7 recorded contributions
Jev-reviewed existing detailed tags · editorial review required
Accepted detailed tags: Public safety, Safety, Safety regulations
I rise briefly at report stage to reiterate my support for this legislation. This
is a practical, commonsense measure that will improve safety on our roads. The core
of this bill is straightforward. Better evidence leads to better outcomes for investigators,
for drivers and for the public. We've already spoken in this House about the real-world value of dashboard camera
footage. It provides clarity where there would otherwise be uncertainty. It helps
determine what actually happened, especially in serious collisions, often in rural
and remote areas where there are few if any witnesses. Ultimately, it supports safer
roads and more effective investigations. I also want to acknowledge the concerns that were raised earlier in this process,
about privacy and the protection of personal information. Those are valid concerns,
and they were taken seriously. What we saw at committee was a thoughtful, non-partisan
effort to address those issues in a balanced way. Members from different sides of this House engaged in constructive discussions, proposed
amendments and worked through the details to ensure this legislation strikes the right
balance. Those amendments strengthened the bill. They clarified how information is
handled, reinforced protections around personal data and ensured that this tool is
used for its intended purpose — public safety. The bill before us today is better because of that process. It now reflects an approach
that protects public safety, while also respecting individual rights and ensuring
that this footage is not misused. That matters because public confidence depends on
getting that balance right. This is the kind of legislation that should bring this House together. It supports
commercial drivers, it supports law enforcement, it supports families who deserve
clear answers after serious incidents, and it does so in a way that is measured, reasonable
and fair. At the end of the day, this bill is about improving safety, providing clarity
and ensuring accountability on the roads. It's practical, it's effective, and it's
ready. I encourage all members of this House to support it.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Police services, Policing, Public safety
I have a few opening remarks, too, if I may. I just want to thank the minister and
her staff for their preparations and attendance for these estimates regarding Budget
2026 as they relate to my role as His Majesty's official opposition critic for Solicitor
General and Public Safety. Before I move into my lines of questioning, I have some brief remarks concerning my
background with policing. Before I move into my lines of questioning, I have some brief remarks concerning my
background with policing and public safety, which is perhaps why my side of the House
sought fit to assign me to serve as critic for Solicitor General and Public Safety. For those who are not aware, I served 19 years with the RCMP in Penticton, Kelowna,
West Kelowna and Lake Country detachments. I was mainly involved with general duty
policing. I was on bike patrol and downtown enforcement in Kelowna, where I dealt
with the homeless population, nuisance calls in the downtown core related to small
businesses and ensuring they were safe, as well as drug and liquor enforcement, all
while dealing with street-level drug addiction and drug trafficking. I was on the crime reduction unit dealing with problem residences across Kelowna,
specifically dealing with property crime offences, where significant stolen property
was being trafficked out of the residences, and specifically targeting prolific offenders. I was also involved with the police and crisis team, or PACT, or the mental health
car, where I rode around with a mental health nurse responding to mental health calls
in Kelowna. I was also on the RCMP tactical team, or public order, where I received
significant training and experience in dealing with public order events, such as protests
and riots. This also resulted in emergency deployment for natural disasters all across
B.C. Finally, I was a road supervisor in Kelowna, supervising six constables. I know a
little bit about front-line policing in British Columbia. I would also like to recognize my colleague the MLA for Surrey-Panorama, in his capacity as critic for community safety and transnational crime, with whom
I have collaborated with in our preparations for these estimates, also formally with
law enforcement with the RCMP, which I know he will be able to explain himself. Today we will start the work of oversight on the ministry operations vote in Budget
2026, with a focus on policing expenditures, public safety planning and the broader
fiscal risks facing British Columbia. This includes not only ongoing policing costs but also major event pressures, such
as the upcoming FIFA World Cup. This will place significant and complex demands on
our public safety system. Across the province, we are seeing policing costs rise steadily
year over year. At the same time, municipalities are raising serious concerns about
affordability. Staffing shortages remain persistent, and communities are questioning
whether service levels are keeping pace with demand. These pressures are not occurring in isolation. They are compounded by large-scale
event obligations that require substantial security planning, coordination and funding. The World Cup provides a clear example of these challenges. Vancouver is set to host
seven matches. While early projections place total event costs in the range of approximately
$240 million to $260 million, there remains a significant lack of transparency around
one of the most critical components — safety and security. Historically, security represents one of the largest and most volatile cost drivers
for events of this scale, yet there is no clear defined public breakdown, no detailed
risk adjustment estimate and no clear contingency framework. We have seen this pattern before. During the 2010 Olympic Winter Games, security costs
escalated significantly beyond early projections, ultimately exceeding $900 million
nationally. Internationally, FIFA World Cup events have also demonstrated a consistent pattern
of underestimating security expenditures early in the planning cycle. With costs rising as risks evolve and operational requirements become clearer, at
the same time, comparisons with other host jurisdictions raise further questions.
