7 recorded contributions
Jev-reviewed existing detailed tags · editorial review required
Accepted detailed tags: Hydropower
If B.C. Hydro loses this case, all 119 independent power projects are at risk of higher
costs if the supplier has Aboriginal ownership, which will fuel already existing economic
uncertainty in the province. To the Premier: will you ensure that B.C. Hydro customers...Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Forestry
I rise today to speak of something that's quite dear to my heart, and that of course
is the community of Peace River South, or the riding of Peace River South, and, more importantly, the beautiful people that live in that region. This region
is not only a wonderful place to live, work and raise a family but also one of the
true economic engines of British Columbia, and I think that's quite often forgotten. Every single day, the hard-working people of Peace River South help drive the provincial
economy forward. Our region produces the energy that heats homes and powers industries.
Our farmers and ranchers help feed communities across Canada and beyond. Our forestry
sector supports jobs, manufacturing, while our tradespeople, truck drivers, contractors
and small businesses keep northern British Columbia moving. From natural gas and forestry to agriculture, mining, tourism and transportation,
Peace River South plays a critical role in generating the wealth and economic activity that supports
services and infrastructure throughout this province. Our riding is also home to critical infrastructure that connects northeast British
Columbia, including the Taylor Bridge, an important transportation link relied on
every day by residents, workers and industry, and of course, in addition, the very
well-known Site C dam and the lesser known, perhaps, Peace Canyon dam. As I've said,
the true strength of Peace River South is its people. Northern British Columbia has always stepped up for this province. The people of Peace River South ask for very little in relation to what we provide. When Peace River South succeeds, British Columbia succeeds. Our region is more than a point on a map. It
is a major contributor to the prosperity of this province and a reminder that the
hard-working people of rural and northern British Columbia remain essential to our
collective future.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Fuels, Propane
My colleague from across the way beat me to it, but I would like to reiterate a welcome
for the Canadian Propane Association — Chris Crawford, Courtney Seir-Todd, Clint Hillman,
Kellan Foreman, Katie Kachur and Nancy Borden. As we all know, propane is one of the cleanest burning fuels available, and with world
events, certainly, there is a massive uptick in demand for the product. I believe
that British Columbia should be proud to be able to provide that very valuable fuel
to the world. Please help me make them feel welcome.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Economic issues, Investments
I'm here today to speak about Bill 20, and I think I can make comments that most,
if not all — certainly, I would think most, the vast majority — in this House would
agree with. I would say that without question reconciliation matters, treaties matter,
and without question the recognition of Indigenous rights is not optional. That's
section 35 of the constitution. Many would suggest, and I'm not saying that I would
disagree with it, that it's the foundation of the future of the province and perhaps
even the country. From a very pragmatic perspective, though, I would also suggest that supporting reconciliation
does not, in any way, suspend scrutiny, nor should it. In fact, I would say that it
demands the opposite. It requires that we examine both carefully and honestly whether
the mechanisms we are putting forward will actually achieve what those mechanisms
promise and what the future needs. That's the responsibility that is before us today. Certainly, we're not trying to decide whether reconciliation is important. Again,
that's been established. What is important for us to determine, when we're discussing
Bill 20, is whether the bill moves us closer to reconciliation or if it drives a wedge
and creates conflict and moves us away from that goal. I would say that good intentions are not enough, certainly not in terms of legislation
of this magnitude. We're not dealing with a short-term policy. As my colleague prior
stated, this work has been underway for 30 years — so certainly, not short-term policy.
We are dealing with agreements that will shape governance, not only in the province
but may even affect beyond those borders. We're dealing with agreements that will
shape land use, will affect economic opportunity and potentially affect legal relationships
for generations. The question is not: do we support reconciliation? I've already stated that. The question
is: are we building that admirable goal on a foundation that will hold? I believe that it's important for Bill 20 to be understood as part of a wider transformation
tied to the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act. I know that that
raised some concerns from across the way, but bear with me, and I will attempt to
explain as to why I believe that's important. The framework has, to date, introduced
shifts in how decisions are interpreted in this province. I don't know that's.... Maybe
leave it right there.... What have we observed? We have observed uncertainty. We have observed evolving interpretations.
We have observed a lack of consistency in how principles are applied across sectors What have we observed? We have observed uncertainty. We have observed evolving interpretations.
We have observed a lack of consistency in how principles are applied across sectors.
