Frank Caputo · 2026-05

229 recorded contributions

Back to media pack

Jev-reviewed existing detailed tags · editorial review required

Governance: 16 contributions
2026-05-05 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Privacy

No, I meant where there is a service of encryption provided. My question was, will that provider of encryption...? Company A provides an end-to-end encryption service in messages. Will this bill require company A to create some sort of mechanism by which that data can be intercepted and by which the government or the state—when I say "state", I think you know what I mean, law enforcement—can access that encrypted data? Is that clear?
Open source reference
2026-05-05 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Privacy

I understand that. I'll tell you where I'm coming from on this. In this instance, the state or the government is compelling an action, and that action relates to information over which there is a reasonable expectation of privacy. That's why you need a warrant. The moment you say to provider A that they need to keep this, there's a reasonable expectation of privacy over what must be kept. Is everybody with me so far? Okay. Does that not engage section 8? I might be out to lunch here, but I've been asked this question, so it's something I'm looking to explore.
Open source reference
2026-05-05 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Privacy

Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to the ministers and officials. I'll note that we have two Kamloopsians at the table today. That's always wonderful. Minister Anandasangaree, you're off the hook today. We won't be asking you about visas and who gave people from the IRGC a visa. We'll stick to Bill C-22 here. I want to go into something you mentioned, Minister. You talked about this being encryption-neutral. One of the greatest concerns I'm hearing about is encryption. Please don't defer to the analysts. I want to hear your perspective on this. This bill could threaten encrypted communications, based on the way it is written or the way some people are reading it. Can you confirm that the purpose of this bill is not to go after end-to-end encryption, as in party A is using a program to deal with party B that is encrypted and there's no way to decrypt it? Can you confirm that this is neither in this bill nor the intent of this bill?
Open source reference
2026-05-05 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Privacy, Regulations

The difference with Bill C-8 , though, Minister.... If you want to get into Bill C-8, that is exactly my cautionary tale. The Liberals voted against just about every amendment that was of consequence. It was the Conservatives and the Bloc that voted for those amendments, that swayed those amendments, with the government often voting against them. Now things have changed. With all due respect, Bill C-8 is not a great example to use. That's why I'm trying to get it on the record. I think I've made my point. You've made your point. Let's move on. The ministerial order is one of the biggest things. One of them, as I said, is encryption; another major issue is the degree to which enforcement and definitions are left to regulation. That's one of the primary criticisms of this bill. I look at proposed section 5, for instance. This is sweeping powers. Proposed paragraph 5(2)(b) says, "the installation, use, operation, management, assessment, testing and maintenance of any device". Proposed paragraph 5(2)(d) says, "the retention of categories of metadata". Minister, I get why the government wants things to be broad; it's because then you can account for things. However, should we not be defining things where we can define them? I'm pretty sure we're going to have experts who say, "Do you know what? We can define categories of metadata." I'm sure we can define categories of metadata. Those don't change every day. Would you be open to an amendment that says that when we're looking at taking information from people over which there's a high expectation of privacy...? I trust you would support an amendment that would define those types of things.
Open source reference
2026-05-07 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Regulations

Right, because in the legislation, part 2 would apply to those who meet the definition of a "core provider", or if I recall correctly, those who are designated by ministerial order. Is that—
Open source reference
2026-05-26 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Privacy

Am I correct in saying then that you, as the Privacy Commissioner, were not consulted on what should be in a bill that touches on so many people's online privacy?
Open source reference
2026-05-26 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Privacy

Yes. I'll intervene just briefly. Given what Mr. Lloyd has reflected on, that his privilege has been breached, and not even as a prima facie breach but as an obvious breach, I would ask, Mr. Chair, if you and the clerk would be able to canvass the Privacy Commissioner's ability to return next week and, in any event, prior to clause-by-clause consideration. I also think the appropriate remedy here is that we do not have amendments close tomorrow. I think it's very obvious that this is the only remedy in what is already a very rushed process. I think this is symptomatic of the fact that we have been moving very quickly. I do not place any blame on the clerk. These things happen. Mistakes happen. We've had four-hour meetings. We're in the midst of another four-hour meeting. I won't say any more. Thank you.
Open source reference
2026-05-26 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Investigations

