Privacy Association reviewed this bill, they
               said it clearly: Bill 9 weakens access rights in British Columbia and expands government
               discretion to refuse, not just limit, requests. This is the verdict from the experts, once again, not from us. Don't shoot
               the messenger. So here we are. We're listening to the public out there, and then they're saying:
               "No, we're listening to the public out there." Our concern is, and why we're asking for this hoist motion, an amendment.... Is the
               government listening to the people out there? We're listening, because that's why
               we're here today. That's why we're sitting here at 12:30 at night discussing an amendment
               to a bill to slow things down so the government can go and listen to the people. Again I ask: why the rush? Why are we rushing this bill through? Why is it so important
               to get this bill through? I think we have some ideas why they might be doing this.
               But if this bill is so good, if it truly improves the transparency and access and
               is doing everything right, why not accept this hoist amendment? Why not take the six
               months to really tweak it, fine-tune it and clean it up? Unless, of course, the government knows what this bill actually does. The purpose of this hoist amendment is simple. Stop, pause, fix, reintroduce. Right
               now this bill does not fix the real problems. The real problem is not that citizens are asking too many questions. The real problem
               is that government is not responding fast enough. The real problem is poor recordkeeping, for one reason or another. And the real problem is backlog. They have got
               a tremendous backlog here that they are struggling with to get to. I have no idea what's happening in the back end there. But we need to slow down. We
               have to look at, find out what the backlog is, find what's going on. The real problem is a culture that sees transparency as a burden, not a responsibility.
               And instead of fixing those problems, this bill seems to be lowering the bar. So hence we get a hoist amendment in here so that we can have a look at that, maybe
               spend some time looking at the processes, the systems and finding out if there are
               ways we can improve them rather than with legislation that appears to be clamping
               down on everything, restricting access, charging fees that some people quite frankly
               don't have the money to be able to go, but they have legitimate reasons for coming
               and seeking information about their government, their business. I want to take a moment to reflect on something that was said in this very chamber
               not that many days ago, because it goes directly to the heart of why this hoist amendment
               is not only justified but absolutely necessary. During the debate on another bill
               in this House, a government member stood in this House and said something that, at
               the time, I agreed totally with. And I still agree with him. He said, and I am paraphrasing the sentiment from him, that we should take our time,
               that we should slow down, that we should make sure we get it right. He was talking
               about a bill that was already before the House, and this is what the member of the
               other House said. Listen to what he said. He said: "We need to take our time. We need
               to slow down and make sure it's right." That is what we're asking on this side of the House, on this particular bill. Slow
               down. Let's make sure we get it right.
Open source reference
2026-05-20 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: Public service

Today I want to recognize both the importance of honouring those who serve and the
               extraordinary organizations that support them when service takes its toll. First, I want to commend my colleague from Prince George–Valemount for her work in getting the month of November recognized as a time to honour first
               responders. That initiative sends a clear and important message that this House understands
               and values the sacrifice made every day by those who serve. In that same spirit, I want to speak about a place that brings that recognition to
               life. A number of colleagues and I recently had the opportunity to visit Honour Ranch,
               hence the pin. Just outside of Ashcroft, it is a place that leaves a lasting impression,
               not only for what it is but for what it represents — a quiet, compassionate commitment
               to those who have given so much in service to others. The reality is this. Service often comes with a cost that is not always visible. First
               responders run towards crisis, towards danger, towards moments that most of us would
               never choose to face. They carry not only the physical demands of their work but also
               the emotional and psychological weight that comes with it. Too often, that burden
               does not end when their shift ends. Honour House and Honour Ranch exist to meet that reality. Honour House provides a
               place to rest, recover, and dignity for first responders and their families. Honour
               Ranch builds on that mission, offering a long-term path to healing through connection,
               nature and community. Together, they send a powerful message that those who serve
               us should never have to heal alone. At the heart of this work is a story that underscores why it matters so deeply. Captain
               Trevor Greene, a Canadian soldier, was critically injured while serving in Afghanistan.
               His journey of recovery, supported by the unwavering care of his wife Debbie, became
               a powerful symbol for resilience and helped inspired the creation of Honour House
               so that others facing profound challenges would have a place to turn. Honour House and Honour Ranch are more than facilities. They are a promise — a promise
               that we will stand by those who have stood for us — and they remind us that behind
               every uniform is a person who deserves not only our respect but our care.