Toronto, which is hosting six matches, has a higher overall projected cost range,
and typical planning assumptions suggest that security can account for between 20
percent and 30 percent of total event costs. In the United States, host cities often appear to carry lower local security costs,
but this is largely due to the ability to draw an extensive federal security infrastructure,
which reduces visible local expenditures but does not eliminate the underlying costs. What this means for British Columbia is that taxpayers are likely more directly exposed
to security cost risks, particularly if those risks are not fully disclosed or adequately
planned for. Transparency is essential not only to ensure accountability but to allow municipalities,
stakeholders and the public to understand the full scope of financial exposure. The questions that I will follow with are designed to bring clarity to these issues.
They focus on cost drivers, risk management, staffing capacity and the sustainability
of current policing models. The goal is to ensure that police public funds are being The questions that I will follow with are designed to bring clarity to these issues.
They focus on cost drivers, risk management, staffing capacity and the sustainability
of current policing models. The goal is to ensure that public funds are being used
effectively, that risks are clearly understood and that decisions made today do not
create greater financial pressures in the future. With that, I'd like to proceed with
my questions. Vancouver is scheduled to host seven FIFA World Cup matches at B.C. Place in 2026.
Public reporting and government disclosures have placed total event costs in a broad
range of approximately $49 million to $98 million and, in some cases, $260 million
or more across all levels of government. Updated projections in comparable jurisdictions suggest that costs continue to evolve
as planning advances. Security is widely recognized as one of the largest cost drivers
for mega-events, often representing between 20 percent and 30 percent of total expenditures
in Canadian planning assumptions and in some international cases, exceeding initial
projections significantly. At present, there is no publicly released stand-alone security budget for the Vancouver
matches. Security-related costs are expected to be embedded across multiple categories
including policing, counterterrorism, venue security and crowd management. Historical precedent — including the 2010 Olympic Games, where security costs exceeded
$900 million nationally — demonstrates that early estimates frequently underestimate
final expenditures due to evolving risk conditions, operational requirements and federal
involvement. Comparative analysis shows that Toronto, hosting six matches, has projected total
costs in the range of approximately $300 million to $380 million, implying a substantial
security component even without detailed public breakdowns. In the U.S., host cities often rely on federal agencies and existing Homeland Security
infrastructure, which can reduce the visibility of local costs, but does not eliminate
the overall expenditure. This creates a structural difference where Canadian jurisdictions
may face more direct and transparent fiscal exposure. Given these factors, the primary concern is not that Vancouver's costs are necessarily
out of line with peer cities, but that the level of transparency, risk disclosure
and contingency planning does not reflect the known volatility and scale of security
expenditures for events of this magnitude. So in the context of this budget, and taking into account FIFA events having a history
of policing and security-cost overruns, will there be cost overruns for FIFA in the
policing and security context?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Policing
Thank you, Minister. Now I'd just like to switch gears into some.... I have a few other questions in other
areas I'd just like to go into, but perhaps the minister might be able to assist me
just in my first line of questioning here. My first thing I have is the sheriff service. Now, I don't know.... I think the minister
has the policing team. Is it a new team for sheriffs, or can I go into those with
you yet?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Provincial institutions
I'd like to take a moment to welcome three guests from my constituency of West Kelowna–Peachland, Dave, Jen and Charlotte Birchmore, who are joining us here today for their first
visit to the Legislature. They're here to see firsthand how this place works, to watch question period, spend
some time in the building and get a better sense of how both government and opposition
carry out their roles in this House. It's always valuable when people take the time
to come here, see the process up close and experience what happens inside this chamber.