Thank you. Happy birthday, Mayor. It's nice to make your acquaintance over Zoom. It's nice to see you again, Commissioner Carrique. I've had the pleasure of meeting you many times. It's nice to see you, Mr. Van Laer. Mr. Van Laer and I worked together on investigations relating to child sexual abuse and exploitation material. One of the reasons that I invited him here and wanted to hear from him is that we haven't heard from anybody yet who has told us what it's like to kick down a door or what metadata you look for when you're doing child sexual abuse investigations. Mr. Van Laer, I'm going to focus my questions on you for the time being. This bill focuses on metadata. Are you familiar with metadata in the context of child sexual abuse material cases and Internet luring cases? I assume you're aware of metadata and how it all works.
Open source reference
2026-05-26 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Investigations

Can you give a timeline? Based on your experience, is there a number you can assign to say, "Look, right now, electronic service providers keep this data for 90 days, and that frequently shuts us out of our investigations"?
Open source reference
2026-05-27 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: National security

Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister called Beijing Canada's greatest security threat. That was during the election. Despite this, within a year, he signed a memorandum of understanding with Communist China as it relates to security matters. I have been asking for that memorandum of understanding for over five months. The minister and the Prime Minister have refused to disclose it.

When will they produce the memorandum of understanding that was signed with Communist China?
Open source reference
2026-05-27 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: External relations, Foreign interference, National security

Mr. Speaker, if the minister wants to talk about history, let us talk about history. When in the past did a Prime Minister call Beijing Canada's greatest security threat, and then within a year sign a memorandum of understanding? Never before had we heard stories of foreign interference to the same degree. Never before had a Prime Minister said exactly what he said.

Why is he unprepared to shine the light? The Liberals do not want to shine the light and they do not want to inform Canadians. Will they do it today, yes or no?
Open source reference
2026-05-28 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: Crisis

Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.

 I listened to a question just a little while ago. Before I begin, I will try a bit of French here.

I thank my colleague for his speech.

I want to ask my hon. colleague from the Bloc a question. One question that is really central to what we are dealing with is tax and Canadians' being bitten, so to speak, by death by a thousand financial cuts. If we were to listen to the member from Winnipeg, Canadians have never had it so good because the Liberals gave a tax cut to 22 million people. Unfortunately, people are still lining up at food banks in record numbers. They cannot pay their mortgages, cannot pay their rent and cannot afford a seven-dollar head of lettuce. Unfortunately, that does not get into the rhetoric.

I wonder whether my hon. colleague agrees that we need to lower the cost of living, whether we are talking about digital streaming taxes or inflationary spending when it comes to the government. Does he not agree that we need to address what has become a cost of living crisis in this country?
Open source reference
2026-05-28 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Foreign interference

Did we have a foreign interference inquiry under Stephen Harper? No. I'll answer that for you. Transparency demands that this be released. People in the House—let me be clear—people in this chamber potentially lost their seats because of foreign interference. Your Prime Minister , who appointed you and whom you answer to, said that this is the greatest "security threat", and within less than a year he signs a secret memorandum of understanding with the very nation that he said was the greatest threat to Canada. Then you come in here, and you won't even tell us—you will not give a clear answer—as to whether they have to sign off. I don't care about Canada.... If it's only about Canada, that's even worse, because then you're not providing the transparency your government has promised. What is it, Minister?
Open source reference
2026-05-28 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Privacy

Okay. I'm sorry; I was thinking about something else. I'll move on from that. What I'd really like to know about is end-to-end encryption. We all know what that means. A number of companies use encrypted technology. Let's say it's Apple Health or something like that. We could agree that's very personal information that would be contained on your smart phone about your health. I don't think anybody's going to dispute that. It attracts a high expectation of privacy. Let's say that's encrypted. That's different from end-to-end encryption. A company like Signal offers a service that goes from one end to another and nobody can break it. That's end-to-end encryption. What about when data is encrypted as part of the program? If Apple has the key to that encryption, would they not be required to track that data as part of this bill?
Open source reference
2026-05-28 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Privacy

