5 recorded contributions · Small sample
Jev-reviewed existing detailed tags · editorial review required
Accepted detailed tags: Marriage
It is always a pleasure and an honour to introduce a former MLA to visit this House.
I would like for the House to welcome Peter Fassbender, a former minister and MLA,
and his wife Charlene. My understanding is that they've been married for 58 years
today. I do not know whether that puts Charlene in the running for the Order of British
Columbia, but it has got to put her for an honourable mention at least. Would the House please give them a very warm welcome.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Agri-food products, Agricultural workers, Fruits
Today I rise to talk about one of Abbotsford South's finest exports, one of British Columbia's great agricultural treasures and one
of the most versatile foods you can find. I'm talking, of course, about blueberries.
Now blueberries may seem small, but they're mighty. You can put them in pancakes,
muffins, smoothies, pies, jams, salads, sauces, yogurts, oatmeal, ice cream or simply
eat them by the handful while pretending you're only going to have one. Abbotsford blueberries are not just a snack; they are what and part of who we are.
Our community is known as the Berry Capital of Canada, and that title was built on
generations of hardworking families. These growers are up early, working long days,
managing weather, labour challenges, rising costs and marketing pressures, all to
produce a crop that is enjoyed here at home and around the world. British Columbia is known for its highbush blueberries, and depending on the season,
you may find varieties such as Duke, Blue Crop, Draper, Liberty, Elliott, Aurora and
Calypso. Each has its own flavour, timing and purpose, from sweet fresh eating to
baking, freezing and processing. They are also good for you. Blueberries are high in fibre, rich in antioxidants and
linked to benefits for heart health, brain health and overall wellness. In other words,
this may be one of the rare times where you can taste something that tastes fantastic
and is actually good for you. In Abbotsford South, blueberry farms support local jobs, suppliers, processors, markets,
tourism and roadside stands. They also bring people together through events like Berry
Fest where our community celebrates the farmers, families and flavours that make Abbotsford
so special. All the good news is that the blueberry season is just around the corner. Fresh B.C.
blueberries are usually at their best in the summertime months, especially in July
and August. This year, farmers are expecting a bunker crop, so I encourage everyone
to come on out to Abbotsford, bring the family to a U-pick, stop at a roadside stand,
fill a bucket, fill your freezer and support our local farmers right here at the source.
Small berry, big impact, very Abbotsford.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Students
Sometimes as we march these hallways, we get to meet some very interesting people.
I would like to draw attention up in the gallery. We have some students from Western
Washington University. They're poli-sci students. I know they're heartbroken that I won't ask a question today, but I promised them
our very best when it comes to heckling, etc., so that they get a good chance of experiencing
a true question period. Will this House please make them very, very welcome — our guests from Washington state?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Farms
Today I rise to talk about one of Abbotsford South's finest exports, one of British Columbia's great agricultural treasures and one
of the most versatile foods you can find. I'm talking, of course, about blueberries.
Now blueberries may seem small, but they're mighty. You can put them in pancakes,
muffins, smoothies, pies, jams, salads, sauces, yogurts, oatmeal, ice cream or simply
eat them by the handful while pretending you're only going to have one. Abbotsford blueberries are not just a snack; they are what and part of who we are.
Our community is known as the Berry Capital of Canada, and that title was built on
generations of hardworking families. These growers are up early, working long days,
managing weather, labour challenges, rising costs and marketing pressures, all to
produce a crop that is enjoyed here at home and around the world. British Columbia is known for its highbush blueberries, and depending on the season,
you may find varieties such as Duke, Blue Crop, Draper, Liberty, Elliott, Aurora and
Calypso. Each has its own flavour, timing and purpose, from sweet fresh eating to
baking, freezing and processing. They are also good for you. Blueberries are high in fibre, rich in antioxidants and
linked to benefits for heart health, brain health and overall wellness. In other words,
this may be one of the rare times where you can taste something that tastes fantastic
and is actually good for you. In Abbotsford South, blueberry farms support local jobs, suppliers, processors, markets,
tourism and roadside stands. They also bring people together through events like Berry
Fest where our community celebrates the farmers, families and flavours that make Abbotsford
so special. All the good news is that the blueberry season is just around the corner. Fresh B.C.
blueberries are usually at their best in the summertime months, especially in July
and August. This year, farmers are expecting a bunker crop, so I encourage everyone
to come on out to Abbotsford, bring the family to a U-pick, stop at a roadside stand,
fill a bucket, fill your freezer and support our local farmers right here at the source.
