6 recorded contributions · Small sample
Jev-reviewed existing detailed tags · editorial review required
Accepted detailed tags: Businesses, Economic issues, Economic regulations, Public finance, Small businesses, Taxes
My office has been inundated with letters from business owners and constituents who
are struggling to make ends meet. Rising costs are forcing businesses to put plans
for new hiring and expansion on hold, as spending habits change and sales decline. As financial pressures rise, this government is adding insult to injury by choosing
to add PST onto services that businesses are legally required to use. One constituent
said: "It seems like this government is punishing small businesses for hiring accountants."
At a time when our economy is struggling, businesses and consumers need some good
news, and they need a helping hand. My question is to the Premier. Will he do the right thing and pause his plan to expand
the PST on October 1?Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Fundraising
I want to join with the member for Richmond-Queensborough in welcoming Stalinjeet and Navpreet Gill and their son Gurmoh and his little sister,
who is five years old, to this Legislature. As my colleague mentioned, they walked from Canada Place in Vancouver all the way
here this morning to the B.C. Legislature. I had the opportunity to join them on the
last leg of that journey from the Gurdwara Singh Sabha Sahib. It was a really meaningful
walk. Not only are they raising funds for their son who needs treatment of his rare
genetic disorder, but also they have identified other gaps for families who are experiencing
the same thing dealing with rare diseases. I thank them so much for their advocacy. I thank them for their strength, for the
courage they're showing. I encourage all British Columbians to help out if they can. Would the House please join me in making them most welcome.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Modernization, Privacy
Good morning, Madam Speaker. Thanks to my colleagues. I rise this early morning to speak to the hoist motion, which I do not support. I want to be clear. I won't be getting into the various amendments, or I won't be
getting into the different parts of the bill. But I would like to explain to my constituents,
perhaps, that might.... I don't probably think there are too many Elenore Sturko : I want to be clear. I won't be getting into the various amendments, or I won't be
getting into the different parts of the bill, but I would like to explain to my constituents,
perhaps, that might.... I don't, probably, think there are too many watching right now, but those who would
perhaps watch this through Hansard, maybe tomorrow or in the coming days.... I've done
my due diligence on this bill. I spoke with members of the government. I listened
to briefings, and I even went so far as to reach out to the independent office of
the Privacy Commissioner so that I myself could know a little bit more about how this
would work if one of my constituents, for example, which I'm sure they do on a regular
basis, would submit a freedom-of-information request or access to private information
from their own records or even from the record of somebody else. I think one of the things that's been missing from this debate and why I don't support
this motion is that in all cases where a request under FOIPPA would be denied, that
would go to the Privacy Commissioner, who is the head of an independent office here
in British Columbia. The decisions made by that independent officer are made using
case law from previous instances where requests have been denied, and it's also based
on just other jurisprudence from instances that this office, which is a very experienced
office, has dealt with. You'll have to pardon me for being a little bit tired, Madam Speaker. How it works is.... If someone puts in a request for information from a government body
or from the government and that request is denied, any British Columbian can actually
complain about that and can complain to the Privacy Commissioner and have that looked
at again and have the explanation as to why that request has been denied. They can also.... Or they should take heart in knowing that even with these new definitions,
that doesn't change. This legislation doesn't take away. This is something that I
actually really wanted to make sure that I would find out on behalf of my constituents
and other British Columbians before I would see this bill go to committee, which.... I do want it to go to committee, and I'm not ashamed of that, because I think that,
while not a perfect bill, there's room for amendment here and that there's also room
to ask important questions during the committee stage and have them answered, which
is something that we don't get to do even in second reading, as you know. When I wanted to find out more about this process.... What would happen if, for example,
someone put in a vexatious request or they were considered to be malicious? Even with
the new changes in the legislation, that decision is not made by a person, a head
of a government agency alone, because every request that would be not fulfilled by
government or by the governing body has to be approved by the independent Privacy
Commissioner. Those protections for British Columbians to make sure that they're not losing the
right to access to information but actually protecting government workers also from
the reality that sometimes people do put in vexatious requests or do sometimes not
provide enough information on what it is that they're seeking or sometimes do repetitive
requests.... This wouldn't even be the first time that those types of issues are being dealt with,
and that's why this hoist motion, which.... It does essentially kill this bill. It's
not about a delay. If you go into our standing orders, which every member in this House has, and actually
look at what that says.... And I know that my colleague from Penticton had read that
into the record and had spoken about that during her speech. You would see that this
kills it, and honestly, I don't think that that is a justifiable delay for British
Columbians, because I think that we have something workable here with this bill. Getting more understanding on behalf of my constituents that.... Look, nothing is changing.