My point though, sir, is this: It could happen. What I'm getting at is that information that is meant to be encrypted and is itself encrypted could be compromised beyond end-to-end encryption. We're not just talking about end-to-end encryption because we were told that would introduce a systemic vulnerability if somebody had to disrupt that. I'm talking about data that is encrypted, but there is nonetheless a road map to it in the provider. What I'm saying and what you're telling me that's of concern is that encryption that is not end-to-end that is provided by the service provider could then be subject to this bill. Do you get where I'm going with this?
Open source reference
2026-05-28 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Regulations

I'm aware of that, but that's precisely my point. We around this table don't know what that's going to look like. I get that's how regulation works, but the uncertainty.... Again, we come back to that word "uncertainty", because it's for up to a year. We don't know what type of metadata is going to take priority. We don't know whether location services are going to be there for up to a year. A year is a long time. I understand that the argument has been made that we need this, but no one has asked, "Why a year?" That's another point. We have asked about industry standards. Australia has two years. Sweden has 10 months. There are also nuances there, but there's that uncertainty again. Another reason for uncertainty is in proposed section 14, and that is the duty to assist. If I was a business owner, I think that I could rightfully fear this. Does proposed section 14 not conceivably require an electronic service provider to create hardware or software to bring it up to government standards, so to speak, so that the data can be retained? I hope that question is clear.
Open source reference
Public Safety & Justice: 10 contributions
2026-05-06 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: Correctional institutions

Mr. Speaker, I have a surprising project to tell members about. Imagine this: no fences, beautiful townhouse-style living, tennis courts, and fishing in the Rideau River over the summertime. No, I am not talking about a new housing project. I am talking about a jail, a penitentiary in fact, that houses notorious sex offender and child killer Darren Scott Ray. That is right. This person was considered so dangerous that police had to follow him around everywhere he went when he was released for just 72 hours, yet he lives in a jail without fences and with a little slice of paradise, having comforts like a tennis court, a beautiful kitchen and all the freedom in the world.

The Liberals bungled this with Bill C-83 and their "least restrictive" measure. Why is it that somebody who is a child-killing sex offender who needs to be supervised every single minute can live in a place without fences?
Open source reference
2026-05-06 · JUST

Accepted detailed tags: Courts, Criminal code

The Supreme Court of Canada is the highest court in the land, as we all know, and it has taken a living tree approach to all sorts of law. In fact, in the Rodriguez decision—if memory serves, it was in 1993—the judges said there was "no constitutional right" to die, as in there was no constitutional right to kill oneself through what we then called euthanasia. Carter came along in 2015. That was a mere 22 years later. That's not very long in the life of the law. Carter came to a completely different conclusion after just 22 years. There was no new statutory law that Carter was based on. Carter wasn't interpreting a different provision of the Criminal Code or of some other federal legislation. Carter was an application that said they wished to engage in what was rebranded as medical assistance in dying, just as Rodriguez was seeking, I believe, to strike down the Criminal Code prohibition on euthanasia. They were both asking the exact same question and the court came to very different conclusions only 22 years later, when the body of law—that which was being considered—was largely the same. I don't think I'm going out on a limb here. The point I am trying to make is that "grossly disproportionate" is what the court is saying today. Do you have any idea about what the court will say tomorrow?
Open source reference
2026-05-06 · JUST