Small berry, big impact, very Abbotsford.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Public access, Public administration
It is actually an honour and a privilege to stand here as the designated speaker for
this motion. I believe this is the first time I've been a designated speaker to respond
to a motion, so I look forward to that, and I believe that I have up to two hours
upon which to make some points. I'd like to start by explaining the motion in plain
language. I rise to speak to the amendment for the motion for the second reading of Bill 9.
The amendment, which I have in front of me, says: "delete the word 'now' and substitute
the words 'six months hence.'" For those that are watching at home or are unfamiliar, or watching late tonight and
perhaps have insomnia, a hoist motion, as this is called, is one of the oldest tools
in parliamentary tradition. I would explain to people that a hoist motion is not a
motion to actually kill a bill. That's not its purpose. A hoist motion is a chance....
Whenever there is legislation that comes on the floor that there have been problems
with — as an example, in this case — a hoist motion is a motion to pause it, to send
it back and get it right. Already there have been, which I will get into in a few moments, a number of changes
by the minister herself where they've realized: "Oops. In our rush to get it here,
there have been a couple of errors already." A hoist motion is now, in this case, going to give us six months, which is the bare
minimum. We could have asked for longer, but FOIs are so important and getting freedom-of-information
requests right is so important that this side of the House wants to make sure that.... The minimum amount of time allowed in a hoist to get it right is six months. What
that will do is allow them, over the summertime, as an example, to be able to ponder
this particular motion, look at it carefully, sort out the errors that are in it and
actually get it right. Now, I think that this Legislature owes this to the people we serve. Now, I was the
critic for Citizens' Services. It was actually my first critic role when elected back
in 2020. And FOIs were one of the things that were hotly debated then. I think it's important for the public to understand what's at stake here. Freedom
of information is a request that people put into their government, and it allows them
to get access to the decisions either that were made or how that decision Freedom of information is a request that people put in, to their government, and it
allows them to get access to the decisions, either that were made, or how that decision
came to be, or what's important when it comes to finding out how government has been
acting. It is that safety net that has been put in there to ensure that government
is acting responsibly. It is that ability to make sure that government is not using
funds in an inappropriate way. My interim leader just spoke of a few embarrassing things that were brought up from
an FOI. Government's natural tendency is to say, "No, no, we really don't want to
have anything embarrassing." Sometimes it's an innocent enough thing that has happened,
but it's embarrassing nonetheless. Now, I spoke in this House about a very embarrassing incident that happened to me
personally, when I was the mayor of Abbotsford, and that side of the House has used
that example many times, to use it as an example, to try and embarrass me. Well, I'm
not embarrassed by it, because an FOI actually, in this case, exonerated me. Yeah, if you've done something inappropriate, it may not always exonerate you. I am
sure the Minister of Finance absolutely hates hearing about her $6,000 limo ride —
which, she has pointed out, was actually an SUV, but it was a $6,000 bill nonetheless.
In my case, what had happened was that chicken manure had been used to deter a homeless
encampment from coming back. It was FOI'd to death, because there's nothing more juicy than that one. The press
and people in the public wanted to make sure that I was the mayor. So they were convinced
that I had ordered that to be done, that I knew about it and that I didn't put a stop
to it. Nothing could be further from the truth. My cell phone was taken, my computer
was taken, and every shred of paper that they could get their hands on there was taken,
because it made international news. An FOI actually is a double-edged sword. While people were looking to literally tar
and paper me with this — not feather — they found out, at the end of the day, that
I actually did not know about it. Upon further FOI requests, they found out that there
was actually a bunch of intermediate staffers that had gotten together and come up
with this horrific idea to do, and spread chicken manure on a homeless encampment
after it had been cleaned up, because they were frustrated with the cat-and-mouse
game. It was a bad idea. I wore it because I was the mayor. I took responsibility for it
because I was the mayor. In fact then what I did, to ensure that that would never
happen again.... I implemented a committee to deal with the issues of homelessness in
Abbotsford, so that it would never, ever, ever happen again. My point on this is that an FOI, while embarrassing, actually can prove that government
did no wrongdoing. It's not always going to embarrass government. It is a healthy
tool that has been put in place to ensure that the press, the public and the opposition
can request an FOI, a freedom-of-information document, get it in a timely manner and
hold government accountable. It is, I believe, one of the foundations of democracy. Now, with regard to this hoist motion that is before this House at this moment, this
debate currently is not about whether the FOI system needs reform. Now, with regards to this hoist motion that is before this House at this moment, this
debate currently is not about whether the FOI system needs reform. Well, it does.