One might even suggest the government has even acknowledged this. I wouldn't even
say "suggested." It has been said in this House. Now, rather than resolving those uncertainties within statute, Bill 20 proposes to
elevate similar concepts into constitutionally protected agreements. I think that
that's something that is exceedingly important for us to establish and discuss as
part of the debate process. It's a significant escalation. This is moving toward constitutionally
protected agreements, and that is something that is at a magnitude that I don't know
everyone that has spoken to this has illustrated to the most effective manner possible. I would suggest that we need to pause and reflect on the difference between ordinary
legislation and treaties, represented by Bill 20 in this case. They are not compatible. Correction. I will correct myself and withdraw that word. They are not comparable. If a statute produces unintended consequences, the Legislature can revisit it. Everyone
that's in this place of honour is very aware of the mechanisms, or most of the mechanisms,
that are available to do that. We can amend it. We can fix it. However, when a treaty
is ratified, it becomes part of the constitutional architecture of Canada. This means
that it is far more difficult to change, its interpretation is largely shaped through
courts, and its effects extend far beyond the control of any single government. So we must ask: are we embedding clarity, or are we embedding uncertainty at the highest
level of law? Bill 20 introduces a model that relies heavily on interpretation over time, thereby
illustrating the risk of open-ended design. Some would describe this as flexibility. Others
would describe it as adaptability. There is another way to describe it: indeterminacy. When key elements are not clearly defined at the outset, they do not disappear. They
simply shift into other arenas. They shift into courts, tribunals, arbitration processes
and prolonged negotiations. This is certainly not theoretical. That is exactly what
happens when agreements lack precision. Many here would agree that that is exactly
what we've seen for so many years. The question could be asked: what are treaties supposed to do? I would suggest if
you ask ten different people, you might get ten almost slightly, if not even significantly,
different answers. Historically, modern treaties in Canada have been designed to accomplish something
very specific. They are meant to settle questions, not extend them. They are meant
to define rights, they are meant to establish jurisdiction, and they are meant to
create certainty moving forward. We have seen several examples of this approach. I would go further to say that these examples are not entirely without challenge,
but they do provide a level of predictability. They allow governments to function.
They allow communities to plan and economies to operate. Some would suggest that Bill
20 moves in a different direction, from certainty to continuous interpretation. It could be interpreted that instead of resolving key questions at the outset, the model
represented by Bill 20 anticipates ongoing interpretation and potential ongoing change.
Instead of clearly delineating boundaries, it leaves space for those boundaries to
evolve. Another critical issue is the process. I would suggest that reconciliation is not
only about agreements between governments, it is also about relationships between
nations. We are hearing legitimate concerns as we're listening to different speakers.
We're hearing about overlapping claims. We're hearing about competing interests. And
we're hearing about insufficient engagement with neighbouring communities. Clearly,
to me, those concerns cannot and should not be brushed aside, because unresolved overlap
does not resolve itself following ratification. It only intensifies. When agreements proceed without alignment, the consequences are certainly predictable
— legal challenges, fractured relationships and delays in implementation. Many would
suggest that that is not reconciliation, that in fact it is conflict deferred. We also have a responsibility to consider the economic implications of this legislation,
Bill 20. In regions like northeast British Columbia, where I live, economic activity
is closely tied to natural resource development, infrastructure investment and long-term
regulatory certainty. Some of the statements that I've certainly made in this House,
and I intend to make many more, are that I don't think many people fully appreciate
the economic engine to the province of British Columbia represented by northeast British
Columbia. If we are not utilizing something like Bill 20 to ensure that certainty is provided,
then the concern lies as to whether that economic engine and, ultimately, the province
is successful financially. Projects in these sectors are capital intensive. That's where I spent the majority
of my career, if not all of it. And it's clear from my experience, and from everything
that I've been told through that experience, that these capital-intensive projects
require some very clear timelines to be fully successful. They require defined authorities,
and they require stable rules. The question is: does Bill 20 provide those three items? Should those elements become unclear, investment decisions are potentially subject
to change. That change, should it ever occur, is certainly not because investors are
opposed to reconciliation, but because uncertainty, without question, carries a cost.
