11 recorded contributions
Jev-reviewed existing detailed tags · editorial review required
Accepted detailed tags: Budgets
I'm happy to take my place in the debate. Although my colleague before me may have
been not clear on whether he was opposed to this bill or not, I certainly am. Yes,
that's a little Zoom humour because he was most definitely very clear in his opposition,
as I have been as well. The reality of this bill is that we've seen this with this government repeatedly.
I'm going to take a little bit of the time to go back down memory lane when it comes
to FOI with this government. It was not that long ago that a minister spent days defending
changes to the FOI Act, defending changes to making it where you have to pay a fee
to file an FOI. There was a lot of concern legitimately raised at that point. There was a lot of concern around what would that fee be. And the answer for days
was: "We don't know what the fee will be because we still have to consult. And so
we're not sure if it'll be $5. We're not sure if it'll be $10. We're not sure if it'll
be $20, but there will be a fee, and we're going to consult." Day after day, question
after question that was asked about this, that was the deflection. It was an admirable
performance by the minister at the time, I must say, in terms of being able to stick
to a speaking point. It may have felt good in the moment inside the chamber for that minister to continue
down that path. It certainly didn't play well out in the general public. It didn't
play well in the media. And it certainly didn't play well when we discovered that
within a few minutes of the bill being passed, an order in council was signed in the
hallway of the Legislature setting the fee at $10. Apparently, those multiple days
on end of questions but no answers during committee stage qualified as consultation
and checking in to see with stakeholders what the fee should be. That is fundamentally the core problem with this government. They repeatedly hide
and evade information. Now, if this was a government that actually, I don't know,
even answered questions in question period directly, maybe people wouldn't be as concerned
about Bill 9 and changes to FOI to make it even harder to access government information.
Maybe if ministers when they were asked direct questions in budget estimates or in
committee stages of bills, very straightforward, sometimes actually routine procedural
questions about a piece of legislation, answered it upfront and didn't take five different
questions to get a very basic answer out of them, perhaps people wouldn't be as worried. I can think back to one time. It was when LNG was being brought forward. I was the
environment critic at the time and, then, Minister Heyman. There was very simple language
in the bill, and it was about setting the emission standards for LNG moving forward.
It very clearly had, basically, boilerplate language in it that said that the minister
through orders in council could set emission levels for LNG projects. All I simply
asked was: does that mean to set the LNG emission profile, that would not have to
come back to the Legislature, that would just could be done over summertime by an
order in council signature? The minister repeatedly answered: "Well, I don't have lawyers here. I can't answer
legal questions about this bill." That was a ridiculous question in the first place,
because every piece of legislation is a legal document. But it was because, frankly,
the minister didn't want to be seen to be responsible as the one setting LNG emissions. Obviously, as the former head of Sierra Club, he was probably not thrilled that he
was going to have to be the signatory not only to the massive tax breaks that were
given to LNG Canada but also to developing and signing off on what the emission profile
for LNG was going to be. Now, I raise all that because it just demonstrates a repeated and continuing erosion Now, I raise all that because it just demonstrates a repeated and continuing erosion
of access to basic information. The minister eventually acknowledged that, yes, indeed,
that's exactly what that language means. We all know it. We see it in every piece
of legislation. We don't need lawyers to tell us that's what it actually means, but
that was the first four or five answers from the minister. Around and around we had
to dance to try to get an upfront answer. So if you're a member of the public or if you're a member of the media.... Imagine how
frustrating it must be for them to try to get a straight answer out of members of
government. That's why we have FOI in the first place. We have FOI because if government
chooses to not be proactive with their disclosure, if government chooses to pick and
choose when they want information to come out, if they want to try to redact, if they
want to try to otherwise hide what is going on in government, it is critically important. I can think back to budget estimates last year when I was asking questions about online
gaming and lobbying efforts that were happening, and the minister insisted that there
hadn't been meetings. In a follow-up question, I was able to provide an actual date
that a senior bureaucrat met with online gaming. And then the minister had to say:
"Oh, oh yeah, actually we did have some meetings." Had I not had that document and that understanding of those calendars, the follow-up
question wouldn't have been asked. We would have simply taken the first question at
face value, which was a question that later turned out — literally, by later, the
next question or two — to not be entirely accurate and not paint an accurate picture
of something as fundamentally important as the expansion of online gaming or not and
the regulatory framework that would look like for online gaming in British Columbia. To the average person at home, you might think: "Well, what's the big deal around
that?" Well, there are pros and cons with gaming, and there are pros and cons with
online gaming, especially, in terms of addiction, in terms of gambling problems and
issues that come forward in that way. I think those are fair questions to ask. Where
exactly industry is headed, where government is headed for any potential expansion
or not on something that can be as addictive as online gaming, understanding what
those timelines are, understanding who's lobbying and what they're lobbying for —
all of that is critically important. If you had a government that was proactively releasing information, proactively talking
about things, not always making you jump through hoops trying to get the most basic
information, you might have a little less heartburn or apprehension about Bill 9.
But that's not the case. Sadly, we have a government that has routinely been acknowledged
as the most secretive government in Canada. We have a government, even on something as simple and basic as a $6,600 limo bill....
The minister.... No, she was not the Minister of Finance at the time, but she was a
minister. She was in Boston, and there were car charges for $6,600. Yet this government
wants to try to pretend it didn't happen. And members of the opposition will hoot
and howl and say that it's not true, that it didn't happen. Well, then why was it
claimed? Using the excuse, "Well, it was a town car; it wasn't a limo," doesn't really matter
to the taxpayer. The taxpayer wants to know why $6,600 was spent on that limo ride
for the weekend instead of a few Ubers to get around. No one begrudges that staff
and ministers have to travel and have to get around and be transported around large
cities. That makes perfect sense. A $6,600 limo ride to accomplish that does seem
a tad excessive. There's been a wide range of other FOIs on these types of issues. When you look at
the state we're in right now and issues around DRIPA, meetings that would be happening
around DRIPA, I think the public.... More daylight is much better than less. You know,
this is why the government that keeps taking steps on Bill 9, especially in the backdrop
of all that's unfolding right now and ever-tanking popularity numbers by a Premier
and his government, makes one second-guess and ponder. Just what exactly are they afraid is going to be discovered through FOI that they're
scrambling to try to get new laws in place before those FOI filings get filed? I think
it's a legitimate concern. I don't tend to be known as one that's a big conspiracy
theorist or goes over the top with distrust, but I actually do have concerns that
the timing of this I don't tend to be known as one that's a big conspiracy theorist or that goes over
the top with distrust, but I actually do have concerns that the timing of this legislation,
given all the other issues going on in British Columbia right now and all the serious
nature of things, is being brought forward at a time where we can't see a tangible
benefit for it, other than restricting the public's, the media's and the opposition's
access to information. You know, when we're looking at the past practice of this government, when we're looking
at past pieces of legislation, when we're looking at actions taken — again, not just
on travel but on decisions that this government has made, things like briefing notes
or estimates binders, a wide range of issues — a lot of times what happens is that
when you pull on the thread, you get a bit of a path. So you start heading down one way, and then you say: "Oh, hang on. Now with that piece
of information, I never imagined that that would have been the answer. So I guess
we'd better start looking over here as well now." That's the critical importance of
FOI. Sometimes we're fortunate enough that we stumble upon that when we're in budget estimates.
So we have a piece of an FOI document, or we have a series of questions, and the answer
comes back, different than we were expecting. That actually engages a whole series
of FOIs that might happen, because what we assumed was happening in government is
in fact not what's happening. An example I'll use on this is that a few years ago, when I was questioning around
the budget and the government made a big, big deal that there were $70 million for
reconciliation efforts put into the budget. Now I was asked on budget day what to
point out as something good in the budget. I said: "Oh, that sounds like it's a good
thing, if there's more capacity for municipalities and nations to work together to
actually move projects forward quickly and get things accomplished." Then you fast-forward to budget estimates, and I thought I would ask a few questions
of the Minister of Indigenous Relations. I said: "Well, how did we come to that dollar
figure? Frankly, I was going to be a bit of a smart aleck with a couple of those questions,
because the minister, before he became part of government, between being an MP — he
was Minister Rankin at the time — and a minister in an election, had resigned as an
MP. His placeholder work, granted to him by the NDP, was to be a highly paid First Nations
consultant, and Nathan Cullen had the same deal. It was a very convenient work transition,
for both of those gentlemen — to be able to resign as an MP, wait to run to become
an MLA, and get very highly lucrative consulting contracts to work with the government
and First Nations. I was going to basically do a calculation of how much they were getting paid per hour
back in their consultant days and figure out how many hours of consulting this $70
million was going to accomplish. What surprised me was actually the answer. The answer
was: "Well, this is what we've historically always spent." At that, I instantly switched gears and said: "Well, this is supposed to be new money.