Everybody agrees. On both sides of the House. That's in fact why this bill is here
and why this amendment is here now. We know that the FOI system is broken. It does
not serve the public as well as it could, and it needs to be addressed. It's not about whether the public bodies are facing pressure. Well, clearly, they
do. Public bodies are under enormous pressure. And FOIs, quite frankly, when I was
the mayor of Abbotsford, were an absolute pain to deal with. It gobbles up staff time.
They have to find out where the information is. They have to photocopy it. They have
to retract certain things and certain names on it. It does take up time. You know what else takes up time? An absolute pain in some people's minds that cities
have to deal with is building inspections. They're there for a good reason. We want
to make sure they're safe. We want to make sure that the buildings are done correctly. So the reason that the Information and Privacy Commissioner agrees that reform is
needed The BCFIPA agrees, and the 2022 all-party committee agreed unanimously. There
was already a committee that dealt with the bill that is in front of this House, and
it came up with recommendations. So the debate is not whether or not we need to reform
FOIs. That is clear, and that is why this bill is here. The secret now is we must
ensure that we get it right. We owe it to the public to get it right. We owe it to
democracy itself, in fact, to get this right. So what this debate is really about, and why we have put this hoist here is to answer
the question: does this bill weaken the public's right to know, or does it strengthen
the systems that deliver on that vital democratic right? On that question, the evidence
is overwhelming. Bill 9 is the wrong answer. There have been mistakes that have been
pointed out already. And that is why we are asking for a very legitimate pause to
be able to strengthen it. And six months, the minimum time, because this is of the essence, is the time this
Legislature needs to find the right solutions to this bill. It is a reasonable request,
and I believe a very much required request, especially when one considers that in
the democratic process, checks and balances are required. Government without checks and balances is not a healthy thing at all. That is why
we are called His Royal Majesty's opposition. We're not here to stop government. We
are here to oppose bad legislation and suggest ways to which and improve it, to keep
government accountable and to actually come up with better legislation than what's
been placed. This hoist will allow us that time to do this. Now, part of why we have done this is because the minister herself made the case for
the hoist. Let me go over a few reasons as to why. So the first thing is, the minister
actually amended her own bill in mid-debate. The minister.... That is worth repeating.
The minister amended her own bill in mid-debate. The Minister of Citizens Services
tabled amendments to her own legislation two weeks into the second reading. That clearly
states that there was problems within the bill already. I didn't say amendment, I said amendments. Do you need me to pause Do you need me to pause for a minute, Mr. Speaker? All right, fair enough. In her words, they were minor adjustments to provide additional clarity. Well, I think
that this hoist will help, in fact, to define what those minor adjustments and what
additional clarity will mean. I would say part of the reason why the minister has made the argument or the case
for this hoist is.... If a bill is ready for this House, if it is clearly ready, if
it has been well-thought-out, one does not need to amend a bill that is ready. The
bill was not ready. The bill had errors and flaws in it when it was presented on this
floor. You do not need to provide additional clarity on legislation that was clear
when you tabled it. The minister realized that there were problems in the bill. She said: "We need to
make some minor adjustments. It's not clear. We've made a mistake already." That is
one area, so the act of tabling those amendments is itself an admission the bill just
was not ready for debate. That's okay. It's okay that the bill was not ready, because this system has in its
place this exact motion, a hoist, to be able to go: "You know what? Hang on a minute.