I hope they enjoy their stay here today. Please join me in welcoming them to the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Planning
I have a few opening remarks, too, if I may. I just want to thank the minister and
her staff for their preparations and attendance for these estimates regarding Budget
2026 as they relate to my role as His Majesty's official opposition critic for Solicitor
General and Public Safety. Before I move into my lines of questioning, I have some brief remarks concerning my
background with policing. Before I move into my lines of questioning, I have some brief remarks concerning my
background with policing and public safety, which is perhaps why my side of the House
sought fit to assign me to serve as critic for Solicitor General and Public Safety. For those who are not aware, I served 19 years with the RCMP in Penticton, Kelowna,
West Kelowna and Lake Country detachments. I was mainly involved with general duty
policing. I was on bike patrol and downtown enforcement in Kelowna, where I dealt
with the homeless population, nuisance calls in the downtown core related to small
businesses and ensuring they were safe, as well as drug and liquor enforcement, all
while dealing with street-level drug addiction and drug trafficking. I was on the crime reduction unit dealing with problem residences across Kelowna,
specifically dealing with property crime offences, where significant stolen property
was being trafficked out of the residences, and specifically targeting prolific offenders. I was also involved with the police and crisis team, or PACT, or the mental health
car, where I rode around with a mental health nurse responding to mental health calls
in Kelowna. I was also on the RCMP tactical team, or public order, where I received
significant training and experience in dealing with public order events, such as protests
and riots. This also resulted in emergency deployment for natural disasters all across
B.C. Finally, I was a road supervisor in Kelowna, supervising six constables. I know a
little bit about front-line policing in British Columbia. I would also like to recognize my colleague the MLA for Surrey-Panorama, in his capacity as critic for community safety and transnational crime, with whom
I have collaborated with in our preparations for these estimates, also formally with
law enforcement with the RCMP, which I know he will be able to explain himself. Today we will start the work of oversight on the ministry operations vote in Budget
2026, with a focus on policing expenditures, public safety planning and the broader
fiscal risks facing British Columbia. This includes not only ongoing policing costs but also major event pressures, such
as the upcoming FIFA World Cup. This will place significant and complex demands on
our public safety system. Across the province, we are seeing policing costs rise steadily
year over year. At the same time, municipalities are raising serious concerns about
affordability. Staffing shortages remain persistent, and communities are questioning
whether service levels are keeping pace with demand. These pressures are not occurring in isolation. They are compounded by large-scale
event obligations that require substantial security planning, coordination and funding. The World Cup provides a clear example of these challenges. Vancouver is set to host
seven matches. While early projections place total event costs in the range of approximately
$240 million to $260 million, there remains a significant lack of transparency around
one of the most critical components — safety and security. Historically, security represents one of the largest and most volatile cost drivers
for events of this scale, yet there is no clear defined public breakdown, no detailed
risk adjustment estimate and no clear contingency framework. We have seen this pattern before. During the 2010 Olympic Winter Games, security costs
escalated significantly beyond early projections, ultimately exceeding $900 million
nationally. Internationally, FIFA World Cup events have also demonstrated a consistent pattern
of underestimating security expenditures early in the planning cycle. With costs rising as risks evolve and operational requirements become clearer, at
the same time, comparisons with other host jurisdictions raise further questions.
Toronto, which is hosting six matches, has a higher overall projected cost range,
and typical planning assumptions suggest that security can account for between 20
percent and 30 percent of total event costs. In the United States, host cities often appear to carry lower local security costs,
but this is largely due to the ability to draw an extensive federal security infrastructure,
which reduces visible local expenditures but does not eliminate the underlying costs. What this means for British Columbia is that taxpayers are likely more directly exposed
to security cost risks, particularly if those risks are not fully disclosed or adequately
planned for. Transparency is essential not only to ensure accountability but to allow municipalities,
stakeholders and the public to understand the full scope of financial exposure. The questions that I will follow with are designed to bring clarity to these issues.
They focus on cost drivers, risk management, staffing capacity and the sustainability
of current policing models. The goal is to ensure that police public funds are being The questions that I will follow with are designed to bring clarity to these issues.
They focus on cost drivers, risk management, staffing capacity and the sustainability
of current policing models. The goal is to ensure that public funds are being used
effectively, that risks are clearly understood and that decisions made today do not
create greater financial pressures in the future. With that, I'd like to proceed with
my questions. Vancouver is scheduled to host seven FIFA World Cup matches at B.C. Place in 2026.