Open source reference
Community Life: 1 contributions
2026-05-28 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: Family

One of the great privileges we have as being members of this House is being able to
               stand and recognize friends and families for birthdays, anniversaries and, today,
               graduations. My wife and I have three daughters graduating from high school this year. We're very
               proud of them — Emily Luck, Cadence Tyack and Kailey Ross. Kailey has accepted a four-year division 1 softball scholarship My wife and I have three daughters graduating from high school this year. We're very
               proud of them. Emily Luck, Cadence Tyack, and Kailey Ross. Kailey has accepted a four-year division 1 softball scholarship at Stetson University
               in Florida, so we're very proud of her. She's worked very, very hard for that and
               we're looking forward.... The last time I spoke to her, she wants to do medicine, hopefully
               become a doctor. So I said: "That'd be great, we need you in B.C. So you get that,
               that'd be fantastic." I'd also like to recognize our granddaughter Josephine Sheldon, who graduated last
               year. She's been called on a mission from her church to go to Sapporo, Japan for 18
               months. We're really proud of her as well. So thank you very much, everyone, for allowing me to introduce them and we're really
               proud of them as grandparents.
Open source reference
Education: 1 contributions
2026-05-28 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: Family education, Scholarships

One of the great privileges we have as being members of this House is being able to
               stand and recognize friends and families for birthdays, anniversaries and, today,
               graduations. My wife and I have three daughters graduating from high school this year. We're very
               proud of them — Emily Luck, Cadence Tyack and Kailey Ross. Kailey has accepted a four-year division 1 softball scholarship My wife and I have three daughters graduating from high school this year. We're very
               proud of them. Emily Luck, Cadence Tyack, and Kailey Ross. Kailey has accepted a four-year division 1 softball scholarship at Stetson University
               in Florida, so we're very proud of her. She's worked very, very hard for that and
               we're looking forward.... The last time I spoke to her, she wants to do medicine, hopefully
               become a doctor. So I said: "That'd be great, we need you in B.C. So you get that,
               that'd be fantastic." I'd also like to recognize our granddaughter Josephine Sheldon, who graduated last
               year. She's been called on a mission from her church to go to Sapporo, Japan for 18
               months. We're really proud of her as well. So thank you very much, everyone, for allowing me to introduce them and we're really
               proud of them as grandparents.
Open source reference
Public Safety & Justice: 1 contributions
2026-05-20 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: Emergency services

Today I want to recognize both the importance of honouring those who serve and the
               extraordinary organizations that support them when service takes its toll. First, I want to commend my colleague from Prince George–Valemount for her work in getting the month of November recognized as a time to honour first
               responders. That initiative sends a clear and important message that this House understands
               and values the sacrifice made every day by those who serve. In that same spirit, I want to speak about a place that brings that recognition to
               life. A number of colleagues and I recently had the opportunity to visit Honour Ranch,
               hence the pin. Just outside of Ashcroft, it is a place that leaves a lasting impression,
               not only for what it is but for what it represents — a quiet, compassionate commitment
               to those who have given so much in service to others. The reality is this. Service often comes with a cost that is not always visible. First
               responders run towards crisis, towards danger, towards moments that most of us would
               never choose to face. They carry not only the physical demands of their work but also
               the emotional and psychological weight that comes with it. Too often, that burden
               does not end when their shift ends. Honour House and Honour Ranch exist to meet that reality. Honour House provides a
               place to rest, recover, and dignity for first responders and their families. Honour
               Ranch builds on that mission, offering a long-term path to healing through connection,
               nature and community. Together, they send a powerful message that those who serve
               us should never have to heal alone. At the heart of this work is a story that underscores why it matters so deeply. Captain
               Trevor Greene, a Canadian soldier, was critically injured while serving in Afghanistan.
               His journey of recovery, supported by the unwavering care of his wife Debbie, became
               a powerful symbol for resilience and helped inspired the creation of Honour House
               so that others facing profound challenges would have a place to turn. Honour House and Honour Ranch are more than facilities. They are a promise — a promise
               that we will stand by those who have stood for us — and they remind us that behind
               every uniform is a person who deserves not only our respect but our care.