We've messed up. Let's think about this in a better term. Let's allow a wholesome
debate on this. Let's send it to a committee to figure out what else may be wrong
with this bill and go at it so that we can come back with a bill that is before this
House that is ready."Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Homelessness
It is actually an honour and a privilege to stand here as the designated speaker for
this motion. I believe this is the first time I've been a designated speaker to respond
to a motion, so I look forward to that, and I believe that I have up to two hours
upon which to make some points. I'd like to start by explaining the motion in plain
language. I rise to speak to the amendment for the motion for the second reading of Bill 9.
The amendment, which I have in front of me, says: "delete the word 'now' and substitute
the words 'six months hence.'" For those that are watching at home or are unfamiliar, or watching late tonight and
perhaps have insomnia, a hoist motion, as this is called, is one of the oldest tools
in parliamentary tradition. I would explain to people that a hoist motion is not a
motion to actually kill a bill. That's not its purpose. A hoist motion is a chance....
Whenever there is legislation that comes on the floor that there have been problems
with — as an example, in this case — a hoist motion is a motion to pause it, to send
it back and get it right. Already there have been, which I will get into in a few moments, a number of changes
by the minister herself where they've realized: "Oops. In our rush to get it here,
there have been a couple of errors already." A hoist motion is now, in this case, going to give us six months, which is the bare
minimum. We could have asked for longer, but FOIs are so important and getting freedom-of-information
requests right is so important that this side of the House wants to make sure that.... The minimum amount of time allowed in a hoist to get it right is six months. What
that will do is allow them, over the summertime, as an example, to be able to ponder
this particular motion, look at it carefully, sort out the errors that are in it and
actually get it right. Now, I think that this Legislature owes this to the people we serve. Now, I was the
critic for Citizens' Services. It was actually my first critic role when elected back
in 2020. And FOIs were one of the things that were hotly debated then. I think it's important for the public to understand what's at stake here. Freedom
of information is a request that people put into their government, and it allows them
to get access to the decisions either that were made or how that decision Freedom of information is a request that people put in, to their government, and it
allows them to get access to the decisions, either that were made, or how that decision
came to be, or what's important when it comes to finding out how government has been
acting. It is that safety net that has been put in there to ensure that government
is acting responsibly. It is that ability to make sure that government is not using
funds in an inappropriate way. My interim leader just spoke of a few embarrassing things that were brought up from
an FOI. Government's natural tendency is to say, "No, no, we really don't want to
have anything embarrassing." Sometimes it's an innocent enough thing that has happened,
but it's embarrassing nonetheless. Now, I spoke in this House about a very embarrassing incident that happened to me
personally, when I was the mayor of Abbotsford, and that side of the House has used
that example many times, to use it as an example, to try and embarrass me. Well, I'm
not embarrassed by it, because an FOI actually, in this case, exonerated me. Yeah, if you've done something inappropriate, it may not always exonerate you. I am
sure the Minister of Finance absolutely hates hearing about her $6,000 limo ride —
which, she has pointed out, was actually an SUV, but it was a $6,000 bill nonetheless.
In my case, what had happened was that chicken manure had been used to deter a homeless
encampment from coming back. It was FOI'd to death, because there's nothing more juicy than that one. The press
and people in the public wanted to make sure that I was the mayor. So they were convinced
that I had ordered that to be done, that I knew about it and that I didn't put a stop
to it. Nothing could be further from the truth. My cell phone was taken, my computer
was taken, and every shred of paper that they could get their hands on there was taken,
because it made international news. An FOI actually is a double-edged sword. While people were looking to literally tar
and paper me with this — not feather — they found out, at the end of the day, that
I actually did not know about it. Upon further FOI requests, they found out that there
was actually a bunch of intermediate staffers that had gotten together and come up
with this horrific idea to do, and spread chicken manure on a homeless encampment
after it had been cleaned up, because they were frustrated with the cat-and-mouse
game. It was a bad idea. I wore it because I was the mayor. I took responsibility for it
because I was the mayor. In fact then what I did, to ensure that that would never
happen again.... I implemented a committee to deal with the issues of homelessness in
Abbotsford, so that it would never, ever, ever happen again. My point on this is that an FOI, while embarrassing, actually can prove that government
did no wrongdoing. It's not always going to embarrass government. It is a healthy
tool that has been put in place to ensure that the press, the public and the opposition
can request an FOI, a freedom-of-information document, get it in a timely manner and
hold government accountable. It is, I believe, one of the foundations of democracy. Now, with regard to this hoist motion that is before this House at this moment, this
debate currently is not about whether the FOI system needs reform. Now, with regards to this hoist motion that is before this House at this moment, this
debate currently is not about whether the FOI system needs reform. Well, it does.