Public reporting and government disclosures have placed total event costs in a broad
range of approximately $49 million to $98 million and, in some cases, $260 million
or more across all levels of government. Updated projections in comparable jurisdictions suggest that costs continue to evolve
as planning advances. Security is widely recognized as one of the largest cost drivers
for mega-events, often representing between 20 percent and 30 percent of total expenditures
in Canadian planning assumptions and in some international cases, exceeding initial
projections significantly. At present, there is no publicly released stand-alone security budget for the Vancouver
matches. Security-related costs are expected to be embedded across multiple categories
including policing, counterterrorism, venue security and crowd management. Historical precedent — including the 2010 Olympic Games, where security costs exceeded
$900 million nationally — demonstrates that early estimates frequently underestimate
final expenditures due to evolving risk conditions, operational requirements and federal
involvement. Comparative analysis shows that Toronto, hosting six matches, has projected total
costs in the range of approximately $300 million to $380 million, implying a substantial
security component even without detailed public breakdowns. In the U.S., host cities often rely on federal agencies and existing Homeland Security
infrastructure, which can reduce the visibility of local costs, but does not eliminate
the overall expenditure. This creates a structural difference where Canadian jurisdictions
may face more direct and transparent fiscal exposure. Given these factors, the primary concern is not that Vancouver's costs are necessarily
out of line with peer cities, but that the level of transparency, risk disclosure
and contingency planning does not reflect the known volatility and scale of security
expenditures for events of this magnitude. So in the context of this budget, and taking into account FIFA events having a history
of policing and security-cost overruns, will there be cost overruns for FIFA in the
policing and security context?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Budgets, Public finance
I have a few opening remarks, too, if I may. I just want to thank the minister and
her staff for their preparations and attendance for these estimates regarding Budget
2026 as they relate to my role as His Majesty's official opposition critic for Solicitor
General and Public Safety. Before I move into my lines of questioning, I have some brief remarks concerning my
background with policing. Before I move into my lines of questioning, I have some brief remarks concerning my
background with policing and public safety, which is perhaps why my side of the House
sought fit to assign me to serve as critic for Solicitor General and Public Safety. For those who are not aware, I served 19 years with the RCMP in Penticton, Kelowna,
West Kelowna and Lake Country detachments. I was mainly involved with general duty
policing. I was on bike patrol and downtown enforcement in Kelowna, where I dealt
with the homeless population, nuisance calls in the downtown core related to small
businesses and ensuring they were safe, as well as drug and liquor enforcement, all
while dealing with street-level drug addiction and drug trafficking. I was on the crime reduction unit dealing with problem residences across Kelowna,
specifically dealing with property crime offences, where significant stolen property
was being trafficked out of the residences, and specifically targeting prolific offenders. I was also involved with the police and crisis team, or PACT, or the mental health
car, where I rode around with a mental health nurse responding to mental health calls
in Kelowna. I was also on the RCMP tactical team, or public order, where I received
significant training and experience in dealing with public order events, such as protests
and riots. This also resulted in emergency deployment for natural disasters all across
B.C. Finally, I was a road supervisor in Kelowna, supervising six constables. I know a
little bit about front-line policing in British Columbia. I would also like to recognize my colleague the MLA for Surrey-Panorama, in his capacity as critic for community safety and transnational crime, with whom
I have collaborated with in our preparations for these estimates, also formally with
law enforcement with the RCMP, which I know he will be able to explain himself. Today we will start the work of oversight on the ministry operations vote in Budget
2026, with a focus on policing expenditures, public safety planning and the broader
fiscal risks facing British Columbia. This includes not only ongoing policing costs but also major event pressures, such
as the upcoming FIFA World Cup. This will place significant and complex demands on
our public safety system. Across the province, we are seeing policing costs rise steadily
year over year. At the same time, municipalities are raising serious concerns about
affordability. Staffing shortages remain persistent, and communities are questioning
whether service levels are keeping pace with demand. These pressures are not occurring in isolation. They are compounded by large-scale
event obligations that require substantial security planning, coordination and funding. The World Cup provides a clear example of these challenges. Vancouver is set to host
seven matches. While early projections place total event costs in the range of approximately
$240 million to $260 million, there remains a significant lack of transparency around
one of the most critical components — safety and security. Historically, security represents one of the largest and most volatile cost drivers
for events of this scale, yet there is no clear defined public breakdown, no detailed
risk adjustment estimate and no clear contingency framework. We have seen this pattern before. During the 2010 Olympic Winter Games, security costs
escalated significantly beyond early projections, ultimately exceeding $900 million
nationally. Internationally, FIFA World Cup events have also demonstrated a consistent pattern
of underestimating security expenditures early in the planning cycle. With costs rising as risks evolve and operational requirements become clearer, at
the same time, comparisons with other host jurisdictions raise further questions.