Open source reference
Science & Technology: 1 contributions
2026-05-06 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: Information dissemination

It's a real pleasure to be here this evening. It reminds me of the old days when
               we used to do all-nighters and things like that. So here we are, an all-nighter. It's
               been a long time. So I'm really looking forward to this, to being able to speak to
               this motion that we've got on the floor here, this hoist motion. Tonight I want to say strongly that I do support the hoist amendment to Bill 9, the
               Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Amendment Act. I think it's a very important thing we're looking at today, because it's one of
               those little small things that define democracy in the end, right? Let me be absolutely clear at the outset about this hoist amendment, what it really
               does, why it really matters in the long term and why it is absolutely necessary that
               we move this as soon as possible. This hoist amendment proposes that the word "now"
               be replaced with "six months hence." I know we've heard that a lot today and the last
               day or two, but once again, I'll repeat it for the viewers out there that have tuned
               in late to this show tonight. I just want to make sure that they're very clear what
               we're trying to do here. We're not trying to defeat this bill, kill the bill, do anything like that. What we
               want to do is have a serious, second, sober look at this bill because there are some
               gaps in it. What we want to do is just extend it for six months, bring it back in
               the fall, allow the government to take some time over the summer vacation here — unfortunately,
               they'll have to work a little bit of their vacation — come back, have another look
               at this and fill in some of the gaps that we're really concerned about. It's not just us that are really concerned about the gaps. It's industry out there.
               It's other businesses. It's FOI associations and groups that have sown some real concern
               about it. I think in my original speech on Bill 9 I talked about that, and I made
               it very clear. We're not here to talk about the bill tonight. We're here to talk about
               the hoist amendment. So we just want to make sure that it's very, very clear that
               we're talking about the hoist and what it wants to do here. Six months to do what this government has failed to do. What are some of the things
               that it has failed to do? Well, it's failed to properly examine the bill, put it under
               a microscope and look at some of the finer details. We know this is the history of
               this government and what they don't do. That's properly consult. We hear that all
               the time, everywhere we go. They haven't properly consulted. So we need to go back
               and properly consult on this bill and properly understand the consequences of this
               deeply flawed legislation because that is what a hoist amendment is for. It's to be
               able to bring and shine the light on some things where there's some holes in it and
               have a look at that and try to improve where we can. The hoist amendment is not about the delay for the sake of delay. We don't want to
               do that. We all believe in properly effective, properly working freedom of information.
               I think that's a really important piece of legislation that this House can do and
               what we have in modern society today. I think it's really important to make sure we
               get it right, make sure we have the right timelines and the right costs. If there
               is a cost, there probably shouldn't be a cost, and that kind of thing, but some of
               the right things we do here. It's about preventing bad laws from being passed in haste. That's what this actually
               looks like. It looks like a bill that's being tried and passed in haste, rushed through.
               So you have to ask the question. Why are we trying to rush this bill through? I'll
               talk a little bit more about that, about rushing things, as I go along here. But it's also about forcing government to take a second, sober look when it has clearly
               gotten it wrong the first time, and this government has gotten it wrong. As I mentioned
               before, it's not just us saying this and other groups. This bill is not ready, and
               that is why this hoist amendment is absolutely necessary as we move forward here. It is not refined, and it certainly is not a balanced bill, as we've seen, as we have
               talked about, in the bill itself. It's not rooted in strengthening transparency. It
               seems more to do with shutting down transparency. This hoist motion will be there
               so we can go and look with clarity of how we can strengthen transparency because that's
               what's This hoist motion will be there so we can go and look, with clarity, at how we can
               strengthen transparency, because that's what it's all about — making sure everybody
               understands exactly what's happening, how the process is to work. It is a bill that weakens access right, expands government discretion and tilts the
               balance away from the public and towards the state, and that is precisely why this
               hoist motion must be passed — to go in and have a look at how it does that and how
               we can pull that back and rebalance the bill, moving forward here. If we allow this
               bill to proceed now, we are knowingly allowing flawed legislation to pass into law,
               legislation that will impact every journalist, every parent, every taxpayer and every
               British Columbia seeking answers from their government. I may say this once or twice through my comments here, but the people's business is
               the people's business. We always need to remember that when we sit in this House and
               we do things in this House. We are here at the behest of our voters and of the people
               that we represent out there. We believe and we feel that six months is not an unreasonable amount of time to ask
               to have a second sober look at this bill and make sure that we all get it right. If
               that side of the House gets it right, we will support it, but it has to be right,
               moving forward. Six months is what good legislators do when a bill is not quite ready
               here. We take some time to have a look at it. So what this hoist amendment is really about. This hoist amendment is about one thing
               — giving this Legislature the time to do its job, because this bill, this deeply consequential
               bill, has not been subjected to the level of scrutiny it deserves. Where was the full
               consultation with transparency experts? Where was the deep engagement with journalists?