This is supposed to be expanded money. What do you mean that this is what has always
been spent?" It turns out that all it was, was that instead of taking it out of contingencies
every year, government just decided to make it a permanent line item. Fine, except
don't start marketing it as "new, expanded, never been done before, enhanced and going
to provide extra" — all that type of language that was used. Why it matters is because in this case, we were able to get to an answer during budget
estimates. However, with these changes to FOI, had we wanted to follow up with an
FOI based on those lines of questioning to see exactly how they got to a historic
average of $70 million of reconciliation spending in any given year, this Bill 9 would
have made that next to impossible, after budget estimates are over, for the opposition
to follow up, fact-check, verify and dig deeper into some of the answers ministers
give. Now, let's remember we have limited time in budget estimates to actually fully question,
especially when ministers start to be evasive with their answers. It starts to chew
up the clock, and they sometimes turn around and take ten minutes to chit-chat with
staff. You can hear them in the smaller committee rooms. They're quite literally talking
about holiday plans and weekend plans and things to kill a clock. They sometimes turn around and take ten minutes to chit-chat with staff. You can hear
them in the smaller committee rooms. They're quite literally talking about holiday
plans and weekend plans and things to kill a clock. Then they turn around, and they
give you a non-answer and hope that you'll move on to a different subject because
they know that we're up against a clock. They do that quite frequently, frankly, and it gets worse the farther we go into a
session and the more desperate a government becomes with reduced polling numbers.
So I fully expect, as we continue on with budget estimates, that will probably continue. The key to it, though, is that, as opposition, that means if we don't get through
all of our material or we get answers that we wanted more follow-up on but we don't
have the time in that current moment to follow up, we would actually access and leverage
an FOI to try to actually get that information or see, again, if the minister is being
forthright with the public about what's truly going on behind the scenes. Now, Bill 9, when I heard that the government was bringing in a bill around FOI reform
and changes, I was actually hoping they would've learned from the last go-around and
actually been bringing in changes to improve FOI access, not make it even harder and
make it essentially nonexistent. It's a way to basically have something on the books
that says you have freedom of information but that, in fact, it doesn't actually exist. Now, when I was the mayor of Kamloops, I got FOI'd a lot, as did council, as a matter
of practice for media and others. In fact, our disclosure and our turnaround and our
expectation of providing and redacting was much more open and transparent than what
the provincial government operates under. Interestingly enough, it's rules the provincial government forces upon municipalities
to operate that way. I don't have an issue with that. When I say "forces upon," I
say that because the provincial government ultimately sets the rules and the laws
that municipalities operate under. In this case, though, every time this government in particular has a chance to make
their own rules, it's always "rules for thee and not for me." That is where we're
at again with these FOI changes in Bill 9. We have a government that is desperate to hide what they're actually doing, a government
that does not want the public to know who they're meeting with when and about what,
a government that certainly doesn't want to provide any clarity or line of sight as
to what is going on, on the DRIPA file, who they are meeting with, what the timeline is. Again, it's not just DRIPA. This impacts all sorts of other areas. We've heard from
the member from Kelowna and myself, who've met with distillers regularly who have
had many promises and many meetings with the government and timelines broken and not
met. Without the ability of FOI'ing and calendar access and understanding just how serious
the government is or isn't taking a file, it makes having those types of conversations
with people that are being impacted by government rules, regulations and tax policies
very, very difficult to understand what exactly the government is truly doing to move
an issue forward and what issues they're just simply deciding to go through the motions
and not actually ever intend to take meaningful or serious action on for any type
of industry that is critically needed. When you look at the mess that forestry is right now in the complete shambles and
the complete.... Well, it sounded like today that the Premier just gave up. He apparently
doesn't know how to work with Ottawa. He doesn't know how to negotiate with Ottawa.
He doesn't know how to get a benefit for British Columbians out of Ottawa. He essentially
shrugged and said that, well, there's nothing more he can do. He doesn't know what
else he can do to try to get Ottawa's attention on softwood. Well, here's the tip. Maybe the government shouldn't have walked away, letting a maritime
province for a lot of years be the head of the softwood table on behalf of all of
the provinces. Just one little suggestion as a sidebar there. But when you look at the mess that forestry is in, when you look at the concerns that
unions are bringing forward, when you look at the concerns that industry is bringing
forward, I think having more daylight, again, on issues around forestry without having
to go through the hoops of even further-restricted FOI documents would provide better
peace of mind and certainty if the government is truly intending on trying to action
or get results that they keep saying they're trying to do. But the results are not
matching the actions. When we hear in 2021, 2022 that the government is going to create 30,000 jobs in forestry
while they're projecting When we hear, in 2021-2022, that the government is going to create 30,000 jobs in
forestry while they're projecting $1 billion in revenue drop, and now we're at $1.3
billion in revenue drop in that time frame, yearly, and we have 15,000 job losses,
not 30,000 job gains, FOI would be a very helpful tool to have to find more certainty
around what decisions the government was rejecting while they were watching the forest
sector completely implode upon itself. It's not just the FOIs that we rely upon on what decisions were made. It's the FOIs
around what advice was being given or what suggestions were being provided that are
critically important, as well, to get a better sense of where the government actually
is on any given file, how serious they actually are on actually trying to solve the
issues of our time and how performative they're trying to be. If you look at the challenges in health care and the wait times, be it surgical wait
times, be it diagnostic wait times, be it cancer treatment wait times, all of those
types of situations.... Again, when was the minister briefed? How frequently does the
minister get briefed? What action did the minister take from those briefings? Did
the minister even care to pay any attention or enact anything that is being suggested
to try to change the system for the better? All of that gets discovered by freedom
of information. I think it's safe to say, if you're watching me speak right now at home, you probably
watch the odd question period, and you would know none of those questions will ever
get answered in question period. We'll ask. We'll keep doing our job as an opposition,
but let's not be under any illusions that this government routinely takes the question
and then answers on something completely off topic. If I tried doing that on this bill debate around Bill 9, the Chair, rightfully so,
would interrupt me and tell me: "Member, you need to be speaking to the bill." In
question period, it seems that this government, in an effort to hide and distract
away, not only completely avoids the question. They're talking about something completely
unrelated to what was even being asked. That's why we need FOI, because it used to
be you could reasonably get some direction and answers out of a government in question
period, but those days have long since passed. So when I see the provisions in Bill 9, when I see the government's excuses, frankly,
for why they say they need Bill 9, the governments want constantly to try to hide
information, try to make things more difficult, not be willing to get back to media
to answer their legitimate questions that they might have. It's interesting how quickly a minister's office will decide they actually can make
comment if they find out that the opposition has already made comment on a news story.
Well, if they're being that difficult just to get a 15-second sound clip, imagine
how difficult they're being to opposition and other people that are looking for information
when we start asking for information on any given file. A good example would be the speculation of vacancy tax, where the ministry had their
own audit done, and at least that was released, but it didn't have to be. We could
have actually found ourselves in a situation where, again, we're struggling and looking
for that information. Really, I guess at its core.... What's the expression about "fool me once"? You know,
we pushed back hard the last time they brought in FOI changes, and the government
insisted that they were still going to forge through and do them. It simply wasn't
acceptable. It wasn't good enough. They managed to do it. Now we've already seen the Premier back down multiple times on legislation. He's done
it with DRIPA. He's had contorted conditions on all sorts of legislation in this place
over the last couple of years. A bill like this — one would hope the government actually sees the writing on the
wall. They can actually.... They don't seem to care or want to understand why this is
such an offensive piece of legislation. They must think that it is nothing more than
political theatre by the opposition. But I can assure the government members that this is not political theatre on our
part. It's the government that tries to do more performative actions across the board
on a regular basis than actual tangible deliverables for the public. The fact that
their biggest priority with all the major crises facing us The fact that their biggest priority with all the major crises facing us seems to
be Bill 9, an FOI restriction act where it actually makes it much harder for the public,
opposition and media to gain access to government information, government decision-making,
government thought process.... That is their underlying, signature piece of legislation,
it seems, in this session. I mean, we did deal with a weighty miscellaneous stats bill last week, so they had
that going for them, I guess. But that's simply not something that works well. I thank you for the time on this bill, and I look forward to further debate.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Public finance
Well, before the Green interlude, the minister was getting quite the round of applause
from the Mutual Admiration Society across the way, so I'll give them another chance
for an applause line about their economic track record. Fastest deficit growth.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Negotiations
Happy to take my place in this debate on Bill 20. It's troubling, watching how events have unfolded over the last little while with
this government and how badly they have now handled even the treaty process. I say
that because we know that treaties do bring stability into regions where treaties
have been in place. We see that in other parts of the province where longer-standing treaties have been in place. But only this government could manage to mess up a system that has taken 30 years
to get us here, and yet they have still managed to completely bungle it when it comes
to talking and trying to better understand and have a treaty that can be better supported
by surrounding nations. I say that because this is a government that repeatedly over
the last little while — when we're talking about repealing DRIPA; when we're talking about the need to repeal DRIPA — insists that they are going
to do it by having conversations and talking and not just taking those types of steps. Yet here we have a treaty where other nations have very clearly said that not only
are they not being listened to, they're not being talked to by this government. It
seems very opposite of everything that this government has been trying to say to us. And so again, when they want to try to wag the finger and lecture us about proper
process and respectful conversations and moving documents forward and getting agreements,
that has not happened in this case. It is very clear by virtue of the hoist motion
we attempted as an amendment previous to this That has not happened in this case. It is very clear, by virtue of the hoist motion
we attempted as an amendment previous to this, that we are sincere about putting the
brakes on this so that further dialogue and discussions can actually happen. That's
what we are hearing from many in association with this particular treaty. There is
no harm in doing that. The government wants to walk the walk? Then they can do that. They can actually say
that they are true and sincere in their attempts. But unfortunately, political theatre
is what this government seems intent on. Political theatre around DRIPA — whether
it's going to be amendments, a three-year pause, a one-year pause, a pause until the
fall with amendments, or maybe it's a repeal.... "We're not really sure, because we're going to do the right thing, and we're going
to have those conversations. Yet we're going to rush through." I say "rush" in the
context of a 30-year document. I understand how that can sound a little bit contradictory. But a document 30 years in the making that this government has been responsible for,
for the last nine years of that 30 years, a third of this time.... And they've managed
to deliver a document that is rife with controversy and rife with lack of consultation,
lack of understanding of agreement of neighbouring nations with the treaty nation
that would be the beneficiary of this treaty. So I can't in good faith move forward with the document, knowing that that is the
backdrop on this. It's not about the fundamental principle of a treaty. It's about
just how badly this government yet again — time and again; it seems it doesn't matter
what topic we're talking about — sets a whole new bar for incompetence. And yet again,
they have done it on this. So I'm hard-pressed. I would welcome the government to point to any other treaties
that took 30 years to get negotiated, wound up in front of this chamber, started to
be debated and then had multiple, multiple groups saying: "Put the brakes on it. This
hasn't been done properly." But only this government, in their incompetence, could
manage to pull that off. Again, after nine years.... Nine long years of the last 30 years has been directly at
the hands of this government negotiating this treaty. So they can't talk and point
the finger back to the start. They can't even point the finger back, although that
30 years, I guess, they would have been in government even at the start of this or
close to it. They can't point the finger back there, nor can they even point it to
the midpoint. The reality is if they can't deliver a document in a nine-year period that was already
well underway, 21 years underway, with some certainty and some confidence and some
buy-in by the other nations, how does anyone have any faith that they could negotiate something between now and the
fall in regards to DRIPA? This is the insanity that is watching this unfold in front
of us with this government in terms of how they are handling the Indigenous file in
general. Every time they touch something it gets worse. Every single time. And this treaty
is just another example of that. I feel for the K'ómoks. They were understandably very excited around this, wanting
to see closure and a moving forward. But they ought to have known, or probably were
figuring out over the last nine years, that the government wasn't dealing with a full
deck. We need to make sure that this actually has had the proper oversight, overview, which
was the premise of the six-month hoist. It was not to try to kill the treaty completely;
it was about trying to give that breathing space as the minister has indicated, the
Attorney General has indicated, is much critically needed for DRIPA — the same time
frame as what our hoist motion was. And that suddenly was unacceptable to this government,
but on DRIPA, it's totally acceptable. Again, totally contradictory language — totally contradictory actions, more importantly.