Toronto, which is hosting six matches, has a higher overall projected cost range,
and typical planning assumptions suggest that security can account for between 20
percent and 30 percent of total event costs. In the United States, host cities often appear to carry lower local security costs,
but this is largely due to the ability to draw an extensive federal security infrastructure,
which reduces visible local expenditures but does not eliminate the underlying costs. What this means for British Columbia is that taxpayers are likely more directly exposed
to security cost risks, particularly if those risks are not fully disclosed or adequately
planned for. Transparency is essential not only to ensure accountability but to allow municipalities,
stakeholders and the public to understand the full scope of financial exposure. The questions that I will follow with are designed to bring clarity to these issues.
They focus on cost drivers, risk management, staffing capacity and the sustainability
of current policing models. The goal is to ensure that police public funds are being The questions that I will follow with are designed to bring clarity to these issues.
They focus on cost drivers, risk management, staffing capacity and the sustainability
of current policing models. The goal is to ensure that public funds are being used
effectively, that risks are clearly understood and that decisions made today do not
create greater financial pressures in the future. With that, I'd like to proceed with
my questions. Vancouver is scheduled to host seven FIFA World Cup matches at B.C. Place in 2026.
Public reporting and government disclosures have placed total event costs in a broad
range of approximately $49 million to $98 million and, in some cases, $260 million
or more across all levels of government. Updated projections in comparable jurisdictions suggest that costs continue to evolve
as planning advances. Security is widely recognized as one of the largest cost drivers
for mega-events, often representing between 20 percent and 30 percent of total expenditures
in Canadian planning assumptions and in some international cases, exceeding initial
projections significantly. At present, there is no publicly released stand-alone security budget for the Vancouver
matches. Security-related costs are expected to be embedded across multiple categories
including policing, counterterrorism, venue security and crowd management. Historical precedent — including the 2010 Olympic Games, where security costs exceeded
$900 million nationally — demonstrates that early estimates frequently underestimate
final expenditures due to evolving risk conditions, operational requirements and federal
involvement. Comparative analysis shows that Toronto, hosting six matches, has projected total
costs in the range of approximately $300 million to $380 million, implying a substantial
security component even without detailed public breakdowns. In the U.S., host cities often rely on federal agencies and existing Homeland Security
infrastructure, which can reduce the visibility of local costs, but does not eliminate
the overall expenditure. This creates a structural difference where Canadian jurisdictions
may face more direct and transparent fiscal exposure. Given these factors, the primary concern is not that Vancouver's costs are necessarily
out of line with peer cities, but that the level of transparency, risk disclosure
and contingency planning does not reflect the known volatility and scale of security
expenditures for events of this magnitude. So in the context of this budget, and taking into account FIFA events having a history
of policing and security-cost overruns, will there be cost overruns for FIFA in the
policing and security context?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Security
I have a few opening remarks, too, if I may. I just want to thank the minister and
her staff for their preparations and attendance for these estimates regarding Budget
2026 as they relate to my role as His Majesty's official opposition critic for Solicitor
General and Public Safety. Before I move into my lines of questioning, I have some brief remarks concerning my
background with policing. Before I move into my lines of questioning, I have some brief remarks concerning my
background with policing and public safety, which is perhaps why my side of the House
sought fit to assign me to serve as critic for Solicitor General and Public Safety. For those who are not aware, I served 19 years with the RCMP in Penticton, Kelowna,
West Kelowna and Lake Country detachments. I was mainly involved with general duty
policing. I was on bike patrol and downtown enforcement in Kelowna, where I dealt
with the homeless population, nuisance calls in the downtown core related to small