               Where was the serious response to warnings from watchdog organizations? We mention those because we're not discussing the bill. We talked about that in the
               previous bill, but these are some of the things we're concerned about, and it's why
               we're looking at the hoist motion — to go back and answer the questions we didn't
               get answers for in the previous discussion and debate of the bill, in the beginning. Instead, we are asked to accept the government's word that this is modernization.
               Modernization — I'm not exactly sure what that word means in this respect. Is it updating?.
               Is it digitizing? What is it doing with this bill to make it more transparent, easily
               readable, that kind of thing? If weakening transparency is modernizing, then we have
               lost the meaning of the word. This government has a track record, and it is not a good one. Once again, I detailed
               that when I did my debate on Bill 9, so we won't reiterate that here. But we know
               that is why we want the hoist motion, because some of those answers were not forthcoming,
               and we're still trying to decide where this bill is going. They are attempting to make some modest amendments — the government on its own — to
               change the bill and try to make it a little bit more transparent, but it's not working.
               As some of my colleagues have mentioned in the past, they are simply a little bit
               of housekeeping amendments and everything, not really changing the gist of the bill
               to begin with. Hence our requirement, our ask for a hoist motion, to be able to take
               the time to look at some of the things that aren't working in this bill. One of the things, as well.... The record from the government is deeply concerning,
               and it should be. This is a government that has been called one of the most secretive
               in Canada. We've heard that numerous times here. We've heard it a number of times
               during the debate on Bill 9, and not only Bill 9 but previous bills that we have discussed
               here — about the way the government is trying to change things, drop it in behind,
               orders in council, those kinds of things. This is a government that received, obviously, the code of silence — a number of my
               colleagues have mentioned that before — from the journalists. Of course, the journalists
               are one of the largest groups that is showing some real concerns about where this
               bill is and their ability to be able to get the access they need to find out things
               like limo rides and things like that. It's been mentioned many times. So this is why
               we need the hoist motion to be able to go in and review and see if journalists, the
               general public, have ease of access. Remember that the people's business is the people's business, and we've got to make
               these bills as transparent and as flexible and available as possible for the general
               public. At the end of the day, we may sound like At the end of the day, we may sound like here.... I know some of the members on the
               other side — not particularly tonight, but earlier on — have been kind of critical
               of our thoughts on this and asking about this hoist motion to be able to go in and
               review this bill a little bit more thoroughly. But it's not rhetoric. There are some concerns there. Like we're saying, we're in
               here doing the people's business ourselves on this side, and this is what we're hearing
               out there in the general public — their concerns. They're bringing it forward to us,
               and we just want to make sure we're doing the right thing here and doing our work. We're here to work. That's why we're here. What time is it? It's almost 12:30, and
               we're in the House here, doing the work to make sure we get it right for the people,
               the people that we represent out there in the general public. So now this same government is asking us to pass legislation that further weakens
               access to information. We don't want to weaken. We want to strengthen. We want to
               give people the ability to be able to come in and access their information. It's their
               information. I think sometimes, as legislators, we might forget about that, but that's
               the most important. This is their information, and it should be accessible. They're
               the ones that pay the bills. They should know what they're buying. That, I think,
               is really important. Hence the hoist amendment so that we can go in and review that information and make
               sure that it's functioning for the people, the voters, the people that put us here
               in this House. That's what we're here for. I had a little note here, just reiterating
               again. It says: "The voters are wanting this." They are holding us accountable to
               make sure we get this right moving forward. Let's talk about the substance of the bill for a few minutes. The government will
               try to hide behind language like "efficiency" and "streamlining." Well, it seems a
               little clear. In our debate on Bill 9, which we're not debating here tonight.... We're
               debating the hoist motion. But back then, we talked about this. We brought a lot of
               this forward and centre to make sure that we could try to get answers that particular
               time through the debate. But now what we need is.... It looks like we're going to need some more time to analyze
               and review this and have a much deeper dive into the bill to make sure that we get
               this right, give the government a chance here. We're asking for six months on this
               hoist amendment so that we can go in and make sure it aligns properly. We want to modernize. We want to make sure of things here. We want to make sure that
               we're using the most modern and useful technology so people can have easy access into
               their own information. But I think this is some doublespeak for some language that's
               trying to shut it down. As a number of my colleagues have talked about, it's more
               about misinformation or disinformation or shutting the information down than it is
               about making it more accessible for the general public out there. When you strip everything away, what are we left with? Well, we're left with a bill
               that replaces "without delay" with "without reasonable delay." That's just one of
               the changes they fundamentally want to change in here, one of the small amendments. Now, I think a few of my colleagues have gone on and talked about this. We need a
               definition of what "reasonable" is. Without delay, without reasonable delay.... We're
               not really sure what unreasonable delay is. I think we've had some great examples. Somebody gets up out of the wrong side of the
               bed, and he decides he wants to reasonably delay somebody just because he's having
               a bad day or something. That's not the way we should be looking at using this information
               or anything like that. I'm really concerned. We need to really make sure the definition of "unreasonable"
               is here. With the hoist motion, we're going to be able to go in and look at these
               words, probably change the words up, make sure they're much tighter and people understand
               what that work really is. It'll expand the ability to disregard requests at the whim of somebody that, once
               again, has a bad day or something. They can disregard requests. There's no real strong
               definition around that. Let's go in and take the time and define that a little bit
               more tightly and make sure that we understand what disregarding requests really is. And it's here: "Increase discretion to reject or limit access." Well, that's not very
               good. I hear about limiting access and not allowing people access in countries other
               than Canada. We're a democratic country. We should be able to have it fairly wide
               open so that people can come and access their information. This hoist amendment will allow us to go in and fix that. Look at how we should be....