The Privacy Commissioner still maintains that final say and has so much case law and
so much other jurisprudence surrounding these decisions. It's not an arbitrary decision.
They don't lack definitions. These things are defined, because there have been other
cases before where requests for information have been And those reasons.... If British Columbians want to have a look at what the legislation,
as it stands now, says and even have a look at what Bill 9 is proposing, they're actually
not that dissimilar. There's only a little bit of change in some of the wording. Some
of the wording I actually had some concerns with. During my ability to meet with the
minister and to express those concerns.... I think that there's some really good amendments
that have come forward that can address some of those concerns. I think the ultimate consideration for British Columbians really needs to be that
the oversight and the assurance that British Columbians need to be able to rely on
is the fact that we have the independent office of the Privacy Commissioner, who oversees
access to information, and legislation with respect to privacy is overseen by this
independent officer of British Columbia. That's not going to change. So I don't see any reason for us to kill this bill, which is what the hoist motion
does. I'm not supportive of killing the bill. I also don't see anything within the
legislation that would require us to have six months. I heard my colleague from Cariboo-Chilcotin. He had talked about some very compelling circumstances where people had issues getting
access to information, very important and personal information on issues that obviously
severely impacted them. I think that we need to look at those types of circumstances
and continue to work towards making it so that people can understand what happened
in those types of circumstances. But the changes that I've seen brought forward in Bill 9.... I don't think they're going
to impede people. I don't think that they will stop people from accessing. This isn't,
in my view, the doomsday bill as has been presented by members of the opposition.
This isn't an affront to democracy. It's some legislation that, in my opinion, modernizes
what we've had. I really respect, too, that the member of the Green Party worked on this legislation
decades ago. That is awesome to be able to work with someone with that much knowledge
about freedom of information and protection of privacy in this province. Some of the
pioneering legislation has been made by lots of different, cool people that I've actually
had the opportunity to work with. But sometimes we need to be able to modernize and change. We're in an extremely digital
environment right now. I just don't think, especially as we see AI make such a huge
impact on the province, that we should be delaying legislation that is workable legislation. So I'm not going to be supporting the hoist motion, because I want to be able to see
this go into committee. I think that we'll have the ability to actually.... Instead
of just standing here with dozens of ChatGPT speeches, how about asking some questions
and having them answered, maybe even adding some amendments that could satisfy members
of the opposition or improve, in ways that they might see, this legislation for their
constituents? But I think for me, the key here to why I'm going to not support the hoist and I want
to see this bill continue to progress in the House is that fundamentally, that oversight
on who really is overseeing whether or not a request for information is fulfilled
is with the Privacy Commissioner. Even with these changes, that oversight still remains,
and British Columbians can be assured that this isn't some trickery to somehow protect
people's reputations. If you're entitled to information, I think that it's important that we get it. Especially
if it can be used to.... I don't want to get into the realm of debating the bill, but
I'm one of the first ones who has demanded information from this government and not
gotten it at times and had to work really hard to be able to prove my points of things It was actually with a great deal of skepticism that I looked at this bill. You know,
I have every reason to be skeptical of a government that, in my opinion, hasn't been
as transparent as it should with some really critical files. But when it comes to
the oversight of making sure that people are treated fairly in terms of getting access
to information in this province, that doesn't change. The independent Office of the Privacy Commissioner is overseeing that. There's other
case law to refer to, so I want to see this bill progress. I'm not going to support
the hoist motion. I appreciate this time to speak.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Indigenous governments, Intergovernmental relations
I rise to speak in favour of the motion to not continue with second reading but to
refer Bill 20 to the Select Standing Committee on Aboriginal Affairs. I've put a lot
of thought into what I wanted to talk about, with regard to why I support this motion
and why I think it's important that we do that in this House. My remarks won't be long this afternoon, but I do think that they make important points.