Everybody agrees. On both sides of the House. That's in fact why this bill is here
and why this amendment is here now. We know that the FOI system is broken. It does
not serve the public as well as it could, and it needs to be addressed. It's not about whether the public bodies are facing pressure. Well, clearly, they
do. Public bodies are under enormous pressure. And FOIs, quite frankly, when I was
the mayor of Abbotsford, were an absolute pain to deal with. It gobbles up staff time.
They have to find out where the information is. They have to photocopy it. They have
to retract certain things and certain names on it. It does take up time. You know what else takes up time? An absolute pain in some people's minds that cities
have to deal with is building inspections. They're there for a good reason. We want
to make sure they're safe. We want to make sure that the buildings are done correctly. So the reason that the Information and Privacy Commissioner agrees that reform is
needed The BCFIPA agrees, and the 2022 all-party committee agreed unanimously. There
was already a committee that dealt with the bill that is in front of this House, and
it came up with recommendations. So the debate is not whether or not we need to reform
FOIs. That is clear, and that is why this bill is here. The secret now is we must
ensure that we get it right. We owe it to the public to get it right. We owe it to
democracy itself, in fact, to get this right. So what this debate is really about, and why we have put this hoist here is to answer
the question: does this bill weaken the public's right to know, or does it strengthen
the systems that deliver on that vital democratic right? On that question, the evidence
is overwhelming. Bill 9 is the wrong answer. There have been mistakes that have been
pointed out already. And that is why we are asking for a very legitimate pause to
be able to strengthen it. And six months, the minimum time, because this is of the essence, is the time this
Legislature needs to find the right solutions to this bill. It is a reasonable request,
and I believe a very much required request, especially when one considers that in
the democratic process, checks and balances are required. Government without checks and balances is not a healthy thing at all. That is why
we are called His Royal Majesty's opposition. We're not here to stop government. We
are here to oppose bad legislation and suggest ways to which and improve it, to keep
government accountable and to actually come up with better legislation than what's
been placed. This hoist will allow us that time to do this. Now, part of why we have done this is because the minister herself made the case for
the hoist. Let me go over a few reasons as to why. So the first thing is, the minister
actually amended her own bill in mid-debate. The minister.... That is worth repeating.
The minister amended her own bill in mid-debate. The Minister of Citizens Services
tabled amendments to her own legislation two weeks into the second reading. That clearly
states that there was problems within the bill already. I didn't say amendment, I said amendments. Do you need me to pause Do you need me to pause for a minute, Mr. Speaker? All right, fair enough. In her words, they were minor adjustments to provide additional clarity. Well, I think
that this hoist will help, in fact, to define what those minor adjustments and what
additional clarity will mean. I would say part of the reason why the minister has made the argument or the case
for this hoist is.... If a bill is ready for this House, if it is clearly ready, if
it has been well-thought-out, one does not need to amend a bill that is ready. The
bill was not ready. The bill had errors and flaws in it when it was presented on this
floor. You do not need to provide additional clarity on legislation that was clear
when you tabled it. The minister realized that there were problems in the bill. She said: "We need to
make some minor adjustments. It's not clear. We've made a mistake already." That is
one area, so the act of tabling those amendments is itself an admission the bill just
was not ready for debate. That's okay. It's okay that the bill was not ready, because this system has in its
place this exact motion, a hoist, to be able to go: "You know what? Hang on a minute.