As we have established in this place of honour, capital is mobile. Does Bill 20 provide
the certainty that is required by the investment market? We have seen situations where opportunities in energy and resource development have
moved elsewhere, even when British Columbia has had a competitive advantage. I've
seen that on a daily basis where I live. It is challenging. The certainty, which.... Again, I'm questioning whether Bill 20 provides that certainty
to the billions of dollars of investment that we require in the northeast. I'm concerned
from that perspective as to whether or not the certainty is there for the billions
of dollars to be invested. I would clearly say that reconciliation cannot succeed in a vacuum. It requires public
understanding. Does Bill 20 provide that public understanding? People in the public
need to know what is being agreed to, how decisions will be made and how accountability
will be maintained. Should that understanding be absent, support may become fragile. Does Bill 20 check
those two boxes and provide what is needed? In the absence of broad support, clearly,
progress becomes difficult to sustain. Transparency is not a procedural detail. It
is a requirement for long-term success. One of the most important questions in this debate is, which is questionable as to
whether Bill 20 identifies it clearly.... The question would be: where does decision-making
authority ultimately reside? And in that case, again, attracting significant capital
to this province that's needed to push forward on these incredibly important projects
— does Bill 20 advance that fundamental need? If authority becomes increasingly distributed across courts, arbitration bodies and
evolving interpretive frameworks, then the role of this Legislature may change. Does
that provide certainty? Does the bill before us provide that certainty? With a potential change comes a question of accountability. This House is accountable
to the people of British Columbia. Every one of us here at some point in the future,
should we choose to continue down this path, will be facing our electorate once more,
and we will be held accountable for the decisions that are made here. I would suggest that many, if not the vast majority of the populace, would say that
that principle must remain intact, that principle of accountability. I would go further
to suggest that any shift in governance must be clearly understood and very clearly
justified. In no way am I calling for an abandonment of progress. I'm making a call to strengthen
it. We can move forward, but we must do so carefully. One would suggest that the meaning
of moving forward carefully would be ensuring overlapping claims are addressed before
agreements are finalized, reinforcing clarity in treaty language and maintaining transparency
throughout the process. It means learning from agreements that have worked and avoiding
unnecessary departures from previously successful models. It also means prioritizing
durability over speed. The decisions we make here will not be judged next year. They will not be judged during
the next election cycle. They will be judged decades from now. These decisions will
be judged on whether they created clarity or confusion, stability or uncertainty,
trust or division. The question before us this afternoon is: does Bill 20 represent
those three points? Reconciliation does deserve Reconciliation does deserve to succeed. Success is not guaranteed. It must be built.
And it must be built on a foundation that is clear, stable and understood by all parties
involved. We remain committed to working constructively, to improving the framework and to ensuring
that reconciliation in British Columbia is not only advanced but sustained. This work
is too important to rush. Let us take the time to do it properly. And with that, thank
you very much.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Economic development
I rise today to speak of something that's quite dear to my heart, and that of course
is the community of Peace River South, or the riding of Peace River South, and, more importantly, the beautiful people that live in that region. This region
is not only a wonderful place to live, work and raise a family but also one of the
true economic engines of British Columbia, and I think that's quite often forgotten. Every single day, the hard-working people of Peace River South help drive the provincial
economy forward. Our region produces the energy that heats homes and powers industries.
Our farmers and ranchers help feed communities across Canada and beyond. Our forestry
sector supports jobs, manufacturing, while our tradespeople, truck drivers, contractors
and small businesses keep northern British Columbia moving. From natural gas and forestry to agriculture, mining, tourism and transportation,
Peace River South plays a critical role in generating the wealth and economic activity that supports
services and infrastructure throughout this province. Our riding is also home to critical infrastructure that connects northeast British
Columbia, including the Taylor Bridge, an important transportation link relied on
every day by residents, workers and industry, and of course, in addition, the very
well-known Site C dam and the lesser known, perhaps, Peace Canyon dam. As I've said,
the true strength of Peace River South is its people. Northern British Columbia has always stepped up for this province. The people of Peace River South ask for very little in relation to what we provide. When Peace River South succeeds, British Columbia succeeds. Our region is more than a point on a map. It
is a major contributor to the prosperity of this province and a reminder that the
hard-working people of rural and northern British Columbia remain essential to our
collective future.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Constitutional law, Provincial governments
I'm here today to speak about Bill 20, and I think I can make comments that most,
if not all — certainly, I would think most, the vast majority — in this House would
agree with. I would say that without question reconciliation matters, treaties matter,
and without question the recognition of Indigenous rights is not optional. That's
section 35 of the constitution. Many would suggest, and I'm not saying that I would
disagree with it, that it's the foundation of the future of the province and perhaps
even the country. From a very pragmatic perspective, though, I would also suggest that supporting reconciliation
does not, in any way, suspend scrutiny, nor should it. In fact, I would say that it
demands the opposite. It requires that we examine both carefully and honestly whether
the mechanisms we are putting forward will actually achieve what those mechanisms
promise and what the future needs. That's the responsibility that is before us today. Certainly, we're not trying to decide whether reconciliation is important. Again,
that's been established. What is important for us to determine, when we're discussing
Bill 20, is whether the bill moves us closer to reconciliation or if it drives a wedge
and creates conflict and moves us away from that goal. I would say that good intentions are not enough, certainly not in terms of legislation
of this magnitude. We're not dealing with a short-term policy. As my colleague prior
stated, this work has been underway for 30 years — so certainly, not short-term policy.