It leads to uncertainty, not just within the project world and communities. It's leading
to a lot of uncertainty within Indigenous nations as to just what this government
actually truly believes in terms of working with Indigenous nations in good faith.
Is it that they only work in good faith with the ones that they deem to be acceptable
in working with them, or will they work truly with all 204 First Nations? So I can't find myself in a position of not being able to support this treaty. I truly
feel that I'm fortunate that the government decided to try to ram it through and not
support the hoist motion. They will have to deal with the consequences of yet another
mishandled file on their part of utter incompetence when it comes to dealing with
issues around Indigenous relations. Thank you for the time. Thank you for the time.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Budgets, Public finance
I'll endeavour to have the minister still be looking forward to my questions as we
hit hour 15, but we'll see where that goes. In terms of the overall budget, I have been looking through and searching and searching
and searching, and I'm unable to locate.... I've had many, many property owners and
people in Richmond with great interest asking where exactly the mortgage backing program
the Premier has promised for people in Richmond would be in this budget. Can the minister point to where in this budget the Premier's commitment pre-budget
that mortgages would be backstopped by the provincial government for people in Richmond
based on the Cowichan ruling resides? Can the minister point to where in this budget the Premier's commitment prebudget
that mortgages would be backstopped by the provincial government for people in Richmond
based on the Quw'utsun ruling resides?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Budgets, Public finance
Does the minister feel that this year's three-year fiscal plan lays out the start
of a pathway to a balanced budget? How confident is she, if that's the case?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Budgets, Economic issues, Finance, Negotiations, Public finance
I guess Thursday when I was questioning around contingencies the minister said, in
response to the member's question, that it is true that the negotiations took longer
than expected and that the cost of the mandate did go up. That is captured in the
increase in the contingency fund. The contingency fund last year was projected to
be $4 billion this year. It is now $5 billion moving forward, and last year was projected
to be $4 billion, not just this year but the subsequent year. Can the minister confirm then by her answer that means that the mandate, the negotiations
with the public sector, has been $1 billion more than the government expected?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Budgets, Contracts, Finance, Public finance
Well, I'm no lawyer, but that certainly sounds like the Interpretation Act changes
that the Premier brought in as the Attorney General have made one confusing legal
mess of things in British Columbia. At the beginning, in the Premier's opening statements, he waxed poetically about the
Westminster system and how wonderful it is to be in budget estimates where the public
can hear full scrutiny and disclosure from the government on things of importance
to the public. Yesterday when I was in budget estimates with the Finance Minister, I was actually
heartened by some proactive disclosure at the same time as we were debating Bill 9
in a different chamber, which is FOI legislation which would severely restrict people's
access to information from the government. The minister proactively disclosed a document
to me, the Treasury Board directive she signed off on, on April 30, while I was questioning
around costs of FIFA. Part of the directive she signed off on, on page 5, is 5(b): if the government of
B.C. or a government organization is subject to a purchase agreement in relation to
provincial FIFA World Cup 26 tickets, it will strictly comply with the terms of that
agreement. So the minister signed off on this directive, Treasury Board directive.
It's got her signature on it. She provided it, fully and wholly, over to me. The problem is that then I asked a question in relation to the document she then provided.
I said the minister signed off on these directions. I'm asking what the cost is of
what she agreed to. If she doesn't know what the cost was when she signed off on the
directive that says the government of B.C. is subject to purchase agreement in relation
to tickets and will strictly comply to the terms of that agreement, that sounds like
a blank cheque. So did the minister know I'm asking what the cost is of what she agreed to. If she doesn't know what the cost
was when she signed off on the directive that says the government of B.C. is subject
to purchase agreement in relation to tickets and will strictly comply to the terms
of that agreement, that sounds like a blank cheque. So did the minister know when she signed off on this directive April 30, 2026, which
was not that long ago, what the cost of the suites were going to be? Or did she not
know what the cost of the suites would be, which would fall under "strictly comply with the terms of agreement" around ticket allocations for FIFA World Cup 2026? It has to be one or the other. Either on April 30 the minister knew what the cost
of the suites were going to be and she should be able to provide that figure today,
or she didn't know and she signed off on a directive that creates a blank cheque for
obligations under FIFA that the government was unaware of on April 30, 2026. To which the minister shockingly replied — again, proactive disclosure: "I suggest
to the member there is a third option, which is that the minister does know and is
deferring to the Ministry of Tourism, Arts, and Culture to give their update, which they plan to do in the coming days." Which to the outside
world might sound like a reasonable answer. In fact, I believe Madam Chair was in the chair when I asked her whether or not ministers
are expected to answer questions that they've actually fully acknowledged they have
the answer to in the middle of budget estimates which, based on her signed directive,
she is directly responsible for. But the minister refused. So I would like to give the Premier the opportunity, as the head of government, to
answer that question which, obviously, government does have the answer to. It may
be in government's convenience to release it as a package with the minister after
this House rises, conveniently not before the Premier's estimates. But his own minister.... By all accounts, everyone agrees in most.... You have the Attorney General and you have
the Finance Minister. Those are kind of the two big heads of ministerial roles. She has acknowledged she signed a directive on April 30 of this year to make sure
you fully participate in all ticket packages required by FIFA. It was a direct question
around what the cost of the suite package is. Not how they were being allocated, not
who was going into the suites — the cost. And she replied she has the answer but refused
to give the answer. That is not acceptable. I hope the Premier would think that's
not acceptable, as well, for the public. So what is the actual cost of the suite package for these seven games that this government
has agreed to under the provisions of the FIFA contract and the Treasury Board directive
signed by his own Finance Minister on April 30?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Fiscal issues
I'm happy to take my place in the debate. Although my colleague before me may have
been not clear on whether he was opposed to this bill or not, I certainly am. Yes,
that's a little Zoom humour because he was most definitely very clear in his opposition,
as I have been as well. The reality of this bill is that we've seen this with this government repeatedly.
I'm going to take a little bit of the time to go back down memory lane when it comes
to FOI with this government. It was not that long ago that a minister spent days defending
changes to the FOI Act, defending changes to making it where you have to pay a fee
to file an FOI. There was a lot of concern legitimately raised at that point. There was a lot of concern around what would that fee be. And the answer for days
was: "We don't know what the fee will be because we still have to consult. And so
we're not sure if it'll be $5. We're not sure if it'll be $10. We're not sure if it'll
be $20, but there will be a fee, and we're going to consult." Day after day, question
after question that was asked about this, that was the deflection. It was an admirable
performance by the minister at the time, I must say, in terms of being able to stick
to a speaking point. It may have felt good in the moment inside the chamber for that minister to continue
down that path. It certainly didn't play well out in the general public. It didn't
play well in the media. And it certainly didn't play well when we discovered that
within a few minutes of the bill being passed, an order in council was signed in the
hallway of the Legislature setting the fee at $10. Apparently, those multiple days
on end of questions but no answers during committee stage qualified as consultation
and checking in to see with stakeholders what the fee should be. That is fundamentally the core problem with this government. They repeatedly hide
and evade information. Now, if this was a government that actually, I don't know,
even answered questions in question period directly, maybe people wouldn't be as concerned
about Bill 9 and changes to FOI to make it even harder to access government information.