I hope that it resonates with people from my community. I hope that it resonates with
the parties who are seeking to see this treaty ratified but also to those who have
taken issue with the ratification of the treaty. Specifically, I'm talking about the Wei Wai Kum First Nation. I did meet with their Chief Roberts. I did receive correspondence from the First
Nation as well, because they are raising concerns that they have with a dispute over
territory that is being claimed as the territory under the treaty that we are going
to legislate through Bill 20. It's also the traditional territory of the Wei Wai Kum. I'm going to just be really specific. At issue in this K'ómoks treaty, in the opinion of the Wei Wai Kum First Nation, is that it contains portions of land overlapping traditional territory.
The primary concern is that the Wei Wai Kum will be required to seek free, prior and informed consent on what they consider to
be their own territory. It has been expressed to me that this is already causing some disputes with a natural
resources project, a wind farm that is already in discussions and the planning phase.
Because of this dispute over territory, it's actually causing a problem already. There's
no framework in the treaty to resolve the dispute. Furthermore, if we pass this implementation legislation and the treaty is ratified,
First Nations who are in conflict over the territory that is overlapping within the
treaty agreement have already said that they would take immediate court action. I'm
not sure whether or not any other direct action by the First Nation will be taken.
As my friend and colleague the critic for Indigenous Relations had said, there has
been talk about blocking things like infrastructure, blocking railways, blocking highways,
blocking important trade corridors or ports. Nobody wants to see that. I think that is why it's of paramount importance that we support the motion to give
ourselves the opportunity, in this place, to have a better understanding of, first
of all, the process that went into trying to resolve the dispute between these First
Nations. I know that considerable effort was made on behalf of the Crown, on behalf
of First Nations, to resolve the dispute about this territory that's overlapping,
but despite the fact that it has been decades of negotiating this treaty, this still
hasn't been resolved. The point of having a treaty is so that we can have some measure of certainty. I think
that my colleagues in this place have done a good job, on both sides of the floor,
in expressing that certainty is something that we need to have, but passing legislation
that allows for the ratification of a treaty that in itself will become wrapped in
uncertainty because of immediate court action is not creating the certainty that we
would expect from this process. I think one of the other aspects of uncertainty — it's probably a broken record by
now in this place — is DRIPA. Of course, there's uncertainty. It's acknowledged on
both sides, acknowledged on both sides of this chamber, that there are serious legal I think one of the other aspects of uncertainty — it's probably a broken record by
now in this place — is DRIPA.... Of course there's uncertainty. It's acknowledged on
both sides, acknowledged on both sides of this chamber that there are serious legal
liabilities in this province related to DRIPA. When DRIPA was passed in 2019.... I think there have been consequences since then that
were probably not necessarily foreseen, especially the way after the 2021 implementation
of the Interpretation Act, section 8.1, that the courts would interpret DRIPA, taking
the negotiations out of the hands of government and putting those decisions into the
court. This government has said time and again that negotiations are best done nation to
nation, government to government, so that means the Crown at the federal level, that
means the Crown at the provincial level, working directly with First Nations, and
First Nations to First Nations. But if we ratify the treaty before this issue is resolved with the overlap of this
territory, then we're again going to be headed potentially into multi-million-dollar
legal action that will be drawn out for decades, that will have decades of uncertainty
attached to it, that at the end of the day will take that ability for negotiation
away and put it again back into the courts, which is something that this government
is actually trying to avoid. Our Attorney General talks about a durable solution and not wanting to have to see
things decided in the courts, which is the unintended consequence of section 8.1 of
the Interpretation Act. Having the courts decide the Gitxaała decision, making DRIPA the law of the land here so that basically the government's
hands are tied in terms of their ability to negotiate, and those things are dictated
by the courts. I don't think that that is where this government wants to go. They can correct me
if I'm wrong. I think that there is plenty of opportunity for members of the government
to dispute what I am saying, but it has been said over and again that we need certainty.
There is definitely legal liability with DRIPA, which is actually also a significant
part of the K'ómoks treaty. I think that we do not really know yet what the consequence of having that
as part of this treaty also involves.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: Courts, Legal issues
I rise to speak in favour of the motion to not continue with second reading but to
refer Bill 20 to the Select Standing Committee on Aboriginal Affairs. I've put a lot
of thought into what I wanted to talk about, with regard to why I support this motion
and why I think it's important that we do that in this House. My remarks won't be long this afternoon, but I do think that they make important points.