businesses and ensuring they were safe, as well as drug and liquor enforcement, all
while dealing with street-level drug addiction and drug trafficking. I was on the crime reduction unit dealing with problem residences across Kelowna,
specifically dealing with property crime offences, where significant stolen property
was being trafficked out of the residences, and specifically targeting prolific offenders. I was also involved with the police and crisis team, or PACT, or the mental health
car, where I rode around with a mental health nurse responding to mental health calls
in Kelowna. I was also on the RCMP tactical team, or public order, where I received
significant training and experience in dealing with public order events, such as protests
and riots. This also resulted in emergency deployment for natural disasters all across
B.C. Finally, I was a road supervisor in Kelowna, supervising six constables. I know a
little bit about front-line policing in British Columbia. I would also like to recognize my colleague the MLA for Surrey-Panorama, in his capacity as critic for community safety and transnational crime, with whom
I have collaborated with in our preparations for these estimates, also formally with
law enforcement with the RCMP, which I know he will be able to explain himself. Today we will start the work of oversight on the ministry operations vote in Budget
2026, with a focus on policing expenditures, public safety planning and the broader
fiscal risks facing British Columbia. This includes not only ongoing policing costs but also major event pressures, such
as the upcoming FIFA World Cup. This will place significant and complex demands on
our public safety system. Across the province, we are seeing policing costs rise steadily
year over year. At the same time, municipalities are raising serious concerns about
affordability. Staffing shortages remain persistent, and communities are questioning
whether service levels are keeping pace with demand. These pressures are not occurring in isolation. They are compounded by large-scale
event obligations that require substantial security planning, coordination and funding. The World Cup provides a clear example of these challenges. Vancouver is set to host
seven matches. While early projections place total event costs in the range of approximately
$240 million to $260 million, there remains a significant lack of transparency around
one of the most critical components — safety and security. Historically, security represents one of the largest and most volatile cost drivers
for events of this scale, yet there is no clear defined public breakdown, no detailed
risk adjustment estimate and no clear contingency framework. We have seen this pattern before. During the 2010 Olympic Winter Games, security costs
escalated significantly beyond early projections, ultimately exceeding $900 million
nationally. Internationally, FIFA World Cup events have also demonstrated a consistent pattern
of underestimating security expenditures early in the planning cycle. With costs rising as risks evolve and operational requirements become clearer, at
the same time, comparisons with other host jurisdictions raise further questions.
Toronto, which is hosting six matches, has a higher overall projected cost range,
and typical planning assumptions suggest that security can account for between 20
percent and 30 percent of total event costs. In the United States, host cities often appear to carry lower local security costs,
but this is largely due to the ability to draw an extensive federal security infrastructure,
which reduces visible local expenditures but does not eliminate the underlying costs. What this means for British Columbia is that taxpayers are likely more directly exposed
to security cost risks, particularly if those risks are not fully disclosed or adequately
planned for. Transparency is essential not only to ensure accountability but to allow municipalities,
stakeholders and the public to understand the full scope of financial exposure. The questions that I will follow with are designed to bring clarity to these issues.
They focus on cost drivers, risk management, staffing capacity and the sustainability
of current policing models. The goal is to ensure that police public funds are being The questions that I will follow with are designed to bring clarity to these issues.
They focus on cost drivers, risk management, staffing capacity and the sustainability
of current policing models. The goal is to ensure that public funds are being used
effectively, that risks are clearly understood and that decisions made today do not
create greater financial pressures in the future. With that, I'd like to proceed with
my questions. Vancouver is scheduled to host seven FIFA World Cup matches at B.C. Place in 2026.