Maybe if ministers when they were asked direct questions in budget estimates or in
committee stages of bills, very straightforward, sometimes actually routine procedural
questions about a piece of legislation, answered it upfront and didn't take five different
questions to get a very basic answer out of them, perhaps people wouldn't be as worried. I can think back to one time. It was when LNG was being brought forward. I was the
environment critic at the time and, then, Minister Heyman. There was very simple language
in the bill, and it was about setting the emission standards for LNG moving forward.
It very clearly had, basically, boilerplate language in it that said that the minister
through orders in council could set emission levels for LNG projects. All I simply
asked was: does that mean to set the LNG emission profile, that would not have to
come back to the Legislature, that would just could be done over summertime by an
order in council signature? The minister repeatedly answered: "Well, I don't have lawyers here. I can't answer
legal questions about this bill." That was a ridiculous question in the first place,
because every piece of legislation is a legal document. But it was because, frankly,
the minister didn't want to be seen to be responsible as the one setting LNG emissions. Obviously, as the former head of Sierra Club, he was probably not thrilled that he
was going to have to be the signatory not only to the massive tax breaks that were
given to LNG Canada but also to developing and signing off on what the emission profile
for LNG was going to be. Now, I raise all that because it just demonstrates a repeated and continuing erosion Now, I raise all that because it just demonstrates a repeated and continuing erosion
of access to basic information. The minister eventually acknowledged that, yes, indeed,
that's exactly what that language means. We all know it. We see it in every piece
of legislation. We don't need lawyers to tell us that's what it actually means, but
that was the first four or five answers from the minister. Around and around we had
to dance to try to get an upfront answer. So if you're a member of the public or if you're a member of the media.... Imagine how
frustrating it must be for them to try to get a straight answer out of members of
government. That's why we have FOI in the first place. We have FOI because if government
chooses to not be proactive with their disclosure, if government chooses to pick and
choose when they want information to come out, if they want to try to redact, if they
want to try to otherwise hide what is going on in government, it is critically important. I can think back to budget estimates last year when I was asking questions about online
gaming and lobbying efforts that were happening, and the minister insisted that there
hadn't been meetings. In a follow-up question, I was able to provide an actual date
that a senior bureaucrat met with online gaming. And then the minister had to say:
"Oh, oh yeah, actually we did have some meetings." Had I not had that document and that understanding of those calendars, the follow-up
question wouldn't have been asked. We would have simply taken the first question at
face value, which was a question that later turned out — literally, by later, the
next question or two — to not be entirely accurate and not paint an accurate picture
of something as fundamentally important as the expansion of online gaming or not and
the regulatory framework that would look like for online gaming in British Columbia. To the average person at home, you might think: "Well, what's the big deal around
that?" Well, there are pros and cons with gaming, and there are pros and cons with
online gaming, especially, in terms of addiction, in terms of gambling problems and
issues that come forward in that way. I think those are fair questions to ask. Where
exactly industry is headed, where government is headed for any potential expansion
or not on something that can be as addictive as online gaming, understanding what
those timelines are, understanding who's lobbying and what they're lobbying for —
all of that is critically important. If you had a government that was proactively releasing information, proactively talking
about things, not always making you jump through hoops trying to get the most basic
information, you might have a little less heartburn or apprehension about Bill 9.
But that's not the case. Sadly, we have a government that has routinely been acknowledged
as the most secretive government in Canada. We have a government, even on something as simple and basic as a $6,600 limo bill....
The minister.... No, she was not the Minister of Finance at the time, but she was a
minister. She was in Boston, and there were car charges for $6,600. Yet this government
wants to try to pretend it didn't happen. And members of the opposition will hoot
and howl and say that it's not true, that it didn't happen. Well, then why was it
claimed? Using the excuse, "Well, it was a town car; it wasn't a limo," doesn't really matter
to the taxpayer. The taxpayer wants to know why $6,600 was spent on that limo ride
for the weekend instead of a few Ubers to get around. No one begrudges that staff
and ministers have to travel and have to get around and be transported around large
cities. That makes perfect sense. A $6,600 limo ride to accomplish that does seem
a tad excessive. There's been a wide range of other FOIs on these types of issues. When you look at
the state we're in right now and issues around DRIPA, meetings that would be happening
around DRIPA, I think the public.... More daylight is much better than less. You know,
this is why the government that keeps taking steps on Bill 9, especially in the backdrop
of all that's unfolding right now and ever-tanking popularity numbers by a Premier
and his government, makes one second-guess and ponder. Just what exactly are they afraid is going to be discovered through FOI that they're
scrambling to try to get new laws in place before those FOI filings get filed? I think
it's a legitimate concern. I don't tend to be known as one that's a big conspiracy
theorist or goes over the top with distrust, but I actually do have concerns that
the timing of this I don't tend to be known as one that's a big conspiracy theorist or that goes over
the top with distrust, but I actually do have concerns that the timing of this legislation,
given all the other issues going on in British Columbia right now and all the serious
nature of things, is being brought forward at a time where we can't see a tangible
benefit for it, other than restricting the public's, the media's and the opposition's
access to information. You know, when we're looking at the past practice of this government, when we're looking
at past pieces of legislation, when we're looking at actions taken — again, not just
on travel but on decisions that this government has made, things like briefing notes
or estimates binders, a wide range of issues — a lot of times what happens is that
when you pull on the thread, you get a bit of a path. So you start heading down one way, and then you say: "Oh, hang on. Now with that piece
of information, I never imagined that that would have been the answer. So I guess
we'd better start looking over here as well now." That's the critical importance of
FOI. Sometimes we're fortunate enough that we stumble upon that when we're in budget estimates.
So we have a piece of an FOI document, or we have a series of questions, and the answer
comes back, different than we were expecting. That actually engages a whole series
of FOIs that might happen, because what we assumed was happening in government is
in fact not what's happening. An example I'll use on this is that a few years ago, when I was questioning around
the budget and the government made a big, big deal that there were $70 million for
reconciliation efforts put into the budget. Now I was asked on budget day what to
point out as something good in the budget. I said: "Oh, that sounds like it's a good
thing, if there's more capacity for municipalities and nations to work together to
actually move projects forward quickly and get things accomplished." Then you fast-forward to budget estimates, and I thought I would ask a few questions
of the Minister of Indigenous Relations. I said: "Well, how did we come to that dollar
figure? Frankly, I was going to be a bit of a smart aleck with a couple of those questions,
because the minister, before he became part of government, between being an MP — he
was Minister Rankin at the time — and a minister in an election, had resigned as an
MP. His placeholder work, granted to him by the NDP, was to be a highly paid First Nations
consultant, and Nathan Cullen had the same deal. It was a very convenient work transition,
for both of those gentlemen — to be able to resign as an MP, wait to run to become
an MLA, and get very highly lucrative consulting contracts to work with the government
and First Nations. I was going to basically do a calculation of how much they were getting paid per hour
back in their consultant days and figure out how many hours of consulting this $70
million was going to accomplish. What surprised me was actually the answer. The answer
was: "Well, this is what we've historically always spent." At that, I instantly switched gears and said: "Well, this is supposed to be new money.
This is supposed to be expanded money. What do you mean that this is what has always
been spent?" It turns out that all it was, was that instead of taking it out of contingencies
every year, government just decided to make it a permanent line item. Fine, except
don't start marketing it as "new, expanded, never been done before, enhanced and going
to provide extra" — all that type of language that was used. Why it matters is because in this case, we were able to get to an answer during budget
estimates. However, with these changes to FOI, had we wanted to follow up with an
FOI based on those lines of questioning to see exactly how they got to a historic
average of $70 million of reconciliation spending in any given year, this Bill 9 would
have made that next to impossible, after budget estimates are over, for the opposition
to follow up, fact-check, verify and dig deeper into some of the answers ministers
give. Now, let's remember we have limited time in budget estimates to actually fully question,
especially when ministers start to be evasive with their answers. It starts to chew
up the clock, and they sometimes turn around and take ten minutes to chit-chat with
staff. You can hear them in the smaller committee rooms. They're quite literally talking
about holiday plans and weekend plans and things to kill a clock. They sometimes turn around and take ten minutes to chit-chat with staff. You can hear
them in the smaller committee rooms. They're quite literally talking about holiday
plans and weekend plans and things to kill a clock. Then they turn around, and they
give you a non-answer and hope that you'll move on to a different subject because
they know that we're up against a clock. They do that quite frequently, frankly, and it gets worse the farther we go into a
session and the more desperate a government becomes with reduced polling numbers.