I hope that it resonates with people from my community. I hope that it resonates with
the parties who are seeking to see this treaty ratified but also to those who have
taken issue with the ratification of the treaty. Specifically, I'm talking about the Wei Wai Kum First Nation. I did meet with their Chief Roberts. I did receive correspondence from the First
Nation as well, because they are raising concerns that they have with a dispute over
territory that is being claimed as the territory under the treaty that we are going
to legislate through Bill 20. It's also the traditional territory of the Wei Wai Kum. I'm going to just be really specific. At issue in this K'ómoks treaty, in the opinion of the Wei Wai Kum First Nation, is that it contains portions of land overlapping traditional territory.
The primary concern is that the Wei Wai Kum will be required to seek free, prior and informed consent on what they consider to
be their own territory. It has been expressed to me that this is already causing some disputes with a natural
resources project, a wind farm that is already in discussions and the planning phase.
Because of this dispute over territory, it's actually causing a problem already. There's
no framework in the treaty to resolve the dispute. Furthermore, if we pass this implementation legislation and the treaty is ratified,
First Nations who are in conflict over the territory that is overlapping within the
treaty agreement have already said that they would take immediate court action. I'm
not sure whether or not any other direct action by the First Nation will be taken.
As my friend and colleague the critic for Indigenous Relations had said, there has
been talk about blocking things like infrastructure, blocking railways, blocking highways,
blocking important trade corridors or ports. Nobody wants to see that. I think that is why it's of paramount importance that we support the motion to give
ourselves the opportunity, in this place, to have a better understanding of, first
of all, the process that went into trying to resolve the dispute between these First
Nations. I know that considerable effort was made on behalf of the Crown, on behalf
of First Nations, to resolve the dispute about this territory that's overlapping,
but despite the fact that it has been decades of negotiating this treaty, this still
hasn't been resolved. The point of having a treaty is so that we can have some measure of certainty. I think
that my colleagues in this place have done a good job, on both sides of the floor,
in expressing that certainty is something that we need to have, but passing legislation
that allows for the ratification of a treaty that in itself will become wrapped in
uncertainty because of immediate court action is not creating the certainty that we
would expect from this process. I think one of the other aspects of uncertainty — it's probably a broken record by
now in this place — is DRIPA. Of course, there's uncertainty. It's acknowledged on
both sides, acknowledged on both sides of this chamber, that there are serious legal I think one of the other aspects of uncertainty — it's probably a broken record by
now in this place — is DRIPA.... Of course there's uncertainty. It's acknowledged on
both sides, acknowledged on both sides of this chamber that there are serious legal
liabilities in this province related to DRIPA. When DRIPA was passed in 2019.... I think there have been consequences since then that
were probably not necessarily foreseen, especially the way after the 2021 implementation
of the Interpretation Act, section 8.1, that the courts would interpret DRIPA, taking
the negotiations out of the hands of government and putting those decisions into the
court. This government has said time and again that negotiations are best done nation to
nation, government to government, so that means the Crown at the federal level, that
means the Crown at the provincial level, working directly with First Nations, and
First Nations to First Nations. But if we ratify the treaty before this issue is resolved with the overlap of this
territory, then we're again going to be headed potentially into multi-million-dollar
legal action that will be drawn out for decades, that will have decades of uncertainty
attached to it, that at the end of the day will take that ability for negotiation
away and put it again back into the courts, which is something that this government
is actually trying to avoid. Our Attorney General talks about a durable solution and not wanting to have to see
things decided in the courts, which is the unintended consequence of section 8.1 of
the Interpretation Act. Having the courts decide the Gitxaała decision, making DRIPA the law of the land here so that basically the government's
hands are tied in terms of their ability to negotiate, and those things are dictated
by the courts. I don't think that that is where this government wants to go. They can correct me
if I'm wrong. I think that there is plenty of opportunity for members of the government
to dispute what I am saying, but it has been said over and again that we need certainty.
There is definitely legal liability with DRIPA, which is actually also a significant
part of the K'ómoks treaty. I think that we do not really know yet what the consequence of having that
as part of this treaty also involves.Open source referenceAccepted detailed tags: First Nations, Indigenous affairs
I rise to speak in favour of the motion to not continue with second reading but to
refer Bill 20 to the Select Standing Committee on Aboriginal Affairs. I've put a lot
of thought into what I wanted to talk about, with regard to why I support this motion
and why I think it's important that we do that in this House. My remarks won't be long this afternoon, but I do think that they make important points.