We are dealing with agreements that will shape governance, not only in the province
but may even affect beyond those borders. We're dealing with agreements that will
shape land use, will affect economic opportunity and potentially affect legal relationships
for generations. The question is not: do we support reconciliation? I've already stated that. The question
is: are we building that admirable goal on a foundation that will hold? I believe that it's important for Bill 20 to be understood as part of a wider transformation
tied to the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act. I know that that
raised some concerns from across the way, but bear with me, and I will attempt to
explain as to why I believe that's important. The framework has, to date, introduced
shifts in how decisions are interpreted in this province. I don't know that's.... Maybe
leave it right there.... What have we observed? We have observed uncertainty. We have observed evolving interpretations.
We have observed a lack of consistency in how principles are applied across sectors What have we observed? We have observed uncertainty. We have observed evolving interpretations.
We have observed a lack of consistency in how principles are applied across sectors.
One might even suggest the government has even acknowledged this. I wouldn't even
say "suggested." It has been said in this House. Now, rather than resolving those uncertainties within statute, Bill 20 proposes to
elevate similar concepts into constitutionally protected agreements. I think that
that's something that is exceedingly important for us to establish and discuss as
part of the debate process. It's a significant escalation. This is moving toward constitutionally
protected agreements, and that is something that is at a magnitude that I don't know
everyone that has spoken to this has illustrated to the most effective manner possible. I would suggest that we need to pause and reflect on the difference between ordinary
legislation and treaties, represented by Bill 20 in this case. They are not compatible. Correction. I will correct myself and withdraw that word. They are not comparable. If a statute produces unintended consequences, the Legislature can revisit it. Everyone
that's in this place of honour is very aware of the mechanisms, or most of the mechanisms,
that are available to do that. We can amend it. We can fix it. However, when a treaty
is ratified, it becomes part of the constitutional architecture of Canada. This means
that it is far more difficult to change, its interpretation is largely shaped through
courts, and its effects extend far beyond the control of any single government. So we must ask: are we embedding clarity, or are we embedding uncertainty at the highest
level of law? Bill 20 introduces a model that relies heavily on interpretation over time, thereby
illustrating the risk of open-ended design. Some would describe this as flexibility. Others
would describe it as adaptability. There is another way to describe it: indeterminacy. When key elements are not clearly defined at the outset, they do not disappear. They
simply shift into other arenas. They shift into courts, tribunals, arbitration processes
and prolonged negotiations. This is certainly not theoretical. That is exactly what
happens when agreements lack precision. Many here would agree that that is exactly
what we've seen for so many years. The question could be asked: what are treaties supposed to do? I would suggest if
you ask ten different people, you might get ten almost slightly, if not even significantly,
different answers. Historically, modern treaties in Canada have been designed to accomplish something
very specific. They are meant to settle questions, not extend them. They are meant
to define rights, they are meant to establish jurisdiction, and they are meant to
create certainty moving forward. We have seen several examples of this approach. I would go further to say that these examples are not entirely without challenge,
but they do provide a level of predictability. They allow governments to function.
They allow communities to plan and economies to operate. Some would suggest that Bill
20 moves in a different direction, from certainty to continuous interpretation. It could be interpreted that instead of resolving key questions at the outset, the model
represented by Bill 20 anticipates ongoing interpretation and potential ongoing change.
Instead of clearly delineating boundaries, it leaves space for those boundaries to
evolve. Another critical issue is the process. I would suggest that reconciliation is not
only about agreements between governments, it is also about relationships between
nations. We are hearing legitimate concerns as we're listening to different speakers.