Accepted detailed tags: Justice system

That's a really interesting one. I'm going to talk for a second here on outraging society and decency, because in the Senneville case, in the court's eyes, to impose a one-year mandatory minimum would outrage the sense of decency in society. That was the court's decision, whereas I think a lot of Canadians here...and I'm not assailing the court's decision. I'm speaking about what I think, what I hear from constituents, which is that the striking down of that actually outraged a number of Canadians and their standards of decency. One of the interesting things we have to look at is what is in Bill C-16 and what isn't in Bill C-16. I spent far too long dealing with sexual offences against children. One of the highlights in coming to Parliament Hill was meeting Justice Moldaver, who, for those who don't know, was on the Supreme Court of Canada until, I guess, roughly 2020, and maybe 2022 or something like that, and somebody here probably knows better. I met him and I referenced the Woodward decision on Internet luring. I could talk about this for hours.
Open source reference
2026-05-07 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Legal issues

As I understand it, if such an order were made, that order would not "possibly" be secret but would be secret, in which case a whistle-blower couldn't necessarily come forward. I guess the only recourse there for the company that's doing that would be to apply for judicial review. Is that accurate?
Open source reference
2026-05-07 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Computer crime

Thank you very much, Professor Geist. I apologize. I want to exercise my prerogative as the chair, because there's one thing I think we're going to hear about in the next round that I think is very important. I'll ask you for a very brief, 15-second response. You mentioned that 30 days for metadata would be appropriate. Oftentimes, there's not even an investigator assigned to an Internet luring case in 30 days. Bearing that in mind, what would you think about 90 days, given those types of crimes, to address those types of crimes or the metadata that would allow us to address those types of crimes?
Open source reference
2026-05-26 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Sexual offences

Thank you. Happy birthday, Mayor. It's nice to make your acquaintance over Zoom. It's nice to see you again, Commissioner Carrique. I've had the pleasure of meeting you many times. It's nice to see you, Mr. Van Laer. Mr. Van Laer and I worked together on investigations relating to child sexual abuse and exploitation material. One of the reasons that I invited him here and wanted to hear from him is that we haven't heard from anybody yet who has told us what it's like to kick down a door or what metadata you look for when you're doing child sexual abuse investigations. Mr. Van Laer, I'm going to focus my questions on you for the time being. This bill focuses on metadata. Are you familiar with metadata in the context of child sexual abuse material cases and Internet luring cases? I assume you're aware of metadata and how it all works.
Open source reference
2026-05-26 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Justice system

Okay. Commissioner Carrique, you have spoken at length, and very passionately, about the necessity for this bill. As somebody who comes from a prosecutorial background, I understand that. I think one of the main things I'd like to ask you about...and Mayor Brown is free to weigh in on this as well. This is important legislation, but it's equally important that we get it right—for instance, on the "reasonable grounds to suspect" versus the "reasonable grounds to believe". Would you support the fact that this is complicated stuff? We can't even agree on a number, for instance, for retaining metadata. At some point, we have to delve into this and get it absolutely right. I don't think there's much room for error here. I feel that the process has been rushed on this. Mayor Brown used the word "dither". In my life, I have looked at the ceiling at night in investigations where we could not put the person behind the computer. It sucks. At the same time, we as parliamentarians have to make sure we get it right. What do the two of you say to that?
Open source reference
2026-05-27 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Justice system

Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. I want to thank all of the witnesses. Deputy Chief Milinovich, I took heed of what you said. My colleague Ms. Acan asked you a question and you said that it was going to take a lot longer than six minutes, and I understand why. This isn't easy stuff. This is complex stuff: how metadata leads to an offender, how a production order is authorized.... I mean, we haven't even gotten into that. I don't think that even once we've talked about the test for getting a production order. I think Mr. Van Laer did very briefly last time, but we haven't even talked about that here. That's part of the point I've been making. I know that my Liberal colleagues may think I'm a broken record, but the reality is that this is not easy stuff. This is where we have had lawyers come in here and disagree: knowledgeable lawyers, people who have practised law for a great deal of time. I would love to hear more from you. I know that extortion is a huge issue in your area. You and I spoke—I believe it was just last month—and I really appreciate your passion for trying to bring safe streets to the Peel region. I echo that. The thing that stands out for me—and this goes for all of our witnesses here—is that we all want safe streets. We all want to put bad people in jail. We all want people who hurt kids to go to jail and—I can say on this end—for a very long time. I would hope that my Liberal colleagues would join that, yet here we are, on the precipice of having to deal with a bill that has huge ramifications and huge implications. I'm going to ask you just one brief question, Mr. Rankin. Was there one recommendation that you really hoped would have made it in here and didn't?
Open source reference
2026-05-27 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Justice system