Public reporting and government disclosures have placed total event costs in a broad
range of approximately $49 million to $98 million and, in some cases, $260 million
or more across all levels of government. Updated projections in comparable jurisdictions suggest that costs continue to evolve
as planning advances. Security is widely recognized as one of the largest cost drivers
for mega-events, often representing between 20 percent and 30 percent of total expenditures
in Canadian planning assumptions and in some international cases, exceeding initial
projections significantly. At present, there is no publicly released stand-alone security budget for the Vancouver
matches. Security-related costs are expected to be embedded across multiple categories
including policing, counterterrorism, venue security and crowd management. Historical precedent — including the 2010 Olympic Games, where security costs exceeded
$900 million nationally — demonstrates that early estimates frequently underestimate
final expenditures due to evolving risk conditions, operational requirements and federal
involvement. Comparative analysis shows that Toronto, hosting six matches, has projected total
costs in the range of approximately $300 million to $380 million, implying a substantial
security component even without detailed public breakdowns. In the U.S., host cities often rely on federal agencies and existing Homeland Security
infrastructure, which can reduce the visibility of local costs, but does not eliminate
the overall expenditure. This creates a structural difference where Canadian jurisdictions
may face more direct and transparent fiscal exposure. Given these factors, the primary concern is not that Vancouver's costs are necessarily
out of line with peer cities, but that the level of transparency, risk disclosure
and contingency planning does not reflect the known volatility and scale of security
expenditures for events of this magnitude. So in the context of this budget, and taking into account FIFA events having a history
of policing and security-cost overruns, will there be cost overruns for FIFA in the
policing and security context?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Fiscal issues, Funding, Public funding
I have a few opening remarks, too, if I may. I just want to thank the minister and
her staff for their preparations and attendance for these estimates regarding Budget
2026 as they relate to my role as His Majesty's official opposition critic for Solicitor
General and Public Safety. Before I move into my lines of questioning, I have some brief remarks concerning my
background with policing. Before I move into my lines of questioning, I have some brief remarks concerning my
background with policing and public safety, which is perhaps why my side of the House
sought fit to assign me to serve as critic for Solicitor General and Public Safety. For those who are not aware, I served 19 years with the RCMP in Penticton, Kelowna,
West Kelowna and Lake Country detachments. I was mainly involved with general duty
policing. I was on bike patrol and downtown enforcement in Kelowna, where I dealt
with the homeless population, nuisance calls in the downtown core related to small
businesses and ensuring they were safe, as well as drug and liquor enforcement, all
while dealing with street-level drug addiction and drug trafficking. I was on the crime reduction unit dealing with problem residences across Kelowna,
specifically dealing with property crime offences, where significant stolen property
was being trafficked out of the residences, and specifically targeting prolific offenders. I was also involved with the police and crisis team, or PACT, or the mental health
car, where I rode around with a mental health nurse responding to mental health calls
in Kelowna. I was also on the RCMP tactical team, or public order, where I received
significant training and experience in dealing with public order events, such as protests
and riots. This also resulted in emergency deployment for natural disasters all across
B.C. Finally, I was a road supervisor in Kelowna, supervising six constables. I know a
little bit about front-line policing in British Columbia. I would also like to recognize my colleague the MLA for Surrey-Panorama, in his capacity as critic for community safety and transnational crime, with whom
I have collaborated with in our preparations for these estimates, also formally with
law enforcement with the RCMP, which I know he will be able to explain himself. Today we will start the work of oversight on the ministry operations vote in Budget
2026, with a focus on policing expenditures, public safety planning and the broader
fiscal risks facing British Columbia. This includes not only ongoing policing costs but also major event pressures, such
as the upcoming FIFA World Cup. This will place significant and complex demands on
our public safety system. Across the province, we are seeing policing costs rise steadily
year over year. At the same time, municipalities are raising serious concerns about
affordability. Staffing shortages remain persistent, and communities are questioning
whether service levels are keeping pace with demand. These pressures are not occurring in isolation. They are compounded by large-scale
event obligations that require substantial security planning, coordination and funding. The World Cup provides a clear example of these challenges. Vancouver is set to host
seven matches. While early projections place total event costs in the range of approximately
$240 million to $260 million, there remains a significant lack of transparency around
one of the most critical components — safety and security. Historically, security represents one of the largest and most volatile cost drivers
for events of this scale, yet there is no clear defined public breakdown, no detailed
risk adjustment estimate and no clear contingency framework. We have seen this pattern before. During the 2010 Olympic Winter Games, security costs
escalated significantly beyond early projections, ultimately exceeding $900 million
nationally. Internationally, FIFA World Cup events have also demonstrated a consistent pattern
of underestimating security expenditures early in the planning cycle. With costs rising as risks evolve and operational requirements become clearer, at
the same time, comparisons with other host jurisdictions raise further questions.