We're hearing about overlapping claims. We're hearing about competing interests. And
we're hearing about insufficient engagement with neighbouring communities. Clearly,
to me, those concerns cannot and should not be brushed aside, because unresolved overlap
does not resolve itself following ratification. It only intensifies. When agreements proceed without alignment, the consequences are certainly predictable
— legal challenges, fractured relationships and delays in implementation. Many would
suggest that that is not reconciliation, that in fact it is conflict deferred. We also have a responsibility to consider the economic implications of this legislation,
Bill 20. In regions like northeast British Columbia, where I live, economic activity
is closely tied to natural resource development, infrastructure investment and long-term
regulatory certainty. Some of the statements that I've certainly made in this House,
and I intend to make many more, are that I don't think many people fully appreciate
the economic engine to the province of British Columbia represented by northeast British
Columbia. If we are not utilizing something like Bill 20 to ensure that certainty is provided,
then the concern lies as to whether that economic engine and, ultimately, the province
is successful financially. Projects in these sectors are capital intensive. That's where I spent the majority
of my career, if not all of it. And it's clear from my experience, and from everything
that I've been told through that experience, that these capital-intensive projects
require some very clear timelines to be fully successful. They require defined authorities,
and they require stable rules. The question is: does Bill 20 provide those three items? Should those elements become unclear, investment decisions are potentially subject
to change. That change, should it ever occur, is certainly not because investors are
opposed to reconciliation, but because uncertainty, without question, carries a cost.
As we have established in this place of honour, capital is mobile. Does Bill 20 provide
the certainty that is required by the investment market? We have seen situations where opportunities in energy and resource development have
moved elsewhere, even when British Columbia has had a competitive advantage. I've
seen that on a daily basis where I live. It is challenging. The certainty, which.... Again, I'm questioning whether Bill 20 provides that certainty
to the billions of dollars of investment that we require in the northeast. I'm concerned
from that perspective as to whether or not the certainty is there for the billions
of dollars to be invested. I would clearly say that reconciliation cannot succeed in a vacuum. It requires public
understanding. Does Bill 20 provide that public understanding? People in the public
need to know what is being agreed to, how decisions will be made and how accountability
will be maintained. Should that understanding be absent, support may become fragile. Does Bill 20 check
those two boxes and provide what is needed? In the absence of broad support, clearly,
progress becomes difficult to sustain. Transparency is not a procedural detail. It
is a requirement for long-term success. One of the most important questions in this debate is, which is questionable as to
whether Bill 20 identifies it clearly.... The question would be: where does decision-making
authority ultimately reside? And in that case, again, attracting significant capital
to this province that's needed to push forward on these incredibly important projects
— does Bill 20 advance that fundamental need? If authority becomes increasingly distributed across courts, arbitration bodies and
evolving interpretive frameworks, then the role of this Legislature may change. Does
that provide certainty? Does the bill before us provide that certainty? With a potential change comes a question of accountability. This House is accountable
to the people of British Columbia. Every one of us here at some point in the future,
should we choose to continue down this path, will be facing our electorate once more,
and we will be held accountable for the decisions that are made here. I would suggest that many, if not the vast majority of the populace, would say that
that principle must remain intact, that principle of accountability. I would go further
to suggest that any shift in governance must be clearly understood and very clearly
justified. In no way am I calling for an abandonment of progress. I'm making a call to strengthen
it. We can move forward, but we must do so carefully. One would suggest that the meaning
of moving forward carefully would be ensuring overlapping claims are addressed before
agreements are finalized, reinforcing clarity in treaty language and maintaining transparency
throughout the process. It means learning from agreements that have worked and avoiding
unnecessary departures from previously successful models. It also means prioritizing
durability over speed. The decisions we make here will not be judged next year. They will not be judged during
the next election cycle. They will be judged decades from now. These decisions will
be judged on whether they created clarity or confusion, stability or uncertainty,
trust or division. The question before us this afternoon is: does Bill 20 represent
those three points? Reconciliation does deserve Reconciliation does deserve to succeed. Success is not guaranteed. It must be built.
And it must be built on a foundation that is clear, stable and understood by all parties
involved. We remain committed to working constructively, to improving the framework and to ensuring
that reconciliation in British Columbia is not only advanced but sustained. This work
is too important to rush. Let us take the time to do it properly. And with that, thank
you very much.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Health care
While it may be considered inappropriate to ask this question with respect to the
massive failure of the Mental Health Act with respect to the incredible tragedy of
Tumbler Ridge, unfortunately there are far too many other examples to choose from. The one that I will speak to is that of Aaron Sanio. Aaron was admitted to Lions Gate
Hospital in North Vancouver, struggling with mental illness and a history of suicide
attempts. His family called the hospital repeatedly, desperate to share what they knew, but
were not able to speak to anyone one directly involved in his care. His father said,
"He was fully aware of how ill he was, and he shared that with me. He used to say:
'Dad, I would rather you know everything.'" His family were not notified when he was released, and shortly after, Aaron took his
own life. Will the minister commit to making the changes to the Mental Health Act today to ensure
that no family ever has to go through this pain again?Open source reference