So I fully expect, as we continue on with budget estimates, that will probably continue. The key to it, though, is that, as opposition, that means if we don't get through
all of our material or we get answers that we wanted more follow-up on but we don't
have the time in that current moment to follow up, we would actually access and leverage
an FOI to try to actually get that information or see, again, if the minister is being
forthright with the public about what's truly going on behind the scenes. Now, Bill 9, when I heard that the government was bringing in a bill around FOI reform
and changes, I was actually hoping they would've learned from the last go-around and
actually been bringing in changes to improve FOI access, not make it even harder and
make it essentially nonexistent. It's a way to basically have something on the books
that says you have freedom of information but that, in fact, it doesn't actually exist. Now, when I was the mayor of Kamloops, I got FOI'd a lot, as did council, as a matter
of practice for media and others. In fact, our disclosure and our turnaround and our
expectation of providing and redacting was much more open and transparent than what
the provincial government operates under. Interestingly enough, it's rules the provincial government forces upon municipalities
to operate that way. I don't have an issue with that. When I say "forces upon," I
say that because the provincial government ultimately sets the rules and the laws
that municipalities operate under. In this case, though, every time this government in particular has a chance to make
their own rules, it's always "rules for thee and not for me." That is where we're
at again with these FOI changes in Bill 9. We have a government that is desperate to hide what they're actually doing, a government
that does not want the public to know who they're meeting with when and about what,
a government that certainly doesn't want to provide any clarity or line of sight as
to what is going on, on the DRIPA file, who they are meeting with, what the timeline is. Again, it's not just DRIPA. This impacts all sorts of other areas. We've heard from
the member from Kelowna and myself, who've met with distillers regularly who have
had many promises and many meetings with the government and timelines broken and not
met. Without the ability of FOI'ing and calendar access and understanding just how serious
the government is or isn't taking a file, it makes having those types of conversations
with people that are being impacted by government rules, regulations and tax policies
very, very difficult to understand what exactly the government is truly doing to move
an issue forward and what issues they're just simply deciding to go through the motions
and not actually ever intend to take meaningful or serious action on for any type
of industry that is critically needed. When you look at the mess that forestry is right now in the complete shambles and
the complete.... Well, it sounded like today that the Premier just gave up. He apparently
doesn't know how to work with Ottawa. He doesn't know how to negotiate with Ottawa.
He doesn't know how to get a benefit for British Columbians out of Ottawa. He essentially
shrugged and said that, well, there's nothing more he can do. He doesn't know what
else he can do to try to get Ottawa's attention on softwood. Well, here's the tip. Maybe the government shouldn't have walked away, letting a maritime
province for a lot of years be the head of the softwood table on behalf of all of
the provinces. Just one little suggestion as a sidebar there. But when you look at the mess that forestry is in, when you look at the concerns that
unions are bringing forward, when you look at the concerns that industry is bringing
forward, I think having more daylight, again, on issues around forestry without having
to go through the hoops of even further-restricted FOI documents would provide better
peace of mind and certainty if the government is truly intending on trying to action
or get results that they keep saying they're trying to do. But the results are not
matching the actions. When we hear in 2021, 2022 that the government is going to create 30,000 jobs in forestry
while they're projecting When we hear, in 2021-2022, that the government is going to create 30,000 jobs in
forestry while they're projecting $1 billion in revenue drop, and now we're at $1.3
billion in revenue drop in that time frame, yearly, and we have 15,000 job losses,
not 30,000 job gains, FOI would be a very helpful tool to have to find more certainty
around what decisions the government was rejecting while they were watching the forest
sector completely implode upon itself. It's not just the FOIs that we rely upon on what decisions were made. It's the FOIs
around what advice was being given or what suggestions were being provided that are
critically important, as well, to get a better sense of where the government actually
is on any given file, how serious they actually are on actually trying to solve the
issues of our time and how performative they're trying to be. If you look at the challenges in health care and the wait times, be it surgical wait
times, be it diagnostic wait times, be it cancer treatment wait times, all of those
types of situations.... Again, when was the minister briefed? How frequently does the
minister get briefed? What action did the minister take from those briefings? Did
the minister even care to pay any attention or enact anything that is being suggested
to try to change the system for the better? All of that gets discovered by freedom
of information. I think it's safe to say, if you're watching me speak right now at home, you probably
watch the odd question period, and you would know none of those questions will ever
get answered in question period. We'll ask. We'll keep doing our job as an opposition,
but let's not be under any illusions that this government routinely takes the question
and then answers on something completely off topic. If I tried doing that on this bill debate around Bill 9, the Chair, rightfully so,
would interrupt me and tell me: "Member, you need to be speaking to the bill." In
question period, it seems that this government, in an effort to hide and distract
away, not only completely avoids the question. They're talking about something completely
unrelated to what was even being asked. That's why we need FOI, because it used to
be you could reasonably get some direction and answers out of a government in question
period, but those days have long since passed. So when I see the provisions in Bill 9, when I see the government's excuses, frankly,
for why they say they need Bill 9, the governments want constantly to try to hide
information, try to make things more difficult, not be willing to get back to media
to answer their legitimate questions that they might have. It's interesting how quickly a minister's office will decide they actually can make
comment if they find out that the opposition has already made comment on a news story.
Well, if they're being that difficult just to get a 15-second sound clip, imagine
how difficult they're being to opposition and other people that are looking for information
when we start asking for information on any given file. A good example would be the speculation of vacancy tax, where the ministry had their
own audit done, and at least that was released, but it didn't have to be. We could
have actually found ourselves in a situation where, again, we're struggling and looking
for that information. Really, I guess at its core.... What's the expression about "fool me once"? You know,
we pushed back hard the last time they brought in FOI changes, and the government
insisted that they were still going to forge through and do them. It simply wasn't
acceptable. It wasn't good enough. They managed to do it. Now we've already seen the Premier back down multiple times on legislation. He's done
it with DRIPA. He's had contorted conditions on all sorts of legislation in this place
over the last couple of years. A bill like this — one would hope the government actually sees the writing on the
wall. They can actually.... They don't seem to care or want to understand why this is
such an offensive piece of legislation. They must think that it is nothing more than
political theatre by the opposition. But I can assure the government members that this is not political theatre on our
part. It's the government that tries to do more performative actions across the board
on a regular basis than actual tangible deliverables for the public. The fact that
their biggest priority with all the major crises facing us The fact that their biggest priority with all the major crises facing us seems to
be Bill 9, an FOI restriction act where it actually makes it much harder for the public,
opposition and media to gain access to government information, government decision-making,
government thought process.... That is their underlying, signature piece of legislation,
it seems, in this session. I mean, we did deal with a weighty miscellaneous stats bill last week, so they had
that going for them, I guess. But that's simply not something that works well. I thank you for the time on this bill, and I look forward to further debate.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Fiscal issues
I'll endeavour to have the minister still be looking forward to my questions as we
hit hour 15, but we'll see where that goes. In terms of the overall budget, I have been looking through and searching and searching
and searching, and I'm unable to locate.... I've had many, many property owners and
people in Richmond with great interest asking where exactly the mortgage backing program
the Premier has promised for people in Richmond would be in this budget. Can the minister point to where in this budget the Premier's commitment pre-budget
that mortgages would be backstopped by the provincial government for people in Richmond
based on the Cowichan ruling resides? Can the minister point to where in this budget the Premier's commitment prebudget
that mortgages would be backstopped by the provincial government for people in Richmond
based on the Quw'utsun ruling resides?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Fiscal issues
Does the minister feel that this year's three-year fiscal plan lays out the start
of a pathway to a balanced budget? How confident is she, if that's the case?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Fiscal issues, Funding, Public funding
I guess Thursday when I was questioning around contingencies the minister said, in
response to the member's question, that it is true that the negotiations took longer
than expected and that the cost of the mandate did go up. That is captured in the
increase in the contingency fund. The contingency fund last year was projected to
be $4 billion this year. It is now $5 billion moving forward, and last year was projected
to be $4 billion, not just this year but the subsequent year. Can the minister confirm then by her answer that means that the mandate, the negotiations
with the public sector, has been $1 billion more than the government expected?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Fiscal issues, Public funding
Well, I'm no lawyer, but that certainly sounds like the Interpretation Act changes
that the Premier brought in as the Attorney General have made one confusing legal
mess of things in British Columbia. At the beginning, in the Premier's opening statements, he waxed poetically about the
Westminster system and how wonderful it is to be in budget estimates where the public
can hear full scrutiny and disclosure from the government on things of importance
to the public. Yesterday when I was in budget estimates with the Finance Minister, I was actually
heartened by some proactive disclosure at the same time as we were debating Bill 9
in a different chamber, which is FOI legislation which would severely restrict people's
access to information from the government. The minister proactively disclosed a document
to me, the Treasury Board directive she signed off on, on April 30, while I was questioning
around costs of FIFA. Part of the directive she signed off on, on page 5, is 5(b): if the government of
B.C. or a government organization is subject to a purchase agreement in relation to
provincial FIFA World Cup 26 tickets, it will strictly comply with the terms of that
agreement. So the minister signed off on this directive, Treasury Board directive.
It's got her signature on it. She provided it, fully and wholly, over to me. The problem is that then I asked a question in relation to the document she then provided.
