2 recorded contributions · Small sample
Jev-reviewed existing detailed tags · editorial review required
Accepted detailed tags: Privacy
Bill 9 is a quiet but devastating assault on British Columbia's Freedom of Information
and Protection of Privacy Act. While they call it streamlining, it is nothing less
than a rollback of the very transparency that British Columbians have fought for decades
to protect. Let us speak plainly about where this leaves us on the world stage. The authoritative
global rights to information rating, the international gold standard measuring legal
strength of access to information laws, ranks countries out of 150 points. Top of
the world is Afghanistan at 139, Mexico at 136 and Serbia at 135. These jurisdictions
have built regimes with minimal exceptions, swift timelines, ironclad appeals and
genuine proactive disclosure. Canada's federal law sits at a mediocre 93 points, 53rd place. British Columbia's
FOIPPA has long been among the strongest in Canada, a provincial leader that kept
us competitive internationally. Bill 9 changes all that. It would replace the duty
to respond without delay....Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Provincial governments, Public administration, Regulations
As if it wasn't bad enough already, the people in British Columbia have had nine
years of demoralization, but with the complete alteration in the relationship between
the government and the legal profession, the medical professions, parents, school
children, realtors, retailers, construction workers, miners, foresters, fishers, short-term
renters, farmers, ranchers, landlords, drivers and, of course, home- and property
owners. On top of that the Canucks finished last but still didn't get the first draft pick,
and it looks like the Whitecaps might be on their way to Vegas. The government never
being one not to pile on, decided now is the time to offer a lousy dessert after a
force-feeding of a nine-year bile buffet to the good people of British Columbia. And
what's on the menu for dessert? Changing the requirements for a freedom-of-information
request. The Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act — what on earth did British
Columbia do to deserve this bill from this government? You would think, with the nightmare
that has befallen this province in the form of DRIPA and all the existential uncertainty
it brings, that this government might just put its feet up for a while and stop twisting
the thumbscrews even tighter. If I didn't know better, I would think that they have
a fascination with finding out just how much the people can take. The most recent polls might be an indication that British Columbians may have finally
had their fill. So I stand here today, this evening, to fight for a reprieve, albeit
very modest. I am fully supporting the hoist motion that is before the House. When
a government seems to derive so much delight from running roughshod over its own people,
something must be done to compel them to hit "pause." Even if for a few months, for
the love of god, can't we give people a breather? It really is shocking to be a witness to such a flagrant use of legislative authority.
Of all things you would think a Western government could do with a majority, stifling
access to information that is generated in this House by the people that the hard-earned
tax dollars paid for is so cynical that only this callous NDP government would take
the time to foist it on British Columbians. In any event, watching them around here, they seem not ashamed or even embarrassed.
If they are, I'm not seeing it. I guess with all they've done over the past nine years,
in their eyes, this slap in the face must seem like small potatoes. Let's take a look at freedom of information in the world and how this hoist motion
might give everyone a chance to rethink this bill and the government. The British
Columbia Freedom of Information and Privacy Protection Act, while they call it streamlining,
is nothing less than a rollback of the very transparency that British Columbians have
fought for decades to protect. Let us speak plainly about where this leaves us on the world stage and why we need
the hoist motion. The authoritative Global Right to Information Rating, the international
gold standard measuring legal strength of access to information laws, ranks countries
out of 150 points. Top of the world, Afghanistan, at 139; Mexico, at 136; and The authoritative Global Right to Information rating, the international gold standard
measuring legal strength of access-to-information laws, ranks countries out of 150
points. Top of the world, Afghanistan at 139, Mexico at 136 and Serbia at 135. These
jurisdictions have built regimes with minimal exceptions, swift timelines, ironclad
appeals and genuine proactive disclosure. Canada's federal law sits at a mediocre
93 points, 53rd place. British Columbia's FOIPPA has long been among the strongest in Canada, a provincial
leader that kept us competitive internationally. Bill 9 changes all that. It replaces
the duty to respond "without delay" with the vague "without unreasonable delay." It
hands public bodies new powers to dismiss requests they deem abusive or burdensome.
It weakens specificity rules and opens the door to longer extensions without real
oversight. These are not minor tweaks. They are deliberate restrictions that critics rightly
call a weakening of access. When Mexico and Serbia, nations once dismissed as less
open than ours, now outrank us on paper, and when even our own federal law lags behind
global best practices, this government is choosing secrecy over sunlight. They deserve
a province that leads the world in openness, not one that slides backwards into the
middle of the pack. I am pleased to speak about this hoist motion tonight, not simply to oppose Bill 9
but to defend one of the most important democratic principles we have in British Columbia:
the principle that government must remain accountable to the people it serves. I rise
to defend the principle that information does not belong to politicians, ministers,
bureaucrats or governments. It belongs to the public. I rise today in support of the hoist motion before this House because the concerns
surrounding Bill 9 are too serious, too numerous and too unresolved for this legislation
to proceed without a pause. Why the hoist motion? Because this is not a routine amendment. It is not a harmless
administrative update. It is not simply modernization, no matter how many times the
government repeats that word. Bill 9 fundamentally changes the relationship between
citizens and their government. It changes the balance between transparency and control,
which is why the hoist motion is absolutely necessary. It fundamentally alters the
balance between openness and secrecy. When legislation carries consequences of that magnitude, this Legislature has responsibility
to stop, reflect, scrutinize and reconsider. That is precisely why a hoist motion
exists, and that is precisely why this House should support a six-month pause on Bill
9. A hoist motion is not obstruction. A hoist motion is responsibility. It is a parliamentary
mechanism designed specifically for situations where legislation raises profound concerns
that require deeper public examination before moving forward. Bill 9 unquestionably meets that threshold because opposition to this bill is not
isolated. The concerns surrounding Bill 9 are broad, serious and completely credible.
Former architects of British Columbia's freedom-of-information legislation have raised
alarms. Journalists have raised alarms. Transparency advocates have raised alarms.
Accountability watchdogs have raised alarms.Open source reference