We've messed up. Let's think about this in a better term. Let's allow a wholesome
debate on this. Let's send it to a committee to figure out what else may be wrong
with this bill and go at it so that we can come back with a bill that is before this
House that is ready."Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Information, Information dissemination
It is actually an honour and a privilege to stand here as the designated speaker for
this motion. I believe this is the first time I've been a designated speaker to respond
to a motion, so I look forward to that, and I believe that I have up to two hours
upon which to make some points. I'd like to start by explaining the motion in plain
language. I rise to speak to the amendment for the motion for the second reading of Bill 9.
The amendment, which I have in front of me, says: "delete the word 'now' and substitute
the words 'six months hence.'" For those that are watching at home or are unfamiliar, or watching late tonight and
perhaps have insomnia, a hoist motion, as this is called, is one of the oldest tools
in parliamentary tradition. I would explain to people that a hoist motion is not a
motion to actually kill a bill. That's not its purpose. A hoist motion is a chance....
Whenever there is legislation that comes on the floor that there have been problems
with — as an example, in this case — a hoist motion is a motion to pause it, to send
it back and get it right. Already there have been, which I will get into in a few moments, a number of changes
by the minister herself where they've realized: "Oops. In our rush to get it here,
there have been a couple of errors already." A hoist motion is now, in this case, going to give us six months, which is the bare
minimum. We could have asked for longer, but FOIs are so important and getting freedom-of-information
requests right is so important that this side of the House wants to make sure that.... The minimum amount of time allowed in a hoist to get it right is six months. What
that will do is allow them, over the summertime, as an example, to be able to ponder
this particular motion, look at it carefully, sort out the errors that are in it and
actually get it right. Now, I think that this Legislature owes this to the people we serve. Now, I was the
critic for Citizens' Services. It was actually my first critic role when elected back
in 2020. And FOIs were one of the things that were hotly debated then. I think it's important for the public to understand what's at stake here. Freedom
of information is a request that people put into their government, and it allows them
to get access to the decisions either that were made or how that decision Freedom of information is a request that people put in, to their government, and it
allows them to get access to the decisions, either that were made, or how that decision
came to be, or what's important when it comes to finding out how government has been
acting. It is that safety net that has been put in there to ensure that government
is acting responsibly. It is that ability to make sure that government is not using
funds in an inappropriate way. My interim leader just spoke of a few embarrassing things that were brought up from
an FOI. Government's natural tendency is to say, "No, no, we really don't want to
have anything embarrassing." Sometimes it's an innocent enough thing that has happened,
but it's embarrassing nonetheless. Now, I spoke in this House about a very embarrassing incident that happened to me
personally, when I was the mayor of Abbotsford, and that side of the House has used
that example many times, to use it as an example, to try and embarrass me. Well, I'm
not embarrassed by it, because an FOI actually, in this case, exonerated me. Yeah, if you've done something inappropriate, it may not always exonerate you. I am
sure the Minister of Finance absolutely hates hearing about her $6,000 limo ride —
which, she has pointed out, was actually an SUV, but it was a $6,000 bill nonetheless.
In my case, what had happened was that chicken manure had been used to deter a homeless
encampment from coming back. It was FOI'd to death, because there's nothing more juicy than that one. The press
and people in the public wanted to make sure that I was the mayor. So they were convinced
that I had ordered that to be done, that I knew about it and that I didn't put a stop
to it. Nothing could be further from the truth. My cell phone was taken, my computer
was taken, and every shred of paper that they could get their hands on there was taken,
because it made international news. An FOI actually is a double-edged sword. While people were looking to literally tar
and paper me with this — not feather — they found out, at the end of the day, that
I actually did not know about it. Upon further FOI requests, they found out that there
was actually a bunch of intermediate staffers that had gotten together and come up
with this horrific idea to do, and spread chicken manure on a homeless encampment
after it had been cleaned up, because they were frustrated with the cat-and-mouse
game. It was a bad idea. I wore it because I was the mayor. I took responsibility for it
because I was the mayor. In fact then what I did, to ensure that that would never
happen again.... I implemented a committee to deal with the issues of homelessness in
Abbotsford, so that it would never, ever, ever happen again. My point on this is that an FOI, while embarrassing, actually can prove that government
did no wrongdoing. It's not always going to embarrass government. It is a healthy
tool that has been put in place to ensure that the press, the public and the opposition
can request an FOI, a freedom-of-information document, get it in a timely manner and
hold government accountable. It is, I believe, one of the foundations of democracy. Now, with regard to this hoist motion that is before this House at this moment, this
debate currently is not about whether the FOI system needs reform. Now, with regards to this hoist motion that is before this House at this moment, this
debate currently is not about whether the FOI system needs reform. Well, it does.