I said the minister signed off on these directions. I'm asking what the cost is of
what she agreed to. If she doesn't know what the cost was when she signed off on the
directive that says the government of B.C. is subject to purchase agreement in relation
to tickets and will strictly comply to the terms of that agreement, that sounds like
a blank cheque. So did the minister know I'm asking what the cost is of what she agreed to. If she doesn't know what the cost
was when she signed off on the directive that says the government of B.C. is subject
to purchase agreement in relation to tickets and will strictly comply to the terms
of that agreement, that sounds like a blank cheque. So did the minister know when she signed off on this directive April 30, 2026, which
was not that long ago, what the cost of the suites were going to be? Or did she not
know what the cost of the suites would be, which would fall under "strictly comply with the terms of agreement" around ticket allocations for FIFA World Cup 2026? It has to be one or the other. Either on April 30 the minister knew what the cost
of the suites were going to be and she should be able to provide that figure today,
or she didn't know and she signed off on a directive that creates a blank cheque for
obligations under FIFA that the government was unaware of on April 30, 2026. To which the minister shockingly replied — again, proactive disclosure: "I suggest
to the member there is a third option, which is that the minister does know and is
deferring to the Ministry of Tourism, Arts, and Culture to give their update, which they plan to do in the coming days." Which to the outside
world might sound like a reasonable answer. In fact, I believe Madam Chair was in the chair when I asked her whether or not ministers
are expected to answer questions that they've actually fully acknowledged they have
the answer to in the middle of budget estimates which, based on her signed directive,
she is directly responsible for. But the minister refused. So I would like to give the Premier the opportunity, as the head of government, to
answer that question which, obviously, government does have the answer to. It may
be in government's convenience to release it as a package with the minister after
this House rises, conveniently not before the Premier's estimates. But his own minister.... By all accounts, everyone agrees in most.... You have the Attorney General and you have
the Finance Minister. Those are kind of the two big heads of ministerial roles. She has acknowledged she signed a directive on April 30 of this year to make sure
you fully participate in all ticket packages required by FIFA. It was a direct question
around what the cost of the suite package is. Not how they were being allocated, not
who was going into the suites — the cost. And she replied she has the answer but refused
to give the answer. That is not acceptable. I hope the Premier would think that's
not acceptable, as well, for the public. So what is the actual cost of the suite package for these seven games that this government
has agreed to under the provisions of the FIFA contract and the Treasury Board directive
signed by his own Finance Minister on April 30?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Provincial governments, Public administration
I'm happy to take my place in the debate. Although my colleague before me may have
been not clear on whether he was opposed to this bill or not, I certainly am. Yes,
that's a little Zoom humour because he was most definitely very clear in his opposition,
as I have been as well. The reality of this bill is that we've seen this with this government repeatedly.
I'm going to take a little bit of the time to go back down memory lane when it comes
to FOI with this government. It was not that long ago that a minister spent days defending
changes to the FOI Act, defending changes to making it where you have to pay a fee
to file an FOI. There was a lot of concern legitimately raised at that point. There was a lot of concern around what would that fee be. And the answer for days
was: "We don't know what the fee will be because we still have to consult. And so
we're not sure if it'll be $5. We're not sure if it'll be $10. We're not sure if it'll
be $20, but there will be a fee, and we're going to consult." Day after day, question
after question that was asked about this, that was the deflection. It was an admirable
performance by the minister at the time, I must say, in terms of being able to stick
to a speaking point. It may have felt good in the moment inside the chamber for that minister to continue
down that path. It certainly didn't play well out in the general public. It didn't
play well in the media. And it certainly didn't play well when we discovered that
within a few minutes of the bill being passed, an order in council was signed in the
hallway of the Legislature setting the fee at $10. Apparently, those multiple days
on end of questions but no answers during committee stage qualified as consultation
and checking in to see with stakeholders what the fee should be. That is fundamentally the core problem with this government. They repeatedly hide
and evade information. Now, if this was a government that actually, I don't know,
even answered questions in question period directly, maybe people wouldn't be as concerned
about Bill 9 and changes to FOI to make it even harder to access government information.
Maybe if ministers when they were asked direct questions in budget estimates or in
committee stages of bills, very straightforward, sometimes actually routine procedural
questions about a piece of legislation, answered it upfront and didn't take five different
questions to get a very basic answer out of them, perhaps people wouldn't be as worried. I can think back to one time. It was when LNG was being brought forward. I was the
environment critic at the time and, then, Minister Heyman. There was very simple language
in the bill, and it was about setting the emission standards for LNG moving forward.
It very clearly had, basically, boilerplate language in it that said that the minister
through orders in council could set emission levels for LNG projects. All I simply
asked was: does that mean to set the LNG emission profile, that would not have to
come back to the Legislature, that would just could be done over summertime by an
order in council signature? The minister repeatedly answered: "Well, I don't have lawyers here. I can't answer
legal questions about this bill." That was a ridiculous question in the first place,
because every piece of legislation is a legal document. But it was because, frankly,
the minister didn't want to be seen to be responsible as the one setting LNG emissions. Obviously, as the former head of Sierra Club, he was probably not thrilled that he
was going to have to be the signatory not only to the massive tax breaks that were
given to LNG Canada but also to developing and signing off on what the emission profile
for LNG was going to be. Now, I raise all that because it just demonstrates a repeated and continuing erosion Now, I raise all that because it just demonstrates a repeated and continuing erosion
of access to basic information. The minister eventually acknowledged that, yes, indeed,
that's exactly what that language means. We all know it. We see it in every piece
of legislation. We don't need lawyers to tell us that's what it actually means, but
that was the first four or five answers from the minister. Around and around we had
to dance to try to get an upfront answer. So if you're a member of the public or if you're a member of the media.... Imagine how
frustrating it must be for them to try to get a straight answer out of members of
government. That's why we have FOI in the first place. We have FOI because if government
chooses to not be proactive with their disclosure, if government chooses to pick and
choose when they want information to come out, if they want to try to redact, if they
want to try to otherwise hide what is going on in government, it is critically important. I can think back to budget estimates last year when I was asking questions about online
gaming and lobbying efforts that were happening, and the minister insisted that there
hadn't been meetings. In a follow-up question, I was able to provide an actual date
that a senior bureaucrat met with online gaming. And then the minister had to say:
"Oh, oh yeah, actually we did have some meetings." Had I not had that document and that understanding of those calendars, the follow-up
question wouldn't have been asked. We would have simply taken the first question at
face value, which was a question that later turned out — literally, by later, the
next question or two — to not be entirely accurate and not paint an accurate picture
of something as fundamentally important as the expansion of online gaming or not and
the regulatory framework that would look like for online gaming in British Columbia. To the average person at home, you might think: "Well, what's the big deal around
that?" Well, there are pros and cons with gaming, and there are pros and cons with
online gaming, especially, in terms of addiction, in terms of gambling problems and
issues that come forward in that way. I think those are fair questions to ask. Where
exactly industry is headed, where government is headed for any potential expansion
or not on something that can be as addictive as online gaming, understanding what
those timelines are, understanding who's lobbying and what they're lobbying for —
all of that is critically important. If you had a government that was proactively releasing information, proactively talking
about things, not always making you jump through hoops trying to get the most basic
information, you might have a little less heartburn or apprehension about Bill 9.
But that's not the case. Sadly, we have a government that has routinely been acknowledged
as the most secretive government in Canada. We have a government, even on something as simple and basic as a $6,600 limo bill....
The minister.... No, she was not the Minister of Finance at the time, but she was a
minister. She was in Boston, and there were car charges for $6,600. Yet this government
wants to try to pretend it didn't happen. And members of the opposition will hoot
and howl and say that it's not true, that it didn't happen. Well, then why was it
claimed? Using the excuse, "Well, it was a town car; it wasn't a limo," doesn't really matter
to the taxpayer. The taxpayer wants to know why $6,600 was spent on that limo ride
for the weekend instead of a few Ubers to get around. No one begrudges that staff
and ministers have to travel and have to get around and be transported around large
cities. That makes perfect sense. A $6,600 limo ride to accomplish that does seem
a tad excessive. There's been a wide range of other FOIs on these types of issues. When you look at
the state we're in right now and issues around DRIPA, meetings that would be happening
around DRIPA, I think the public.... More daylight is much better than less. You know,
this is why the government that keeps taking steps on Bill 9, especially in the backdrop
of all that's unfolding right now and ever-tanking popularity numbers by a Premier
and his government, makes one second-guess and ponder. Just what exactly are they afraid is going to be discovered through FOI that they're
scrambling to try to get new laws in place before those FOI filings get filed? I think
it's a legitimate concern. I don't tend to be known as one that's a big conspiracy
theorist or goes over the top with distrust, but I actually do have concerns that
the timing of this I don't tend to be known as one that's a big conspiracy theorist or that goes over
the top with distrust, but I actually do have concerns that the timing of this legislation,
given all the other issues going on in British Columbia right now and all the serious
nature of things, is being brought forward at a time where we can't see a tangible
benefit for it, other than restricting the public's, the media's and the opposition's
access to information. You know, when we're looking at the past practice of this government, when we're looking
at past pieces of legislation, when we're looking at actions taken — again, not just
on travel but on decisions that this government has made, things like briefing notes
or estimates binders, a wide range of issues — a lot of times what happens is that
when you pull on the thread, you get a bit of a path. So you start heading down one way, and then you say: "Oh, hang on. Now with that piece
of information, I never imagined that that would have been the answer. So I guess
we'd better start looking over here as well now." That's the critical importance of
FOI. Sometimes we're fortunate enough that we stumble upon that when we're in budget estimates.
So we have a piece of an FOI document, or we have a series of questions, and the answer
comes back, different than we were expecting. That actually engages a whole series
of FOIs that might happen, because what we assumed was happening in government is
in fact not what's happening. An example I'll use on this is that a few years ago, when I was questioning around
the budget and the government made a big, big deal that there were $70 million for
reconciliation efforts put into the budget. Now I was asked on budget day what to
point out as something good in the budget. I said: "Oh, that sounds like it's a good
thing, if there's more capacity for municipalities and nations to work together to
actually move projects forward quickly and get things accomplished." Then you fast-forward to budget estimates, and I thought I would ask a few questions
of the Minister of Indigenous Relations. I said: "Well, how did we come to that dollar
figure? Frankly, I was going to be a bit of a smart aleck with a couple of those questions,
because the minister, before he became part of government, between being an MP — he
was Minister Rankin at the time — and a minister in an election, had resigned as an
MP. His placeholder work, granted to him by the NDP, was to be a highly paid First Nations
consultant, and Nathan Cullen had the same deal. It was a very convenient work transition,
for both of those gentlemen — to be able to resign as an MP, wait to run to become
an MLA, and get very highly lucrative consulting contracts to work with the government
and First Nations. I was going to basically do a calculation of how much they were getting paid per hour
back in their consultant days and figure out how many hours of consulting this $70
million was going to accomplish. What surprised me was actually the answer. The answer
was: "Well, this is what we've historically always spent." At that, I instantly switched gears and said: "Well, this is supposed to be new money.