Toronto, which is hosting six matches, has a higher overall projected cost range,
and typical planning assumptions suggest that security can account for between 20
percent and 30 percent of total event costs. In the United States, host cities often appear to carry lower local security costs,
but this is largely due to the ability to draw an extensive federal security infrastructure,
which reduces visible local expenditures but does not eliminate the underlying costs. What this means for British Columbia is that taxpayers are likely more directly exposed
to security cost risks, particularly if those risks are not fully disclosed or adequately
planned for. Transparency is essential not only to ensure accountability but to allow municipalities,
stakeholders and the public to understand the full scope of financial exposure. The questions that I will follow with are designed to bring clarity to these issues.
They focus on cost drivers, risk management, staffing capacity and the sustainability
of current policing models. The goal is to ensure that police public funds are being The questions that I will follow with are designed to bring clarity to these issues.
They focus on cost drivers, risk management, staffing capacity and the sustainability
of current policing models. The goal is to ensure that public funds are being used
effectively, that risks are clearly understood and that decisions made today do not
create greater financial pressures in the future. With that, I'd like to proceed with
my questions. Vancouver is scheduled to host seven FIFA World Cup matches at B.C. Place in 2026.
Public reporting and government disclosures have placed total event costs in a broad
range of approximately $49 million to $98 million and, in some cases, $260 million
or more across all levels of government. Updated projections in comparable jurisdictions suggest that costs continue to evolve
as planning advances. Security is widely recognized as one of the largest cost drivers
for mega-events, often representing between 20 percent and 30 percent of total expenditures
in Canadian planning assumptions and in some international cases, exceeding initial
projections significantly. At present, there is no publicly released stand-alone security budget for the Vancouver
matches. Security-related costs are expected to be embedded across multiple categories
including policing, counterterrorism, venue security and crowd management. Historical precedent — including the 2010 Olympic Games, where security costs exceeded
$900 million nationally — demonstrates that early estimates frequently underestimate
final expenditures due to evolving risk conditions, operational requirements and federal
involvement. Comparative analysis shows that Toronto, hosting six matches, has projected total
costs in the range of approximately $300 million to $380 million, implying a substantial
security component even without detailed public breakdowns. In the U.S., host cities often rely on federal agencies and existing Homeland Security
infrastructure, which can reduce the visibility of local costs, but does not eliminate
the overall expenditure. This creates a structural difference where Canadian jurisdictions
may face more direct and transparent fiscal exposure. Given these factors, the primary concern is not that Vancouver's costs are necessarily
out of line with peer cities, but that the level of transparency, risk disclosure
and contingency planning does not reflect the known volatility and scale of security
expenditures for events of this magnitude. So in the context of this budget, and taking into account FIFA events having a history
of policing and security-cost overruns, will there be cost overruns for FIFA in the
policing and security context?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Road safety
I rise briefly at report stage to reiterate my support for this legislation. This
is a practical, commonsense measure that will improve safety on our roads. The core
of this bill is straightforward. Better evidence leads to better outcomes for investigators,
for drivers and for the public. We've already spoken in this House about the real-world value of dashboard camera
footage. It provides clarity where there would otherwise be uncertainty. It helps
determine what actually happened, especially in serious collisions, often in rural
and remote areas where there are few if any witnesses. Ultimately, it supports safer
roads and more effective investigations. I also want to acknowledge the concerns that were raised earlier in this process,
about privacy and the protection of personal information. Those are valid concerns,
and they were taken seriously. What we saw at committee was a thoughtful, non-partisan
effort to address those issues in a balanced way. Members from different sides of this House engaged in constructive discussions, proposed
amendments and worked through the details to ensure this legislation strikes the right
balance. Those amendments strengthened the bill. They clarified how information is
handled, reinforced protections around personal data and ensured that this tool is
used for its intended purpose — public safety. The bill before us today is better because of that process. It now reflects an approach
that protects public safety, while also respecting individual rights and ensuring
that this footage is not misused. That matters because public confidence depends on
getting that balance right. This is the kind of legislation that should bring this House together. It supports
commercial drivers, it supports law enforcement, it supports families who deserve
clear answers after serious incidents, and it does so in a way that is measured, reasonable
and fair. At the end of the day, this bill is about improving safety, providing clarity
and ensuring accountability on the roads. It's practical, it's effective, and it's
ready. I encourage all members of this House to support it.Open source reference