I am still processing what is in this bill. As a result, in order to fulfill our obligation as His Majesty's loyal opposition, we should have the right to hear from officials fulsomely before we have to submit amendments. Otherwise, we are essentially going to a glorified clause-by-clause because, in that case, we're going to hear from officials after amendments are in, which we would normally do in a clause-by-clause setting anyway. We're almost postponing the unavoidable. We're not really following a proper process in that. I reiterate that there has been substantial questioning on this bill, and dare I say, from some people, substantial opposition. We heard today that a lot of people are really in favour of this bill. We have a group that is quite in favour of the bill. We have a group that is quite opposed to the bill. Our job is to try to find some middle ground that puts bad people behind bars and ensures that privacy and charter rights are protected. I think everybody around this table would want to see that. How do we do that when we have amendments that are due before we hear from officials? To me, it is eminently reasonable that we would hear from officials before amendments. I don't understand why we wouldn't do it. For instance, let's look at part 1, "reasonable grounds to suspect" versus "reasonable grounds to believe". We heard about the lower threshold from Commissioner Carrique. The only time we actually talked about reasonable grounds to suspect versus reasonable grounds to believe was when I asked the question. My recollection of reasonable grounds to believe is that a peace officer personally or subjectively believes that an offence has been committed—not suspects—and that the belief is objectively reasonable. That is reasonable grounds to believe, or it was five years ago when I was still practising law.
Open source reference
2026-05-28 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Public safety

Thank you, Mr. Chair. Welcome, Minister. Thank you to all of the witnesses. Through the chair, I will be directing all of my questions to the Minister of Public Safety. Thank you for appearing. Minister, will you extend the study on Bill C-22 , yes or no?
Open source reference
Science & Technology: 7 contributions
2026-05-05 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Cryptography

No, I meant where there is a service of encryption provided. My question was, will that provider of encryption...? Company A provides an end-to-end encryption service in messages. Will this bill require company A to create some sort of mechanism by which that data can be intercepted and by which the government or the state—when I say "state", I think you know what I mean, law enforcement—can access that encrypted data? Is that clear?
Open source reference
2026-05-05 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Cryptography

What I'm talking about is a company whose "secret sauce", if you'll forgive my vernacular, is providing an encryption service. That is what it does. Company A provides a service that says terminal one to terminal two or contact one to contact two will be encrypted. That is its business model. What I'm asking is this: Will Bill C-22 require it to be able to plug into that encryption and decrypt it for law enforcement?
Open source reference
2026-05-05 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Computer security

That is exactly what I was looking for, but based on my reading of the bill, when I went through the one definition and then into systemic vulnerability, that wasn't clear to me. My exhortation is this: As officials, please turn your minds to this, because I think there should be, one, an encrypted data definition and, two, something that very clearly says what you just said—that a decryption of encrypted data is a systemic vulnerability—or put it right in the definition of systemic vulnerability. I know this is technical. I hope I'm being clear here.
Open source reference
2026-05-05 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Cryptography

Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you to the ministers and officials. I'll note that we have two Kamloopsians at the table today. That's always wonderful. Minister Anandasangaree, you're off the hook today. We won't be asking you about visas and who gave people from the IRGC a visa. We'll stick to Bill C-22 here. I want to go into something you mentioned, Minister. You talked about this being encryption-neutral. One of the greatest concerns I'm hearing about is encryption. Please don't defer to the analysts. I want to hear your perspective on this. This bill could threaten encrypted communications, based on the way it is written or the way some people are reading it. Can you confirm that the purpose of this bill is not to go after end-to-end encryption, as in party A is using a program to deal with party B that is encrypted and there's no way to decrypt it? Can you confirm that this is neither in this bill nor the intent of this bill?
Open source reference
2026-05-05 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Information