This is supposed to be expanded money. What do you mean that this is what has always
been spent?" It turns out that all it was, was that instead of taking it out of contingencies
every year, government just decided to make it a permanent line item. Fine, except
don't start marketing it as "new, expanded, never been done before, enhanced and going
to provide extra" — all that type of language that was used. Why it matters is because in this case, we were able to get to an answer during budget
estimates. However, with these changes to FOI, had we wanted to follow up with an
FOI based on those lines of questioning to see exactly how they got to a historic
average of $70 million of reconciliation spending in any given year, this Bill 9 would
have made that next to impossible, after budget estimates are over, for the opposition
to follow up, fact-check, verify and dig deeper into some of the answers ministers
give. Now, let's remember we have limited time in budget estimates to actually fully question,
especially when ministers start to be evasive with their answers. It starts to chew
up the clock, and they sometimes turn around and take ten minutes to chit-chat with
staff. You can hear them in the smaller committee rooms. They're quite literally talking
about holiday plans and weekend plans and things to kill a clock. They sometimes turn around and take ten minutes to chit-chat with staff. You can hear
them in the smaller committee rooms. They're quite literally talking about holiday
plans and weekend plans and things to kill a clock. Then they turn around, and they
give you a non-answer and hope that you'll move on to a different subject because
they know that we're up against a clock. They do that quite frequently, frankly, and it gets worse the farther we go into a
session and the more desperate a government becomes with reduced polling numbers.
So I fully expect, as we continue on with budget estimates, that will probably continue. The key to it, though, is that, as opposition, that means if we don't get through
all of our material or we get answers that we wanted more follow-up on but we don't
have the time in that current moment to follow up, we would actually access and leverage
an FOI to try to actually get that information or see, again, if the minister is being
forthright with the public about what's truly going on behind the scenes. Now, Bill 9, when I heard that the government was bringing in a bill around FOI reform
and changes, I was actually hoping they would've learned from the last go-around and
actually been bringing in changes to improve FOI access, not make it even harder and
make it essentially nonexistent. It's a way to basically have something on the books
that says you have freedom of information but that, in fact, it doesn't actually exist. Now, when I was the mayor of Kamloops, I got FOI'd a lot, as did council, as a matter
of practice for media and others. In fact, our disclosure and our turnaround and our
expectation of providing and redacting was much more open and transparent than what
the provincial government operates under. Interestingly enough, it's rules the provincial government forces upon municipalities
to operate that way. I don't have an issue with that. When I say "forces upon," I
say that because the provincial government ultimately sets the rules and the laws
that municipalities operate under. In this case, though, every time this government in particular has a chance to make
their own rules, it's always "rules for thee and not for me." That is where we're
at again with these FOI changes in Bill 9. We have a government that is desperate to hide what they're actually doing, a government
that does not want the public to know who they're meeting with when and about what,
a government that certainly doesn't want to provide any clarity or line of sight as
to what is going on, on the DRIPA file, who they are meeting with, what the timeline is. Again, it's not just DRIPA. This impacts all sorts of other areas. We've heard from
the member from Kelowna and myself, who've met with distillers regularly who have
had many promises and many meetings with the government and timelines broken and not
met. Without the ability of FOI'ing and calendar access and understanding just how serious
the government is or isn't taking a file, it makes having those types of conversations
with people that are being impacted by government rules, regulations and tax policies
very, very difficult to understand what exactly the government is truly doing to move
an issue forward and what issues they're just simply deciding to go through the motions
and not actually ever intend to take meaningful or serious action on for any type
of industry that is critically needed. When you look at the mess that forestry is right now in the complete shambles and
the complete.... Well, it sounded like today that the Premier just gave up. He apparently
doesn't know how to work with Ottawa. He doesn't know how to negotiate with Ottawa.
He doesn't know how to get a benefit for British Columbians out of Ottawa. He essentially
shrugged and said that, well, there's nothing more he can do. He doesn't know what
else he can do to try to get Ottawa's attention on softwood. Well, here's the tip. Maybe the government shouldn't have walked away, letting a maritime
province for a lot of years be the head of the softwood table on behalf of all of
the provinces. Just one little suggestion as a sidebar there. But when you look at the mess that forestry is in, when you look at the concerns that
unions are bringing forward, when you look at the concerns that industry is bringing
forward, I think having more daylight, again, on issues around forestry without having
to go through the hoops of even further-restricted FOI documents would provide better
peace of mind and certainty if the government is truly intending on trying to action
or get results that they keep saying they're trying to do. But the results are not
matching the actions. When we hear in 2021, 2022 that the government is going to create 30,000 jobs in forestry
while they're projecting When we hear, in 2021-2022, that the government is going to create 30,000 jobs in
forestry while they're projecting $1 billion in revenue drop, and now we're at $1.3
billion in revenue drop in that time frame, yearly, and we have 15,000 job losses,
not 30,000 job gains, FOI would be a very helpful tool to have to find more certainty
around what decisions the government was rejecting while they were watching the forest
sector completely implode upon itself. It's not just the FOIs that we rely upon on what decisions were made. It's the FOIs
around what advice was being given or what suggestions were being provided that are
critically important, as well, to get a better sense of where the government actually
is on any given file, how serious they actually are on actually trying to solve the
issues of our time and how performative they're trying to be. If you look at the challenges in health care and the wait times, be it surgical wait
times, be it diagnostic wait times, be it cancer treatment wait times, all of those
types of situations.... Again, when was the minister briefed? How frequently does the
minister get briefed? What action did the minister take from those briefings? Did
the minister even care to pay any attention or enact anything that is being suggested
to try to change the system for the better? All of that gets discovered by freedom
of information. I think it's safe to say, if you're watching me speak right now at home, you probably
watch the odd question period, and you would know none of those questions will ever
get answered in question period. We'll ask. We'll keep doing our job as an opposition,
but let's not be under any illusions that this government routinely takes the question
and then answers on something completely off topic. If I tried doing that on this bill debate around Bill 9, the Chair, rightfully so,
would interrupt me and tell me: "Member, you need to be speaking to the bill." In
question period, it seems that this government, in an effort to hide and distract
away, not only completely avoids the question. They're talking about something completely
unrelated to what was even being asked. That's why we need FOI, because it used to
be you could reasonably get some direction and answers out of a government in question
period, but those days have long since passed. So when I see the provisions in Bill 9, when I see the government's excuses, frankly,
for why they say they need Bill 9, the governments want constantly to try to hide
information, try to make things more difficult, not be willing to get back to media
to answer their legitimate questions that they might have. It's interesting how quickly a minister's office will decide they actually can make
comment if they find out that the opposition has already made comment on a news story.
Well, if they're being that difficult just to get a 15-second sound clip, imagine
how difficult they're being to opposition and other people that are looking for information
when we start asking for information on any given file. A good example would be the speculation of vacancy tax, where the ministry had their
own audit done, and at least that was released, but it didn't have to be. We could
have actually found ourselves in a situation where, again, we're struggling and looking
for that information. Really, I guess at its core.... What's the expression about "fool me once"? You know,
we pushed back hard the last time they brought in FOI changes, and the government
insisted that they were still going to forge through and do them. It simply wasn't
acceptable. It wasn't good enough. They managed to do it. Now we've already seen the Premier back down multiple times on legislation. He's done
it with DRIPA. He's had contorted conditions on all sorts of legislation in this place
over the last couple of years. A bill like this — one would hope the government actually sees the writing on the
wall. They can actually.... They don't seem to care or want to understand why this is
such an offensive piece of legislation. They must think that it is nothing more than
political theatre by the opposition. But I can assure the government members that this is not political theatre on our
part. It's the government that tries to do more performative actions across the board
on a regular basis than actual tangible deliverables for the public. The fact that
their biggest priority with all the major crises facing us The fact that their biggest priority with all the major crises facing us seems to
be Bill 9, an FOI restriction act where it actually makes it much harder for the public,
opposition and media to gain access to government information, government decision-making,
government thought process.... That is their underlying, signature piece of legislation,
it seems, in this session. I mean, we did deal with a weighty miscellaneous stats bill last week, so they had
that going for them, I guess. But that's simply not something that works well. I thank you for the time on this bill, and I look forward to further debate.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Provincial governments
I'll endeavour to have the minister still be looking forward to my questions as we
hit hour 15, but we'll see where that goes. In terms of the overall budget, I have been looking through and searching and searching
and searching, and I'm unable to locate.... I've had many, many property owners and
people in Richmond with great interest asking where exactly the mortgage backing program
the Premier has promised for people in Richmond would be in this budget. Can the minister point to where in this budget the Premier's commitment pre-budget
that mortgages would be backstopped by the provincial government for people in Richmond
based on the Cowichan ruling resides? Can the minister point to where in this budget the Premier's commitment prebudget
that mortgages would be backstopped by the provincial government for people in Richmond
based on the Quw'utsun ruling resides?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Public administration, Public sector
I guess Thursday when I was questioning around contingencies the minister said, in
response to the member's question, that it is true that the negotiations took longer
than expected and that the cost of the mandate did go up. That is captured in the
increase in the contingency fund. The contingency fund last year was projected to
be $4 billion this year. It is now $5 billion moving forward, and last year was projected
to be $4 billion, not just this year but the subsequent year. Can the minister confirm then by her answer that means that the mandate, the negotiations
with the public sector, has been $1 billion more than the government expected?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Public administration, Public sector
Well, I'm no lawyer, but that certainly sounds like the Interpretation Act changes
that the Premier brought in as the Attorney General have made one confusing legal
mess of things in British Columbia. At the beginning, in the Premier's opening statements, he waxed poetically about the
Westminster system and how wonderful it is to be in budget estimates where the public
can hear full scrutiny and disclosure from the government on things of importance
to the public. Yesterday when I was in budget estimates with the Finance Minister, I was actually
heartened by some proactive disclosure at the same time as we were debating Bill 9
in a different chamber, which is FOI legislation which would severely restrict people's
access to information from the government. The minister proactively disclosed a document
to me, the Treasury Board directive she signed off on, on April 30, while I was questioning
around costs of FIFA. Part of the directive she signed off on, on page 5, is 5(b): if the government of
B.C. or a government organization is subject to a purchase agreement in relation to
provincial FIFA World Cup 26 tickets, it will strictly comply with the terms of that
agreement. So the minister signed off on this directive, Treasury Board directive.