I hope that it resonates with people from my community. I hope that it resonates with
the parties who are seeking to see this treaty ratified but also to those who have
taken issue with the ratification of the treaty. Specifically, I'm talking about the Wei Wai Kum First Nation. I did meet with their Chief Roberts. I did receive correspondence from the First
Nation as well, because they are raising concerns that they have with a dispute over
territory that is being claimed as the territory under the treaty that we are going
to legislate through Bill 20. It's also the traditional territory of the Wei Wai Kum. I'm going to just be really specific. At issue in this K'ómoks treaty, in the opinion of the Wei Wai Kum First Nation, is that it contains portions of land overlapping traditional territory.
The primary concern is that the Wei Wai Kum will be required to seek free, prior and informed consent on what they consider to
be their own territory. It has been expressed to me that this is already causing some disputes with a natural
resources project, a wind farm that is already in discussions and the planning phase.
Because of this dispute over territory, it's actually causing a problem already. There's
no framework in the treaty to resolve the dispute. Furthermore, if we pass this implementation legislation and the treaty is ratified,
First Nations who are in conflict over the territory that is overlapping within the
treaty agreement have already said that they would take immediate court action. I'm
not sure whether or not any other direct action by the First Nation will be taken.
As my friend and colleague the critic for Indigenous Relations had said, there has
been talk about blocking things like infrastructure, blocking railways, blocking highways,
blocking important trade corridors or ports. Nobody wants to see that. I think that is why it's of paramount importance that we support the motion to give
ourselves the opportunity, in this place, to have a better understanding of, first
of all, the process that went into trying to resolve the dispute between these First
Nations. I know that considerable effort was made on behalf of the Crown, on behalf
of First Nations, to resolve the dispute about this territory that's overlapping,
but despite the fact that it has been decades of negotiating this treaty, this still
hasn't been resolved. The point of having a treaty is so that we can have some measure of certainty. I think
that my colleagues in this place have done a good job, on both sides of the floor,
in expressing that certainty is something that we need to have, but passing legislation
that allows for the ratification of a treaty that in itself will become wrapped in
uncertainty because of immediate court action is not creating the certainty that we
would expect from this process. I think one of the other aspects of uncertainty — it's probably a broken record by
now in this place — is DRIPA. Of course, there's uncertainty. It's acknowledged on
both sides, acknowledged on both sides of this chamber, that there are serious legal I think one of the other aspects of uncertainty — it's probably a broken record by
now in this place — is DRIPA.... Of course there's uncertainty. It's acknowledged on
both sides, acknowledged on both sides of this chamber that there are serious legal
liabilities in this province related to DRIPA. When DRIPA was passed in 2019.... I think there have been consequences since then that
were probably not necessarily foreseen, especially the way after the 2021 implementation
of the Interpretation Act, section 8.1, that the courts would interpret DRIPA, taking
the negotiations out of the hands of government and putting those decisions into the
court. This government has said time and again that negotiations are best done nation to
nation, government to government, so that means the Crown at the federal level, that
means the Crown at the provincial level, working directly with First Nations, and
First Nations to First Nations. But if we ratify the treaty before this issue is resolved with the overlap of this
territory, then we're again going to be headed potentially into multi-million-dollar
legal action that will be drawn out for decades, that will have decades of uncertainty
attached to it, that at the end of the day will take that ability for negotiation
away and put it again back into the courts, which is something that this government
is actually trying to avoid. Our Attorney General talks about a durable solution and not wanting to have to see
things decided in the courts, which is the unintended consequence of section 8.1 of
the Interpretation Act. Having the courts decide the Gitxaała decision, making DRIPA the law of the land here so that basically the government's
hands are tied in terms of their ability to negotiate, and those things are dictated
by the courts. I don't think that that is where this government wants to go. They can correct me
if I'm wrong. I think that there is plenty of opportunity for members of the government
to dispute what I am saying, but it has been said over and again that we need certainty.
There is definitely legal liability with DRIPA, which is actually also a significant
part of the K'ómoks treaty. I think that we do not really know yet what the consequence of having that
as part of this treaty also involves.Open source reference