The difference with Bill C-8 , though, Minister.... If you want to get into Bill C-8, that is exactly my cautionary tale. The Liberals voted against just about every amendment that was of consequence. It was the Conservatives and the Bloc that voted for those amendments, that swayed those amendments, with the government often voting against them. Now things have changed. With all due respect, Bill C-8 is not a great example to use. That's why I'm trying to get it on the record. I think I've made my point. You've made your point. Let's move on. The ministerial order is one of the biggest things. One of them, as I said, is encryption; another major issue is the degree to which enforcement and definitions are left to regulation. That's one of the primary criticisms of this bill. I look at proposed section 5, for instance. This is sweeping powers. Proposed paragraph 5(2)(b) says, "the installation, use, operation, management, assessment, testing and maintenance of any device". Proposed paragraph 5(2)(d) says, "the retention of categories of metadata". Minister, I get why the government wants things to be broad; it's because then you can account for things. However, should we not be defining things where we can define them? I'm pretty sure we're going to have experts who say, "Do you know what? We can define categories of metadata." I'm sure we can define categories of metadata. Those don't change every day. Would you be open to an amendment that says that when we're looking at taking information from people over which there's a high expectation of privacy...? I trust you would support an amendment that would define those types of things.
Open source reference
2026-05-26 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Cryptography

Yes, I think that this bill is actually much more technical than Bill C-8 because, with Bill C-8, we could understand what different components meant. I think we'll have a witness in the next round who actually talks about what metadata is. We actually haven't gotten into the technical aspects of this. We have largely heard from people like you—people from Google, people from Apple—about their concerns, but we haven't even had time to delve into the technical aspects as to what this encryption means. Is that with respect to all aspects? Is it end-to-end encryption? I'm not an expert on these things, and we haven't heard about that data or about that analysis from experts. I'm quite concerned. Mr. Neuenschwander and Ms. Patell, you can weigh in on this. The minister was equivocal when I asked about encryption. Even though we as Conservatives will be putting forward amendments that will clearly say that encryption will be offside when this bill is studied clause by clause, are you still concerned with respect to this bill touching encrypted technology?
Open source reference
2026-05-28 · SECU

Accepted detailed tags: Cryptography

Okay. I'm sorry; I was thinking about something else. I'll move on from that. What I'd really like to know about is end-to-end encryption. We all know what that means. A number of companies use encrypted technology. Let's say it's Apple Health or something like that. We could agree that's very personal information that would be contained on your smart phone about your health. I don't think anybody's going to dispute that. It attracts a high expectation of privacy. Let's say that's encrypted. That's different from end-to-end encryption. A company like Signal offers a service that goes from one end to another and nobody can break it. That's end-to-end encryption. What about when data is encrypted as part of the program? If Apple has the key to that encryption, would they not be required to track that data as part of this bill?
Open source reference
Economy & Employment: 2 contributions
2026-05-28 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: Trade negotiations

Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola. What I appreciate about this member is not what he says, but with how much volume he says it. I just do not know. We heard 20 minutes of ranting, raving and nothingness, but one of the things that really caught my ear is when he talked about trade and how they are going to get the best deal. 

The government has not been to the negotiating table since October. The reason it has not been to the negotiating table since October is that it is scared of losing another MP or two and having to go to an election when times look good. The Liberals do not want to deal with the United States so that they can run against him rather than run on their disastrous record. Shame on that member. Shame on the government for not going to bat for Canadians. We need a deal. They are not trying to get one. He should be ashamed for that rhetoric in the House.
Open source reference
2026-05-28 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: Economic issues

Madam Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people of Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.

 I listened to a question just a little while ago. Before I begin, I will try a bit of French here.

I thank my colleague for his speech.