It's got her signature on it. She provided it, fully and wholly, over to me. The problem is that then I asked a question in relation to the document she then provided.
I said the minister signed off on these directions. I'm asking what the cost is of
what she agreed to. If she doesn't know what the cost was when she signed off on the
directive that says the government of B.C. is subject to purchase agreement in relation
to tickets and will strictly comply to the terms of that agreement, that sounds like
a blank cheque. So did the minister know I'm asking what the cost is of what she agreed to. If she doesn't know what the cost
was when she signed off on the directive that says the government of B.C. is subject
to purchase agreement in relation to tickets and will strictly comply to the terms
of that agreement, that sounds like a blank cheque. So did the minister know when she signed off on this directive April 30, 2026, which
was not that long ago, what the cost of the suites were going to be? Or did she not
know what the cost of the suites would be, which would fall under "strictly comply with the terms of agreement" around ticket allocations for FIFA World Cup 2026? It has to be one or the other. Either on April 30 the minister knew what the cost
of the suites were going to be and she should be able to provide that figure today,
or she didn't know and she signed off on a directive that creates a blank cheque for
obligations under FIFA that the government was unaware of on April 30, 2026. To which the minister shockingly replied — again, proactive disclosure: "I suggest
to the member there is a third option, which is that the minister does know and is
deferring to the Ministry of Tourism, Arts, and Culture to give their update, which they plan to do in the coming days." Which to the outside
world might sound like a reasonable answer. In fact, I believe Madam Chair was in the chair when I asked her whether or not ministers
are expected to answer questions that they've actually fully acknowledged they have
the answer to in the middle of budget estimates which, based on her signed directive,
she is directly responsible for. But the minister refused. So I would like to give the Premier the opportunity, as the head of government, to
answer that question which, obviously, government does have the answer to. It may
be in government's convenience to release it as a package with the minister after
this House rises, conveniently not before the Premier's estimates. But his own minister.... By all accounts, everyone agrees in most.... You have the Attorney General and you have
the Finance Minister. Those are kind of the two big heads of ministerial roles. She has acknowledged she signed a directive on April 30 of this year to make sure
you fully participate in all ticket packages required by FIFA. It was a direct question
around what the cost of the suite package is. Not how they were being allocated, not
who was going into the suites — the cost. And she replied she has the answer but refused
to give the answer. That is not acceptable. I hope the Premier would think that's
not acceptable, as well, for the public. So what is the actual cost of the suite package for these seven games that this government
has agreed to under the provisions of the FIFA contract and the Treasury Board directive
signed by his own Finance Minister on April 30?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Mortgage assistance, Mortgage loans
I'll endeavour to have the minister still be looking forward to my questions as we
hit hour 15, but we'll see where that goes. In terms of the overall budget, I have been looking through and searching and searching
and searching, and I'm unable to locate.... I've had many, many property owners and
people in Richmond with great interest asking where exactly the mortgage backing program
the Premier has promised for people in Richmond would be in this budget. Can the minister point to where in this budget the Premier's commitment pre-budget
that mortgages would be backstopped by the provincial government for people in Richmond
based on the Cowichan ruling resides? Can the minister point to where in this budget the Premier's commitment prebudget
that mortgages would be backstopped by the provincial government for people in Richmond
based on the Quw'utsun ruling resides?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Indigenous affairs
Happy to take my place in this debate on Bill 20. It's troubling, watching how events have unfolded over the last little while with
this government and how badly they have now handled even the treaty process. I say
that because we know that treaties do bring stability into regions where treaties
have been in place. We see that in other parts of the province where longer-standing treaties have been in place. But only this government could manage to mess up a system that has taken 30 years
to get us here, and yet they have still managed to completely bungle it when it comes
to talking and trying to better understand and have a treaty that can be better supported
by surrounding nations. I say that because this is a government that repeatedly over
the last little while — when we're talking about repealing DRIPA; when we're talking about the need to repeal DRIPA — insists that they are going
to do it by having conversations and talking and not just taking those types of steps. Yet here we have a treaty where other nations have very clearly said that not only
are they not being listened to, they're not being talked to by this government. It
seems very opposite of everything that this government has been trying to say to us. And so again, when they want to try to wag the finger and lecture us about proper
process and respectful conversations and moving documents forward and getting agreements,
that has not happened in this case. It is very clear by virtue of the hoist motion
we attempted as an amendment previous to this That has not happened in this case. It is very clear, by virtue of the hoist motion
we attempted as an amendment previous to this, that we are sincere about putting the
brakes on this so that further dialogue and discussions can actually happen. That's
what we are hearing from many in association with this particular treaty. There is
no harm in doing that. The government wants to walk the walk? Then they can do that. They can actually say
that they are true and sincere in their attempts. But unfortunately, political theatre
is what this government seems intent on. Political theatre around DRIPA — whether
it's going to be amendments, a three-year pause, a one-year pause, a pause until the
fall with amendments, or maybe it's a repeal.... "We're not really sure, because we're going to do the right thing, and we're going
to have those conversations. Yet we're going to rush through." I say "rush" in the
context of a 30-year document. I understand how that can sound a little bit contradictory. But a document 30 years in the making that this government has been responsible for,
for the last nine years of that 30 years, a third of this time.... And they've managed
to deliver a document that is rife with controversy and rife with lack of consultation,
lack of understanding of agreement of neighbouring nations with the treaty nation
that would be the beneficiary of this treaty. So I can't in good faith move forward with the document, knowing that that is the
backdrop on this. It's not about the fundamental principle of a treaty. It's about
just how badly this government yet again — time and again; it seems it doesn't matter
what topic we're talking about — sets a whole new bar for incompetence. And yet again,
they have done it on this. So I'm hard-pressed. I would welcome the government to point to any other treaties
that took 30 years to get negotiated, wound up in front of this chamber, started to
be debated and then had multiple, multiple groups saying: "Put the brakes on it. This
hasn't been done properly." But only this government, in their incompetence, could
manage to pull that off. Again, after nine years.... Nine long years of the last 30 years has been directly at
the hands of this government negotiating this treaty. So they can't talk and point
the finger back to the start. They can't even point the finger back, although that
30 years, I guess, they would have been in government even at the start of this or
close to it. They can't point the finger back there, nor can they even point it to
the midpoint. The reality is if they can't deliver a document in a nine-year period that was already
well underway, 21 years underway, with some certainty and some confidence and some
buy-in by the other nations, how does anyone have any faith that they could negotiate something between now and the
fall in regards to DRIPA? This is the insanity that is watching this unfold in front
of us with this government in terms of how they are handling the Indigenous file in
general. Every time they touch something it gets worse. Every single time. And this treaty
is just another example of that. I feel for the K'ómoks. They were understandably very excited around this, wanting
to see closure and a moving forward. But they ought to have known, or probably were
figuring out over the last nine years, that the government wasn't dealing with a full
deck. We need to make sure that this actually has had the proper oversight, overview, which
was the premise of the six-month hoist. It was not to try to kill the treaty completely;
it was about trying to give that breathing space as the minister has indicated, the
Attorney General has indicated, is much critically needed for DRIPA — the same time
frame as what our hoist motion was. And that suddenly was unacceptable to this government,
but on DRIPA, it's totally acceptable. Again, totally contradictory language — totally contradictory actions, more importantly.
It leads to uncertainty, not just within the project world and communities. It's leading
to a lot of uncertainty within Indigenous nations as to just what this government
actually truly believes in terms of working with Indigenous nations in good faith.
Is it that they only work in good faith with the ones that they deem to be acceptable
in working with them, or will they work truly with all 204 First Nations? So I can't find myself in a position of not being able to support this treaty. I truly
feel that I'm fortunate that the government decided to try to ram it through and not
support the hoist motion. They will have to deal with the consequences of yet another
mishandled file on their part of utter incompetence when it comes to dealing with
issues around Indigenous relations. Thank you for the time. Thank you for the time.Open source reference