Everybody agrees. On both sides of the House. That's in fact why this bill is here
and why this amendment is here now. We know that the FOI system is broken. It does
not serve the public as well as it could, and it needs to be addressed. It's not about whether the public bodies are facing pressure. Well, clearly, they
do. Public bodies are under enormous pressure. And FOIs, quite frankly, when I was
the mayor of Abbotsford, were an absolute pain to deal with. It gobbles up staff time.
They have to find out where the information is. They have to photocopy it. They have
to retract certain things and certain names on it. It does take up time. You know what else takes up time? An absolute pain in some people's minds that cities
have to deal with is building inspections. They're there for a good reason. We want
to make sure they're safe. We want to make sure that the buildings are done correctly. So the reason that the Information and Privacy Commissioner agrees that reform is
needed The BCFIPA agrees, and the 2022 all-party committee agreed unanimously. There
was already a committee that dealt with the bill that is in front of this House, and
it came up with recommendations. So the debate is not whether or not we need to reform
FOIs. That is clear, and that is why this bill is here. The secret now is we must
ensure that we get it right. We owe it to the public to get it right. We owe it to
democracy itself, in fact, to get this right. So what this debate is really about, and why we have put this hoist here is to answer
the question: does this bill weaken the public's right to know, or does it strengthen
the systems that deliver on that vital democratic right? On that question, the evidence
is overwhelming. Bill 9 is the wrong answer. There have been mistakes that have been
pointed out already. And that is why we are asking for a very legitimate pause to
be able to strengthen it. And six months, the minimum time, because this is of the essence, is the time this
Legislature needs to find the right solutions to this bill. It is a reasonable request,
and I believe a very much required request, especially when one considers that in
the democratic process, checks and balances are required. Government without checks and balances is not a healthy thing at all. That is why
we are called His Royal Majesty's opposition. We're not here to stop government. We
are here to oppose bad legislation and suggest ways to which and improve it, to keep
government accountable and to actually come up with better legislation than what's
been placed. This hoist will allow us that time to do this. Now, part of why we have done this is because the minister herself made the case for
the hoist. Let me go over a few reasons as to why. So the first thing is, the minister
actually amended her own bill in mid-debate. The minister.... That is worth repeating.
The minister amended her own bill in mid-debate. The Minister of Citizens Services
tabled amendments to her own legislation two weeks into the second reading. That clearly
states that there was problems within the bill already. I didn't say amendment, I said amendments. Do you need me to pause Do you need me to pause for a minute, Mr. Speaker? All right, fair enough. In her words, they were minor adjustments to provide additional clarity. Well, I think
that this hoist will help, in fact, to define what those minor adjustments and what
additional clarity will mean. I would say part of the reason why the minister has made the argument or the case
for this hoist is.... If a bill is ready for this House, if it is clearly ready, if
it has been well-thought-out, one does not need to amend a bill that is ready. The
bill was not ready. The bill had errors and flaws in it when it was presented on this
floor. You do not need to provide additional clarity on legislation that was clear
when you tabled it. The minister realized that there were problems in the bill. She said: "We need to
make some minor adjustments. It's not clear. We've made a mistake already." That is
one area, so the act of tabling those amendments is itself an admission the bill just
was not ready for debate. That's okay. It's okay that the bill was not ready, because this system has in its
place this exact motion, a hoist, to be able to go: "You know what? Hang on a minute.
We've messed up. Let's think about this in a better term. Let's allow a wholesome
debate on this. Let's send it to a committee to figure out what else may be wrong
with this bill and go at it so that we can come back with a bill that is before this
House that is ready."Open source reference