I want to ask my hon. colleague from the Bloc a question. One question that is really central to what we are dealing with is tax and Canadians' being bitten, so to speak, by death by a thousand financial cuts. If we were to listen to the member from Winnipeg, Canadians have never had it so good because the Liberals gave a tax cut to 22 million people. Unfortunately, people are still lining up at food banks in record numbers. They cannot pay their mortgages, cannot pay their rent and cannot afford a seven-dollar head of lettuce. Unfortunately, that does not get into the rhetoric.

I wonder whether my hon. colleague agrees that we need to lower the cost of living, whether we are talking about digital streaming taxes or inflationary spending when it comes to the government. Does he not agree that we need to address what has become a cost of living crisis in this country?
Open source reference
Health: 2 contributions
2026-05-06 · JUST

Accepted detailed tags: Euthanasia

The Supreme Court of Canada is the highest court in the land, as we all know, and it has taken a living tree approach to all sorts of law. In fact, in the Rodriguez decision—if memory serves, it was in 1993—the judges said there was "no constitutional right" to die, as in there was no constitutional right to kill oneself through what we then called euthanasia. Carter came along in 2015. That was a mere 22 years later. That's not very long in the life of the law. Carter came to a completely different conclusion after just 22 years. There was no new statutory law that Carter was based on. Carter wasn't interpreting a different provision of the Criminal Code or of some other federal legislation. Carter was an application that said they wished to engage in what was rebranded as medical assistance in dying, just as Rodriguez was seeking, I believe, to strike down the Criminal Code prohibition on euthanasia. They were both asking the exact same question and the court came to very different conclusions only 22 years later, when the body of law—that which was being considered—was largely the same. I don't think I'm going out on a limb here. The point I am trying to make is that "grossly disproportionate" is what the court is saying today. Do you have any idea about what the court will say tomorrow?
Open source reference
2026-05-28 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: Infectious diseases, Vaccines

Madam Speaker, the second petition, which 51 signatories have signed, notes that Canadians travel worldwide for all sorts of reasons, that viruses such as measles are significantly increasing, that when people return home they are often subject to diseases we do not experience here, and that people do not know about travel health advice being available.

Petitioners therefore call upon the House of Commons to integrate travel vaccine, medicine and health education into the public health system in Canada, to establish a reasonable user fee, to ensure appropriate health data collection and to recognize that public trust can be built in travel medicine and screening.
Open source reference
Community Life: 1 contributions
2026-05-28 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: International travel

Madam Speaker, the second petition, which 51 signatories have signed, notes that Canadians travel worldwide for all sorts of reasons, that viruses such as measles are significantly increasing, that when people return home they are often subject to diseases we do not experience here, and that people do not know about travel health advice being available.

Petitioners therefore call upon the House of Commons to integrate travel vaccine, medicine and health education into the public health system in Canada, to establish a reasonable user fee, to ensure appropriate health data collection and to recognize that public trust can be built in travel medicine and screening.
Open source reference
Housing & Development: 1 contributions
2026-05-07 · Hansard

Accepted detailed tags: Mortgage loans

Mr. Speaker, it is always a pleasure to rise on behalf of the people from Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola.

I have to say I am quite disappointed in the government's response. In fact, I think it is going to have to resile from this response at some point. When I heard the minister say this was just fearmongering, to me, that was completely unbecoming. Is it fearmongering when somebody goes to renew their mortgage and they have to get a higher interest rate because the market is saying that their house is no longer worth the same amount? Crickets. Is it fearmongering when somebody cannot get insurance at the same rate? That has nothing to do with what is being said on this side of the House. It has to do with, really, what is happening on the ground. 

The only reason that the government is dealing with this is because it has been hearing about it. The government is hearing about it because of the reasons I just said.

Does the hon. member not agree?
Open source reference
Defence & Foreign Affairs: 0 contributions
Education: 0 contributions
Environment & Resources: 0 contributions
Public Finance: 0 contributions
Rights & Inclusion: 0 contributions
Social Services: 0 contributions
Transportation: 0 contributions