               How do we limit this without really limiting access? Once again, the people's business
               is the people's business. They should not be limited to the access that they have
               on their information. As well, it fails to address the real And as well, it fails to address the real problems within the system. There are a
               number of problems in the system. It has been slowed down in efficiency. The technology has been slow. The staffing has been limited. Those kinds of things.
               So this really hasn't been a lot of reform, it looks like. It just seems to be that
               instead of fixing the front end, they're doing it with the back end and doing some
               things to shut access down and make it tougher to get in to see the information that
               they have. When the B.C. Freedom of Information and Privacy Association reviewed this bill, they
               said it clearly: Bill 9 weakens access rights in British Columbia and expands government
               discretion to refuse, not just limit, requests. This is the verdict from the experts, once again, not from us. Don't shoot
               the messenger. So here we are. We're listening to the public out there, and then they're saying:
               "No, we're listening to the public out there." Our concern is, and why we're asking for this hoist motion, an amendment.... Is the
               government listening to the people out there? We're listening, because that's why
               we're here today. That's why we're sitting here at 12:30 at night discussing an amendment
               to a bill to slow things down so the government can go and listen to the people. Again I ask: why the rush? Why are we rushing this bill through? Why is it so important
               to get this bill through? I think we have some ideas why they might be doing this.
               But if this bill is so good, if it truly improves the transparency and access and
               is doing everything right, why not accept this hoist amendment? Why not take the six
               months to really tweak it, fine-tune it and clean it up? Unless, of course, the government knows what this bill actually does. The purpose of this hoist amendment is simple. Stop, pause, fix, reintroduce. Right
               now this bill does not fix the real problems. The real problem is not that citizens are asking too many questions. The real problem
               is that government is not responding fast enough. The real problem is poor recordkeeping, for one reason or another. And the real problem is backlog. They have got
               a tremendous backlog here that they are struggling with to get to. I have no idea what's happening in the back end there. But we need to slow down. We
               have to look at, find out what the backlog is, find what's going on. The real problem is a culture that sees transparency as a burden, not a responsibility.
               And instead of fixing those problems, this bill seems to be lowering the bar. So hence we get a hoist amendment in here so that we can have a look at that, maybe
               spend some time looking at the processes, the systems and finding out if there are
               ways we can improve them rather than with legislation that appears to be clamping
               down on everything, restricting access, charging fees that some people quite frankly
               don't have the money to be able to go, but they have legitimate reasons for coming
               and seeking information about their government, their business. I want to take a moment to reflect on something that was said in this very chamber
               not that many days ago, because it goes directly to the heart of why this hoist amendment
               is not only justified but absolutely necessary. During the debate on another bill
               in this House, a government member stood in this House and said something that, at
               the time, I agreed totally with. And I still agree with him. He said, and I am paraphrasing the sentiment from him, that we should take our time,
               that we should slow down, that we should make sure we get it right. He was talking
               about a bill that was already before the House, and this is what the member of the
               other House said. Listen to what he said. He said: "We need to take our time. We need
               to slow down and make sure it's right." That is what we're asking on this side of the House, on this particular bill. Slow
               down. Let's make sure we get it right.
Open source reference
Defence & Foreign Affairs: 0 contributions
Economy & Employment: 0 contributions
Environment & Resources: 0 contributions
Health: 0 contributions
Housing & Development: 0 contributions
Public Finance: 0 contributions
Rights & Inclusion: 0 contributions
Social Services: 0 contributions
Transportation: 0 contributions